Neg selling feedback - HotUKDeals
We use cookie files to improve site functionality and personalisation. By continuing to use HUKD, you accept our cookie and privacy policy.
Get the HUKD app free at Google Play

Search Error

An error occurred when searching, please try again!

Login / Sign UpSubmit

All Comments

(21) Jump to unreadPost a comment
Comments/page:
1 Like #1
Can't see how you could have it removed it would open the floodgates for others.

Unfortunately like it or not the feedback given was the other persons opinion and that is what you have to abide by.

You admit to not paying on the day you promised.
#2
greg_68
Can't see how you could have it removed it would open the floodgates for others.

Unfortunately like it or not the feedback given was the other persons opinion and that is what you have to abide by.

You admit to not paying on the day you promised.


But 1 day before leaving feedback isnt enough time to respond is it.
[mod]#3
I sell all my old tat on ebay, and feedback is a real problem there. For example, I sold something on the Saturday evening, they paid for it on the Sunday (paypal), I emailed them to say I would post it to them on the Tuesday. They complained as I didn't post it on the Monday. Like many other people, I actually do have a life, and I reckon posting it on the Tuesday is more than reasonable. My point is...ebay have a proceedure where you can get negtive feedback removed. And rightly so, as there are some grumpy folk out there who get pleasure in being grumpy and doing this sort of thing. So, perhaps some sort of HUKD feedback removal should be set up. If it was set up then folk might not leave negative feedback so readily.
#4
andywedge
I sell all my old tat on ebay, and feedback is a real problem there. For example, I sold something on the Saturday evening, they paid for it on the Sunday (paypal), I emailed them to say I would post it to them on the Tuesday. They complained as I didn't post it on the Monday. Like many other people, I actually do have a life, and I reckon posting it on the Tuesday is more than reasonable. My point is...ebay have a proceedure where you can get negtive feedback removed. And rightly so, as there are some grumpy folk out there who get pleasure in being grumpy and doing this sort of thing. So, perhaps some sort of HUKD feedback removal should be set up. If it was set up then folk might not leave negative feedback so readily.


I dont think they were being grumpy, its easy to see why they thought I wasnt going to pay esp as they are quite new to the site but they neg feedbacked too quickly and I didnt know till when I came on the next day and saw the feedback.
[mod]#5
Like I say, I (and you by the sounds of it) have a life away from the computer. There should be some procedure to have negative feedback removed. Either it is done mutually with the buyer/seller, or a moderator can review the "case" if the buyer/seller can't agree to have it removed.
#6
Did he sell it to you? And have you left any feedback?
banned#7
if neg rep is removed beause you dont like it, then there aint much point in having a feedback system really. If the seller/buyer felt you deserved a neg then surely that is there perogative, if the buyer and seller agree it was wrongly left then slightly different, as i left neg rep for some but by hitting the worng button, and a mod removed it for me, but if i felt someone deserved neg rep i would leave it, and not be too happy if it was removed
#8
The reason I ask is because if you have left any feedback, then you you may be able to get the comments removed as they might fall into one of the categories mentioned in "Feedback abuse" on Ebay's help pages.
Feedback comments containing any of the following are not permitted:

* Links or scripts
* References to eBay or PayPal investigations
* References to law enforcement investigations
* Negative statements that conflict with a positive rating
* Personally identifying information about another member, including real name, address, phone number, or email address
* Political, religious or social commentary commentary rather than a genuine comment about the transaction
* The comment, reply or follow-up references a completely separate transaction or unrelated experience
* Profane, vulgar, obscene or racist language or adult material
* Inflammatory language, such as fraud, liar, cheater, scam artist, con man etc., while strongly discouraged, will not be removed

Breaches of this policy may result in a range of actions, including:

* Feedback rating and/or comment removal
* Listing cancellation
* Limits on account privileges
* Account suspension
* Forfeit of eBay fees on cancelled listings
* Loss of PowerSeller status


I have had a comment removed because the follow up he gave was negative after he "had" to leave me positive feedback as a seller.
I also think that if you haven't left feedback, you might be covered by the fact that the comment is unrelated to the sale - because the sale did not take place due to the seller be very hasty about the payment from you.
banned#9
franbo, im assuming op is referring to feedback left here on hukd, not ebay
#10
Good job you're on the ball!! Anyway, just thought I'd help - if anyone has this problem on ebay, then see above!!!
Sorry!:oops:
#11
To be fair mate you didn't do what you agreed to do, i'm quite laid back and if someone says they will pay me one day but they pay me the next I can let it slip but there are a lot of people who would have been waiting on that money.

