Hooked on hotukdeals|Join HUKD!

Western Digital 2TB Caviar Green Hard Disk Drive - WD20EARX - £74.99 @ Amazon.co.uk

JustLikeArkwrightJustLikeArkwright

First time under £75 in almost a year @ Amazon.

My now preferred alternative to the Samsung/Seagate HD204UI, especially as it has that extra year of warranty.

TIP: Get the Best Deals In Your Inbox

or
211° Hot Cold

All Comments (24)

Jump to unread Post a Comment
1
    kilasuit
    Also @ ebuyer too Ebuyer Link
    speedking
    How are these drives in a NAS environment? I am wanting to use them with a Synology box to be left running 24/7 and called upon medium/heavy usage in evenings and weekends for serving up music and video content and backing up data. My preferred WD Red drives never seem to be in stock so am forced to look elsewhere.

    Any help is greatly appreciated as am clueless on what 2/3TB drive to use in RAID 1 with my dual drive Synology NAS.
    andy_d90
    speedking
    How are these drives in a NAS environment? I am wanting to use them with a Synology box to be left running 24/7 and called upon medium/heavy usage in evenings and weekends for serving up music and video content and backing up data. My preferred WD Red drives never seem to be in stock so am forced to look elsewhere.

    Any help is greatly appreciated as am clueless on what 2/3TB drive to use in RAID 1 with my dual drive Synology NAS.


    While these are excellent drives, I have indeed heard a few negative comments regarding using them in nas boxes.

    I went for two 2tb samsungs instead.
    JustLikeArkwright
    kilasuit
    Also @ ebuyer too Ebuyer Link


    Yep, so if you use TCB or Quidco you get about a quid back.
    darrenanderson1984
    My Samsung HD204UI just packed it in after 5 months. Luckily managed to get the data off of it. Got one of these from Scan for £73.96 because of free delivery from Hexus forums.

    The Acronis software that you can download after purchasing this is really good for cloning a failing drive.

    I really do wish that hard drives were more reliable. They just get cheaper and cheaper instead of better and better. Finger out please manufacturers.
    veedubjai
    Delivers from and sold by Amazon.co.uk in certified Frustration-Free Packaging. Hmmm...Never had them delivered like that but questionable on how will they deliver them, in big boxes & not enough protection.
    ka2
    ka27 months, 1 week ago #7Show comment toolsReply
    extra warranty year?
    wd has 2 years warranty..amazon says 3 but why?
    seagate also has 2 on some drives.
    buybuybuy
    Been ruunung a pair of these Raid 1 in a Netgear Duo Nas 24/7 but lightish use for 7 months, no problems yet (fingers crossed).
    mtothaj
    These are droping in price nicely - good find.
    das1969
    These drives are currently £71.99 (as on AM 09/10/2012) on the "today only" page for scan.co.uk, for those who get free delivery from Scan and want to save a little bit more.

    http://www.scan.co.uk/todayonly/index.aspx
    thingswelike
    darrenanderson1984

    I really do wish that hard drives were more reliable. They just get cheaper and cheaper instead of better and better. Finger out please manufacturers.

    All these manufacturers create drives which are more reliable. You don't have buy the cheapest!
    For example, some manufacturers call them 'enterprise', some specify that they are suitable for 24/7 use etc.

    For an example, look into the Seagate ST32000645NS.
    Reser
    JustLikeArkwright
    First time under £75 in almost a year @ Amazon.My now preferred alternative to the Samsung/Seagate HD204UI, especially as it has that extra year of warranty.


    Sorry what?

    Are you idiots still under the assumption Western Digital has a longer warranty?

    http://technewspedia.com/seagate-increases-the-warranty-period-of-your-hard-drives/

    Seagate now has 2-3 year Warrentys. I just bought 1 x 3TB and 2 x 2 TB Seagate drives and all of them have over 2 years worth of warrenty, expiring Novemember 2014.

    Western Digital has 2 year warrentys now, Seagate also has 2 year warrentys, Neither has a better warranty period.

    2TB Segate - £67 - 2 Year Warrenty, much better deal.

    This deal is cold.



    Edited By: Reser on Oct 09, 2012 12:28
    Verbal Kint
    So much emphasis in the buying considerations over warranty periods.

    1 year, 2 years, Lifetime warranties? None of which are a scrap of use when you've lost your data. It's reliability we need for our precious 0's and 1's not a warranty.
    DAZZ2000
    Reser
    JustLikeArkwright
    First time under £75 in almost a year @ Amazon.My now preferred alternative to the Samsung/Seagate HD204UI, especially as it has that extra year of warranty.


    Sorry what?

