I've had to open a dispute with PayPal today against these guys for the first time in years of using them.
Download code came through and it's already been redeemed. CDKeys refuse to help me further saying it's a new key and that they are not replaceable.
Really peed off about it! Surely they can contact Microsoft and trace who used the key, see where they live and see the IP address compared to mine?!
My questions is, are PayPal likely to side with them, or me?