dark_shadow is offlineAdd to dark_shadow's Reputation
dark_shadow's Avatar
dark_shadow
Flame Thrower
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 505

The 'Constructive cristicism' thread

POSTED BY: dark_shadow 5 months, 3 days ago

There are far too many people ranting on about the new look. To be frank it's not fair on the Admin/Web Team.

I'd like to voice my thoughts on the new site.

Quite clearly, a lot of effort has been put into making this site unique but I'm afraid to say it's not user-friendly at all.

Most users here like the 'conventional' style forums and we're all used to it. Surely it shouldn't be too difficult giving the user an option to choose between the CSS styles?

Or perhaps make a comprise between the the old layout, but updated with the new colours and features.

I urge all members to post in this thread offering constructive criticism and we'll hopefully get some answers from the Admin/Mod team :)

Tags: , , (Add a tag)


ryoooh is offline  
ryoooh's Avatar
ryoooh
Flame Thrower
ryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant future
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 684
looks s*it. can hardly be bothered to read what people have written anymore. so much white even in classic view and the most simple and effective thing of all, TEMPERATURE BARS, are GONE !!!!(hidden in the actual topic which is USELESS and extremely and uncessarily time consuming) how do we know how hot anything is anymore? plus u have to click deals to get only deals then click hot or new etc. as the site is hotukdeals it should go to deals page automatically, not have all the other forum topics merged in one view, u wont be getting new visitors by doing that.
Reply With Quote
pmcx9 is offline  
pmcx9
Matchstick
pmcx9 will become famous soon enough
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 99
no brainer.....go back to old style. hard to be constructive when its so very very wrong
Reply With Quote
davcohen is offline  
davcohen
Pilot Light
davcohen is on a distinguished road
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Posts: 110
the new graphics and colours are very nice however there is no need to section things out it well before so switch it back to the classic style that everyone can use and was happy with
Reply With Quote
fcuk is offline  
fcuk
Matchstick
fcuk is an unknown quantity at this point
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 22
Absalute Rubbish, will keep checking to see if changed back to normal before using it, as its totaly unusable, should of just updated it colour wise or new buttons, just to make it look fresh/different from time to time, qvc change there look every year, by colours,size etc...but not to this extent....
bring it back
Reply With Quote
mako is offline  
mako's Avatar
mako
Pilot Light
mako is just really nicemako is just really nicemako is just really nicemako is just really nicemako is just really nice
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Portsmouth
Posts: 252
its a little unfair to just bombard the admin team with unhelpful comments like "it looks *****". I think they have implemented some good functionality into the site, i would agree that its a little too white for my liking. Change freaks people out and i think thats whats happening here, theres a lot of good stuff in the new website, just needs to be tweaked to perfection.
Reply With Quote
elmo1314 is offline  
elmo1314
Flint
elmo1314 will become famous soon enoughelmo1314 will become famous soon enough
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 5
I used to look at the site every day - now it is full of dull chat like this.

I just want deals, freebies and vouchers - not discussions (at the end of the day I ask my friends for advice etc)

Listen to the people, go back tot eh old site.
Reply With Quote
ryoooh is offline  
ryoooh's Avatar
ryoooh
Flame Thrower
ryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant future
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 684
it is fair, the users are the people who basically power the site, no users = no site. almost 500 people have taken the time to sign the petition, that speaks for itself.

above all this is an absolutely insane time to implement what is in effect a HUKD BETA website...do it in feb when nobody gives a.
Reply With Quote
zoopakev is offline  
zoopakev
Matchstick
zoopakev is on a distinguished road
 
Join Date: May 2007
Posts: 85
Isn’t it time someone locked this like the others....

