Hooked on hotukdeals|Join HUKD!

Question Why is Scan banned?

MeathotukdealsMeathotukdeals

Just went to search by vendor and see Scan is banned and wondered why? I like to read about their deals because they are local to me and the place I'd be buying my PC stuff from.

All Comments (81)

Jump to unreadLocked
    dcx_badass
    It's a dumb idea, will just be a section of constant spam of every item on every site.
    ShaunnyBwoy
    dcx_badass
    It's a dumb idea, will just be a section of constant spam of every item on every site.

    Ok, develop that idea then, and add a fee for these companies posting. Less likely to spam if they are charged the privilege of doing so, and HUKD have an additional avenue of funding.
    realblender
    ShaunnyBwoy
    dcx_badass
    It's a dumb idea, will just be a section of constant spam of every item on every site.

    Ok, develop that idea then, and add a fee for these companies posting. Less likely to spam if they are charged the privilege of doing so, and HUKD have an additional avenue of funding.

    People would ignore the commecial section as they can get enough special offers in their inbox or directly from websites. If companies are allowed to post directly alongside other deals, then people wont post deals as it will create a horrible sales atmosphere. You just need to look at the AVforums where every other user is openly working on behalf of a company and promoting goods.

    Are the hotukdeals blogs sponsored deals? At least that has always been my assumption. I have never really looked but their "offers" never look very attractive.
    dunfyboy
    Scan promoted themselves on a website that has nothing to do with HUKD and gets banned? What happened to the members of HUKD who actually posted the Scan deals? Banned too?
    dcx_badass
    dunfyboy
    Scan promoted themselves on a website that has nothing to do with HUKD and gets banned? What happened to the members of HUKD who actually posted the Scan deals? Banned too?


    It's not about them promoting themselves, they were begging people to post it on hukd.
    dunfyboy
    dcx_badass
    dunfyboy
    Scan promoted themselves on a website that has nothing to do with HUKD and gets banned? What happened to the members of HUKD who actually posted the Scan deals? Banned too?


    It's not about them promoting themselves, they were begging people to post it on hukd.

    Agreed, but they weren't doing it on here. As long as they comply with Facebook's T&Cs they can do what they want on Facebook. I know anyone linked with a company can't self promote on here but is there anything in HUKD's T&Cs that bars them from doing anything outwith this site?

    Not that I'm pro-Scan. I'm as P'd off as everyone else about them upping their free P&P limit.
    dcx_badass
    HUKD rules don't allow merchants to self promote, by getting people to post on HUKD that's what they were doing.
    fanpages
    dcx_badass
    HUKD rules don't allow merchants to self promote, by getting people to post on HUKD that's what they were doing.


    The Game Group have a Twitter feed & self-promote by it many times a day.

    + The Hut Group send out e-mails to every customer a few times a week (sometimes more than once per day).

    & so on...

    Edited By: fanpages on Oct 11, 2011 21:55
    gunstarZero
    maybe tescos should start promoting their own misprices so they get banned
    ShaunnyBwoy
    fanpages
    dcx_badass
    HUKD rules don't allow merchants to self promote, by getting people to post on HUKD that's what they were doing.


    The Game Group have a Twitter feed & self-promote by it many times a day.

    + The Hut Group send out e-mails to every customer a few times a week (sometimes more than once per day).

    & so on...


    But they're not promoting their selves on the HUKD site. Though, I agree with you about The Hut Group using the same email shots 3 times a week.

    Another related subject is that I have noticed some site including a HUKD shortcut for posting a deal. I imagine they are cleared for usage on their site by admin, but isn't it essentially the same thing? This one was on the 7dayshop site:

    http://www.7dayshop.com/catalog/images/HUKD.jpg
    fanpages
    ShaunnyBwoy
    But they're not promoting their selves on the HUKD site....


    Neither are Scan. They are asking their customers to promote on their behalf.

    According to the "Help" text (quoted below) if a (HotUKDeals) member does not benefit from doing this, then that is not self-promotion.

    [ http://www.hotukdeals.com/help ]

    Posting Deals / Who can post deals on HotUKDeals?

    This website is for people who want to share good deals theyve found or look for advice from other members. Anyone can post a deal here as long as theyre not an advertiser or merchant: HotUKDeals is not a promotional tool for businesses and companies and anyone found posting items for the purposes of personal gain will be banned from the site. We may occassionally remove deals if we feel the merchant in question does not have adequate contact and/or registration details. Generally speaking we only allow UK based companies, although allowances on the above will always be made for merchants who have a strong reputation with our members.