    Are you idiots still under the assumption Western Digital has a longer warranty?

    http://technewspedia.com/seagate-increases-the-warranty-period-of-your-hard-drives/

    Seagate now has 2-3 year Warrentys. I just bought 1 x 3TB and 2 x 2 TB Seagate drives and all of them have over 2 years worth of warrenty, expiring Novemember 2014.

    Western Digital has 2 year warrentys now, Seagate also has 2 year warrentys, Neither has a better warranty period.

    2TB Segate - £67 - 2 Year Warrenty, much better deal.

    This deal is cold.




    Please don't breed, troll.
    zx9r11
    speedking
    How are these drives in a NAS environment? I am wanting to use them with a Synology box to be left running 24/7 and called upon medium/heavy usage in evenings and weekends for serving up music and video content and backing up data. My preferred WD Red drives never seem to be in stock so am forced to look elsewhere. Any help is greatly appreciated as am clueless on what 2/3TB drive to use in RAID 1 with my dual drive Synology NAS.


    Possibly the 2tb version of This

    Edited By: zx9r11 on Oct 09, 2012 14:21: spelling
    thekanester
    DAZZ2000
    Reser
    JustLikeArkwright
    First time under £75 in almost a year @ Amazon.My now preferred alternative to the Samsung/Seagate HD204UI, especially as it has that extra year of warranty.


    Sorry what?

    Are you idiots still under the assumption Western Digital has a longer warranty?

    http://technewspedia.com/seagate-increases-the-warranty-period-of-your-hard-drives/

    Seagate now has 2-3 year Warrentys. I just bought 1 x 3TB and 2 x 2 TB Seagate drives and all of them have over 2 years worth of warrenty, expiring Novemember 2014.

    Western Digital has 2 year warrentys now, Seagate also has 2 year warrentys, Neither has a better warranty period.

    2TB Segate - £67 - 2 Year Warrenty, much better deal.

    This deal is cold.




    Please don't breed, troll.


    Learning to spell wouldn't be a bad idea either... that was on his original quote, not yours btw.


    Edited By: thekanester on Oct 09, 2012 13:20
    jacksonliam
    I have the 1.5TB version of this, while its been quick enough, reliable, quiet and cool it does take a while to spin up (a few secs).

    Edited By: jacksonliam on Oct 09, 2012 13:23
    JustLikeArkwright
    thekanester
    DAZZ2000
    Reser
    JustLikeArkwright
    First time under £75 in almost a year @ Amazon.My now preferred alternative to the Samsung/Seagate HD204UI, especially as it has that extra year of warranty.


    Sorry what?

    Are you idiots still under the assumption Western Digital has a longer warranty?

    http://technewspedia.com/seagate-increases-the-warranty-period-of-your-hard-drives/

    Seagate now has 2-3 year Warrentys. I just bought 1 x 3TB and 2 x 2 TB Seagate drives and all of them have over 2 years worth of warrenty, expiring Novemember 2014.

    Western Digital has 2 year warrentys now, Seagate also has 2 year warrentys, Neither has a better warranty period.

    2TB Segate - £67 - 2 Year Warrenty, much better deal.

    This deal is cold.




    Please don't breed, troll.


    Learning to spell wouldn't be a bad idea either... that was on his original quote, not yours btw.



    Since I was specifically referring to the HD204UI which was many people's drive of choice prior to the Seagate's purchase of the Samsung HDD division, I'm not sure why our "friend" was getting so excited. As the warranty went from three years to one that became an important buying consideration, especially during the price highs as a result of the Thai floods. As prices are now steadily dropping and the HD204UI is being phased out it's worth checking out what is available. If you like WD then this is a decent deal.

    Of course if you are not backing up a warranty of any length is somewhat moot.
    jsw72
    Agree with the sentiments above about the importance of reliability over warranty length and the tendancy is to assume manufacturer's provide longer warranties on more reliable drives but this might not always be the case. Besides when your drive fails with 2000Gb of downloaded films on, would you send it off for a refund?
    JustLikeArkwright
    jsw72
    Agree with the sentiments above about the importance of reliability over warranty length and the tendancy is to assume manufacturer's provide longer warranties on more reliable drives but this might not always be the case. Besides when your drive fails with 2000Gb of downloaded films on, would you send it off for a refund?


    I would still choose WD over Seagate in both cases. As for your theoretical question, well it depends on the level of 'fail', I don't know what the stats are on drives that completely stop working with little or no warning. I'd suggest in most instances there is an indication, at least for the technically minded, that something is up, meaning the said files can be move/erased prior to being RMA'd.

Post a Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.

I Approve
Your Comments On This Post
Comment Preview
Close

PRIVATE MESSAGE

Close
Sorry, you can’t currently send PMs. Once you’re a more active member of the forum, the PM service will be unlocked for you.
Welcome to HUKD!
Close
Join the Community