Can you get rid of negative feedback? - HotUKDeals
We use cookie files to improve site functionality and personalisation. By continuing to use HUKD, you accept our cookie and privacy policy.
Get the HUKD app free at Google Play

Search Error

An error occurred when searching, please try again!

Login / Sign UpSubmit

All Comments

(21) Jump to unreadPost a comment
Comments/page:
#1
looks a little unfair contact the mod involved

tbh it makes no difference to people wanting to trade with you, they can see the thread in question
#2
I don't think the feedback is unfair, unless i'm mistaken you was still haggling on the morning of you prom (Fri 26th June?)

I told him via pm


That's why everything needs to be done on the thread
#3
RedIron
I don't think the feedback is unfair, unless i'm mistaken you was still haggling on the morning of you prom (Fri 26th June?)



That's why everything needs to be done on the thread


Agreed, I would say you are at fault in this matter and not the seller. Ok so you told him by PM that you needed it by a certain date but why were you still haggling over £1 on a DVD 2 days before you needed it.

Actually looking at this you said on the 28th of june that you wore a kilt to your prom that friday which would make Friday the 26th. So how did you expect to get this when you were haggling over the inbetweeners and Transformers @ 20.21 on the Thursday Night (25th), what kind of Postal service do you think he was gonna use "SAME DAY" even 1st class recorded isnt a garuanteed next days service.
#4
Feedback looks fairly honest to me.
1 Like #5
i dont see any confirmation of acceptance of any deal.......no trade took place

if i enquire about something then change my mind i dont expect negative feedback especially not in a day or so
#6
casparwhite;5724675
i dont see any confirmation of acceptance of any deal.......no trade took place

if i enquire about something then change my mind i dont expect negative feedback especially not in a day or so


£60 1st class rec.


Hi there Ross yeah it's still for sale and i'd gladly accept the £60 first class recorded.


That looks like an acceptance to me, the rest was trying to add things to it.

Also don't forget some things had been done through PM so not everything is on the thread.

And the Neg was left on the 3rd of July, a week after the prom rather than within "a day or so"
#7
Offer > £60 1st class rec.
Acceptance > Hi there Ross yeah it's still for sale and i'd gladly accept the £60 first class recorded.

Whats not to see? The OP then went on to start asking about buying unrelated items.
#8
casparwhite;5724675
i dont see any confirmation of acceptance of any deal.......no trade took place

if i enquire about something then change my mind i dont expect negative feedback especially not in a day or so

+1
#9
Wheres Sassie when you need her :lol:
#10
guv
Which suggests it wasn't a done deal!


He messed the guy about, The seller SHANDO was goin to take it at £57 when he came in with an offer of £60 that was accepted then delayed the posting of the item by haggling over DVDs and when he knew it was to late to get it posted to him didnt let the seller know until the sunday, 2 days after his night out so do you not think that deserves some Neg feedback.
banned#11
guv;5724867
Which suggests it wasn't a done deal!


I agree. There was an offer however I deem this offer to have then lapsed as rossg91 had to ask if the item was still for sale the following day.

MisterMarston then offers it to rossg91 but a counter offer by rossg91 is refused.

As there is no clear deal being agreed, Feedback cannot be left.


milewide;5724928
He messed the guy about, The seller SHANDO was goin to take it at £57 when he came in with an offer of £60 that was accepted then delayed the posting of the item by haggling over DVDs and when he knew it was to late to get it posted to him didnt let the seller know until the sunday, 2 days after his night out so do you not think that deserves some Neg feedback.


Feedback is still not applicable, however it would not be unreasonable to assume that rossg91 has been a timewaster/thread spoiler with the later postings as it's obvious a deal could never have been completed to his satisfaction.
#12
In that case there are loads of members with similar feedbacks for example, from the 1st page on the FS FT forum;

http://www.hotukdeals.com/forum-feedback?user_id=129399
#13
RedIron
In that case there are loads of members with similar feedbacks for example, from the 1st page on the FS FT forum;

http://www.hotukdeals.com/forum-feedback?user_id=129399


i really think its down to reports to get it sorted like this 1....not expecting mods to go through everyones feedback to check if they are legitimate

come on you lost this 1 dont be so bitter lol
banned#14
RedIron;5725000
In that case there are loads of members with similar feedbacks for example, from the 1st page on the FS FT forum;

http://www.hotukdeals.com/forum-feedback?user_id=129399


I don't see a deal on that thread, so I would agree with you. However csamual may have meant the feedback to be aimed at another thread, but that's only guesswork on my part, leading me to the next comment.

casparwhite;5725021
i really think its down to reports to get it sorted like this 1....not expecting mods to go through everyones feedback to check if they are legitimate


It's up to the parties involved to report any feedback left unfairly.
#15
casparwhite;5725021
i really think its down to reports to get it sorted like this 1....not expecting mods to go through everyones feedback to check if they are legitimate

come on you lost this 1 dont be so bitter lol


I'm not bitter lol

I just can't see how and negative isn't fair in this example when he clearly had no intention of finishing the deal DVD's or no DVD's.

On Friday morning he was haggling over the deal even though his prom was on the same day. There was no way he could have expected to have it on the same day when they're around 400 miles away from each other.

I think that should be highlighted in his feedback as i'd hate if I missed out on a genuine sale (To shando in this example) because of a complete time waster who had no intention of completing the deal.

This brings me back to my continual point that every negative left should automatically be flagged (like a report post) for a mod to review it and take appropriate action.
#16
so after all that and the mod agreeing feedback cant be left as no trade took place...... the feedback still stands?

i lol
#17
Right - i'm the man who left the feedback.

I don't understand why this post has been made, because i've been on this site for quite some time now and have seen far worse excuses for leaving feedback than this.

You left numerous comments on the thread whilst i wasn't looking at it, asking if it was still available and making me offers. The ONLY PM i've ever recieved from you was to say 'replied in thread - cheers'. Never did you tell me you needed it by a certain point.

We agreed the deal on £60. It's a lot of money for a suit, and i needed this sold, so i didn't want to hassle you. But then you did not respond, so i had to ask if it was still on. You then wanted to add DVD's which i said i couldn't really do.

It was your fault for making the deal longer than nescacerry, and then you dropped me at the end with a 'no doesn't matter anymore'.

I feel it's appropriate feedback because you have messed me around completely.
banned#18
It's not appropriate for the reasons I've listed above. It's since been removed. Your relevant comment should have been left in the thread.

Likewise, you would be much better concentrating on resolving outstanding trades as per my earlier thread locks.
#19
aScottishBloke;5729793
It's not appropriate for the reasons I've listed above. It's since been removed. Your relevant comment should have been left in the thread.

Likewise, you would be much better concentrating on resolving outstanding trades as per my earlier thread locks.


I guess there has been a change of heart then as the feedback is back again?
#20
RedIron
I guess there has been a change of heart then as the feedback is back again?


lol nearly the same but not quite........thats new!:?
banned#21
RedIron;5749456
I guess there has been a change of heart then as the feedback is back again?


casparwhite;5750461
lol nearly the same but not quite........thats new!:?


Removed. Thanks for noticing :thumbsup:

Post a Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.

...OR log in with your social account

...OR comment using your social account

Thanks for your comment! Keep it up!
We just need to have a quick look and it will be live soon.
The community is happy to hear your opinion! Keep contributing!