Can’t believe the new site, what an enormous backward step for savers, A giant leap backward

completely vacuous ..... utter utter cobblers
Reply With Quote
ryoooh is offline  
ryoooh's Avatar
ryoooh
Flame Thrower
ryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant futureryoooh has a brilliant future
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 684
elmo u need to setup your custom thread and select vouchers deals and freebies and then use the custom tab to get your usual daily fix of the hot stuff. but you still wont be able to glance to see the very hottest deals at the moment. and why you should have to setup a 'custom' tab to see this basic mix of stuff which in the old days would of automatically been presented to you is beyond me, but hey ho.
Reply With Quote
minorbob is offline  
minorbob
Flint
minorbob is on a distinguished road
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Posts: 7
I can't seem to be able to upload an image, but please try this on Firefox on the Mac. The menu has gone crazy and I get it running down the page all over the top of other text on the page.
Reply With Quote
shieldsy is offline  
shieldsy
Pilot Light
shieldsy is just really niceshieldsy is just really niceshieldsy is just really niceshieldsy is just really niceshieldsy is just really nice
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Bradford
Posts: 158
elmo1314:
I used to look at the site every day - now it is full of dull chat like this.

I just want deals, freebies and vouchers - not discussions (at the end of the day I ask my friends for advice etc)

Listen to the people, go back tot eh old site.
If you don't like the chat, don't go to the forums!
Reply With Quote
Deleted User Name 3 is offline  
Deleted User Name 3
Pilot Light
Deleted User Name 3 has a spectacular aura aboutDeleted User Name 3 has a spectacular aura aboutDeleted User Name 3 has a spectacular aura about
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Posts: 437
unique? It now looks like all those advert websites (you know the ones, you do a websearch and get thousands of results for "review xxxxx at yyyy" or "find cheap prices on nnnnnn at ttttttttt" and "find user opinions and cheap prices at pppppppppppp". Those horrible affiliate based sites that offer no real info. Obviously this site DOES have real info, but it's now hidden (plus one look at it and you don't want to find it).

It's far too cluttered and messy - too many different colours to distract, too much going on in general on each page and each section/post isn't broken up enough - it all seems to be one big mass.
Reply With Quote
nobby1 is offline  
nobby1
Matchstick
nobby1 is on a distinguished road
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 17
i just find it rock hard to find anything.....it's not user friendly like the old site
Reply With Quote
JimmyW is offline  
JimmyW's Avatar
JimmyW
Pilot Light
JimmyW is a jewel in the roughJimmyW is a jewel in the roughJimmyW is a jewel in the roughJimmyW is a jewel in the rough
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 377
I'm only a new member here but have been browsing for as long as I can remember so for what it's worth:

I love the idea behind the new site I just don't think it's been executed very well. Obviously a lot of work has gone in to building the back end and the way it works on a series of filter options is potentially a great way to categorize the content on the site. However, I'm really not fond of the way the forums have been incorporated in to this system - I would much rather have all the main content; deals, vouchers etc in one location which can be sorted using the advanced filter options - and have the forums stand alone and completely conventional.

The header looks sloppy to me, the old version was nicely designed and worked - the tagline in the logo looks like an afterthought and the logo it's self looks very plain and rushed and just dropped in place without much thought. Then the right hand side of the header is equally rushed looking, the link text is far too big (not much smaller than the logo font) and sticks out like a sore thumb - the logo on the left is bottom aligned in the header and the info on the right is top, as they use similar font sizes it just doesn't sit rite in my eyes.

I'm not keen on how the two main horizontal navigation/filter bars are identical in style - one specifies a category of product and the other is the actual categories of the site/different pages - but it just looks like one continuation of the same thing on to a new line - as a first time visitor I don't thing I would have a clue what all that did, and that you needed to select an option from each line to filter down the results.

There is no definition in colour between different elements on the "forum" pages - it's all just content on a white/light grey background and consequently very hard to read as nothing has borders, it just looks like a load of text and images thrown on to a white page.

I don't know why there is an inconsistency in the page width, as you browse the main pages the page is centre aligned with a fixed width, but when you click a deal to enter the 'forum' - the pages jump to 100% fluid width which doesn't look very nice for those of us using widescreen monitors. Not that using the whole area on screen is a bad thing, but everything is so white and undefined that it's not easy to use.

Anyway, no offence intended to the designer(s)/developer(s) - just a few observations I have made, as I say, there is great potential in the new functionality, it's just not being executed very well as people are going to find it so confusing to navigate which is just about the biggest problem you want to avoid on such a rich content driven site.
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools