|
I'm only a new member here but have been browsing for as long as I can remember so for what it's worth:
I love the idea behind the new site I just don't think it's been executed very well. Obviously a lot of work has gone in to building the back end and the way it works on a series of filter options is potentially a great way to categorize the content on the site. However, I'm really not fond of the way the forums have been incorporated in to this system - I would much rather have all the main content; deals, vouchers etc in one location which can be sorted using the advanced filter options - and have the forums stand alone and completely conventional.
The header looks sloppy to me, the old version was nicely designed and worked - the tagline in the logo looks like an afterthought and the logo it's self looks very plain and rushed and just dropped in place without much thought. Then the right hand side of the header is equally rushed looking, the link text is far too big (not much smaller than the logo font) and sticks out like a sore thumb - the logo on the left is bottom aligned in the header and the info on the right is top, as they use similar font sizes it just doesn't sit rite in my eyes.
I'm not keen on how the two main horizontal navigation/filter bars are identical in style - one specifies a category of product and the other is the actual categories of the site/different pages - but it just looks like one continuation of the same thing on to a new line - as a first time visitor I don't thing I would have a clue what all that did, and that you needed to select an option from each line to filter down the results.
There is no definition in colour between different elements on the "forum" pages - it's all just content on a white/light grey background and consequently very hard to read as nothing has borders, it just looks like a load of text and images thrown on to a white page.
I don't know why there is an inconsistency in the page width, as you browse the main pages the page is centre aligned with a fixed width, but when you click a deal to enter the 'forum' - the pages jump to 100% fluid width which doesn't look very nice for those of us using widescreen monitors. Not that using the whole area on screen is a bad thing, but everything is so white and undefined that it's not easy to use.
Anyway, no offence intended to the designer(s)/developer(s) - just a few observations I have made, as I say, there is great potential in the new functionality, it's just not being executed very well as people are going to find it so confusing to navigate which is just about the biggest problem you want to avoid on such a rich content driven site.
|