You should have sent me a message to the seller letting him know, or given him a call, the only breakdown of communication was on your side as such you wont get that neg removed
#12
RedIron
To be fair mate you didn't do what you agreed to do, i'm quite laid back and if someone says they will pay me one day but they pay me the next I can let it slip but there are a lot of people who would have been waiting on that money.

You should have sent me a message to the seller letting him know, or given him a call, the only breakdown of communication was on your side as such you wont get that neg removed


I would of paid thtough but the seller quickly sold it to someone else so I couldnt, and I never said I would definately pay that day I said I should get payment off that day if I got a chance to go up town (since I dont have internet banking)
#13
ryouga
I would of paid thtough but the seller quickly sold it to someone else so I couldnt, and I never said I would definately pay that day I said I should get payment off that day if I got a chance to go up town (since I dont have internet banking)


But your Op says,
My last bad feedback was due to a misunderstanding, what happened was we agreed a sale, I got the details and said I would do a bank transfer the next day


:thinking:
banned#14
I'm afraid once again ryouga you will need to communicate better when you make contact.

If I said I was going to do something, I'd do it. If I meant I will try to do it, I'd make sure that fact was very clear also and spell out I was hoping to do it unless something stopped me. And if that happened, i would make sure I emailed to apologise straight away and say when I would be doing so.

This "breakdown in communication" appears to follow you around, but is completely preventable if you communicate your intentions (a) and do what you say you will or (b) spell out why you've been prevented from doing so straight away. From what you have said (and I've not seen you say), it sounds like you just left it and now complain this guy has communicated his views about his satisfaction by leaving feedback. (Which could have been avoided.)

You need to take it as another lesson and move on.
banned#15
Due to the well know problems I had a few weeks ago I didnt pay it in that day but the day after I got neg feedback for being a timewaster

only 2 days had passed since the deal was agreed and 1 since payment was supposed to gone through so not enough time to reply and the seller never pm'd me to ask if there was a problem.


And did you pm the seller to apologise for not paying in when you said?

Regardless of that, considering you stated that you had no money and had bid on so much in a short space of time, if I had been the seller I would have gone elsewhere too, and negged you I'm afraid.
#16
Sounds like you got off lightly, you can be suspended for not paying and people have been in the past...
[mod]#17
Shouldn't make promises you can't keep. I'd have negged you and reported you for timewasting as well.
#18
Sigh its back again to things I said being picked out at random

I told the person I should be able to pay that day but might not since it was first day of uni so I wasnt sure what time I finished and if not it would be the tuesday and they said ok, and even after they negged me said id still buy it as like otherwise I was going to sell some stuff to pay for it as didnt want to pull out.

So still the seller knew it might not be monday I paid and didnt want to sell to me when I emailed to say I still wanted it.

And col its silly to mention on me bidding on such much in a short period, someone can bid on thousands of quid of stuff, if the bid isnt accepted then its not important since you dont need cash to find it.

To back up, the money was agreed to be paid the monday or tuesday, in fact if I remember correct I said to them "as soon as I get a chance, should be monday but as im at uni might not get down town in time so may be tuesday"

And even if I did pay Monday it would have taken up to 3 days to clear.
banned#19
at the end of the day, feedback is between you and them, you cant decide what feedback they should give you, a chance we all take whe we buy and sell, a deal was done between you and them and they chose to leave neg, just one of those things
#20
stop winging . so when you left me a neg because i left you one cause you lied after 2 weeks of not sending can i have mine changed ......no cause its feedback to show people if ur a good seller or NOT SO GOOD seller
#21
csamual
stop winging . so when you left me a neg because i left you one cause you lied after 2 weeks of not sending can i have mine changed ......no cause its feedback to show people if ur a good seller or NOT SO GOOD seller



Dont mention that you failed to send your items when promised did ya. and I sent 2 to you but only 1 arrived(I got other back as undelivered)

Post a Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.

...OR log in with your social account

...OR comment using your social account

Thanks for your comment! Keep it up!
We just need to have a quick look and it will be live soon.
The community is happy to hear your opinion! Keep contributing!