    BFN,

    fp.

    Edited By: fanpages on Oct 12, 2011 10:49
    jah128
    To add to FP's comments - surely allowing a site to have the "Submit to Hotukdeals" buttons plastered on each and every item they sell is 100% a "promotional tool for businesses"
    Meathotukdeals
    reddit
    By the same token, why such a big issue with a ban?

    If you regularly like what Scan have to offer then simply visit their site each day to look.


    The good bit for me was the community here. Not being PC savvy I wouldn't really know a good deal on PC bits. Hearing the HotUKDeals community helped resolve that matter.
    TelicVet
    This smacks of a company not "playing ball" with the admin on this site, and them throwing the teddy FAR out of the pram. I'm quite bored of site admins inflating their "power". Scan have stuck to the rules by asking OTHERS to post a deal, if it's a crap deal, then it gets cold reviews. I wonder if the companies that generate the most revenue for the site get such totalitarian treatment.
    jah128
    TelicVet
    I wonder if the companies that generate the most revenue for the site get such totalitarian treatment.


    The companies that generate the most revenue for this site get to put a 'Submit to HUKD' button on each of their products, a 'vote this product hot' button on each of those already submitted, mass deal submissions from moderators and 'forum helpers', endorsed representation from company members to produce dishonest rebuttals to complaints on this site, and much other preferential treatment. The mods and admin deny this, and always have, but these denials are getting harder and harder to believe...
    TelicVet
    jah128
    TelicVet
    I wonder if the companies that generate the most revenue for the site get such totalitarian treatment.


    The companies that generate the most revenue for this site get to put a 'Submit to HUKD' button on each of their products, a 'vote this product hot' button on each of those already submitted, .

    If that's the case, then isn't that basically what Scan were doing albeit by skipping pressing the official button and asking people to do it for them?
    They're using one rule for one and one for another.


    Edited By: TelicVet on Oct 13, 2011 18:49: Basically I used too many basically's. Basically.
    fanpages
    FYI: Why are deals for Toys R Us banned?

    Another merchant caught "self-promoting", it seems.
    faevilangel
    The rules are simple, if you're self promoting as a business, that business gets banned. Anyone who has a business and feels it should be promoted then they can contact the admin to get a mod to publish the deal for them. Asking people on facebook to spam a forum with your "offers" is spamming and isn't what this site is about.

    The share on HUKD buttons are a tool to allow visitors to that site / product to promote it if they feel it's a good deal. I am sure the admins are keeping an eye on the sites who have the button to make sure it's not being abused.

    Scan are a multi-million pound company and if they can't get people to promote their offers without begging and bribing then they are doing something wrong. Ebuyer got caught doing it and got banned, but now they are back after sorting out the issues.

    HUKD is not a personal spam machine for large companies, it's a deal finding website where good offers from ANY retailer can be added, if a company like scan decide we want to spam then they will be banned. If HUKD allowed scan to do as they please, the site would just be full of scan's "offers".
    Shengis
    faevilangel
    The rules are simple, if you're self promoting as a business, that business gets banned. Anyone who has a business and feels it should be promoted then they can contact the admin to get a mod to publish the deal for them. Asking people on facebook to spam a forum with your "offers" is spamming and isn't what this site is about.

    The share on HUKD buttons are a tool to allow visitors to that site / product to promote it if they feel it's a good deal. I am sure the admins are keeping an eye on the sites who have the button to make sure it's not being abused.

    Scan are a multi-million pound company and if they can't get people to promote their offers without begging and bribing then they are doing something wrong. Ebuyer got caught doing it and got banned, but now they are back after sorting out the issues.

    HUKD is not a personal spam machine for large companies, it's a deal finding website where good offers from ANY retailer can be added, if a company like scan decide we want to spam then they will be banned. If HUKD allowed scan to do as they please, the site would just be full of scan's "offers".

    Check the feedback forum on that add deal/vote button. It does look on the face of it that that's exactly what it is for those that use said buttons and it does appear to be being abused from whats been posted.
    shadowdogg
    I'm happy enough for Scan to be banned :)

Post a Comment

No more comments can be posted to this thread.
I Approve
Your Comments On This Post
Comment Preview
Close

PRIVATE MESSAGE

Close
Sorry, you can’t currently send PMs. Once you’re a more active member of the forum, the PM service will be unlocked for you.
Welcome to HUKD!
Close
Join the Community