Chiptivo is offlineAdd to Chiptivo's Reputation
Chiptivo's Avatar
Chiptivo
Solar Flare
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 1029

RANT... Asda carrier bags are going... 5p in Future..

POSTED BY: Chiptivo 5 months, 5 hours ago

Had a mini arguement, well, maybe discussion in Asda today...

They would not let me have a normal bag??? They only had the 5p plastic and the £1 canvas bags hanging up, they had the old free ones under the counter.. She eventually let me have some for my shopping, but said as from next Monday (May of been Friday) all asda's bags are going to cost 5p each, but can be replaced free of charged if damaged (What happens to the old 5p ones that get brought back? I said, they recycle them, I said why can't standard ones be recycled?? No answer)....

I entered into a discussion, that I always recycle my carrier bags with rubbish in the kitchen, and they are biodegradable (in fact asda's are not!!!!!) and the answer was to buy kitchen waste bags that are biodegradable instead.....

They then played the "We have to be responsable to the enviroment" card... I pointed to the two 2000watt motor revolving doors they have at the front of the store and why they can't just be openings???. That kinda shut her up....

No asda for me in future, Sainsbury's already use FREE biodegradable bags, that if you look on the boxes have use by dates as they disintergrate if left for too long in storage..

I fear we have more to worry about than carrier bags.
I am very carefull re the enviroment, try not to use the car unless I have to, plant loads of plants, and regulary cut the grass to get rid of CO2. I hope we have all noticed that it is no longer called Global warming (Because the planet is currently cooling down year on year like it natually does fluctuate) so we are now calling it climate change????
The planet adapts to change well. We have much bigger problems that carrier bags.

Tags: (Add a tag)



pinkkitty2007 is offline  
pinkkitty2007's Avatar
pinkkitty2007
Solar Flare
pinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicypinkkitty2007 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Here
Posts: 7,485
View FS/FT Feedback
My local shop now only has the reusable canvas ones at £1 each and no other options. I think most shops will be going down the reusable bag route from now on
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to bellabonkers
bellabonkers is offline  
bellabonkers's Avatar
bellabonkers
Solar Flare
bellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicybellabonkers is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Newcastle upon Tyne
Posts: 6,533
View FS/FT Feedback
Loved the way you argued about the revolving doors. It winds me up when stores have the heating on full blast but prop their doors open???? It's not the little man that needs to make a change. Big companies need to do their bit and not pass the blame on to the consumer.
I didn't know they were going to start charging. Good job i have a stash of bags ready to recycle in my kitchen.
Reply With Quote
pghstochaj is offline  
pghstochaj
Flame Thrower
pghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to all
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 560
View FS/FT Feedback
Revolving doors save energy compared to open doors. 4 kW is a small usage anyway.
Bio-degradable isn't the issue here, waste of resources going to landfill is.
Consider life cycle analysis.
etc. etc.
Reply With Quote
ryouga is offline  
ryouga's Avatar
ryouga
Solar Flare
ryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating upryouga is heating up
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Chester
Posts: 4,574
View FS/FT Feedback
bellabonkers:
Loved the way you argued about the revolving doors. It winds me up when stores have the heating on full blast but prop their doors open???? It's not the little man that needs to make a change. Big companies need to do their bit and not pass the blame on to the consumer.
I didn't know they were going to start charging. Good job i have a stash of bags ready to recycle in my kitchen.
My university blasts the heating up at nighttimes especially at the weekend so bad that everyone is sweating even before they start dancing and we all know its a ploy to get people to buy more.
Reply With Quote
aScottishBloke is offline  
aScottishBloke
Solar Flare
aScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond repute
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Scottish Borders
Posts: 1,008
View FS/FT Feedback
Chiptivo,

Next time you go into ASDA or another similar store and they try to charge you extra for taking away the purchases you have bought, e.g. £200 on groceries, leave them behind on the till. They will soon get the message.

Let them invest in a more environmentally friendly option, it's not as if they don't charge it back indirectly.
Reply With Quote
GAVINLEWISHUKD is offline  
GAVINLEWISHUKD's Avatar
GAVINLEWISHUKD
Solar Flare
GAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating upGAVINLEWISHUKD is heating up
 
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: NOTTM
Posts: 2,577
View FS/FT Feedback
My local Asda stopped the free bags and people have started just putting the goods back in baskets so the trolley boys now have to collect all the abandoned baskets from all around the car park. I guy just put the basket in his boot and drove off.

As for me I just take my bright orange Sainsburys bag for life to Asda.
Reply With Quote
pghstochaj is offline  
pghstochaj
Flame Thrower
pghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to all
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 560
View FS/FT Feedback
aScottishBloke:
Chiptivo,

Next time you go into ASDA or another similar store and they try to charge you extra for taking away the purchases you have bought, e.g. £200 on groceries, leave them behind on the till. They will soon get the message.

Let them invest in a more environmentally friendly option, it's not as if they don't charge it back indirectly.
The government has suggested they will take action with law if supermarkets don't...
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to Robotochan
Robotochan is offline  
Robotochan's Avatar
Robotochan
Solar Flare
Robotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond reputeRobotochan has a reputation beyond repute
 
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: JDeal Central
Posts: 1,752
View FS/FT Feedback
So Asda are introducing the pay for bag scheme earlier than some of the other stores big woop. 5p is hardly worth crying about. A lot of people already use Bags for Life which is what everyone should be doing anyway.

Going by your logic of the automatic doors I assume you use a manual grass cutter?

I personally feel little can be done at the consumer end of the supply chain, maybe if packaging was made more sparse and with less plastic we'd have less to throw away and more of what we do throw away will be a little more "eco-friendly"

The Climate is changing and not for the better, sure the planet goes through it's cycles however we are causing them to be much more extreme than pre-industrial revolution. Only way we're gonna be saved is a massive geo-engineering project...
Reply With Quote
Chiptivo is offline  
Chiptivo's Avatar
Chiptivo
Solar Flare
Chiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud of
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,029
View FS/FT Feedback
aScottishBloke:
Chiptivo,

Next time you go into ASDA or another similar store and they try to charge you extra for taking away the purchases you have bought, e.g. £200 on groceries, leave them behind on the till. They will soon get the message.

Let them invest in a more environmentally friendly option, it's not as if they don't charge it back indirectly.

Yes, I thought of that today.. If they would not let me have the "Free under the counter bags" I may of considered leaving the sale and walking out.
I would of been embarrased if a assistant or manager came along and paid for the 5p ones for me, but it is the point...

Sainsbury's carrier bags are made from recycled plastic, and biodegrade within a couple of years..

Landfill is interesting also, I could argue that landfill is not a bad conpromise for our waste. Our local landfill is now a very nice nature reserve, and also provides methane gas for our local cake and biscuit factory.. A win win situation.


Found a quote from asda managment today "We want to make protecting the planet easier and more affordable for our 15m customers."????
With revolving doors, and stadium floodlighting in the stores.
Reply With Quote
Shengis is offline  
Shengis's Avatar
Shengis
Solar Flare
Shengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Miles from anywhere....
Posts: 7,954
View FS/FT Feedback
http://www.hotukdeals.com/item/15713...th-u-when-u-g/

http://www.hotukdeals.com/item/18074...to-plastic-ba/
Reply With Quote
aScottishBloke is offline  
aScottishBloke
Solar Flare
aScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond reputeaScottishBloke has a reputation beyond repute
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Scottish Borders
Posts: 1,008
View FS/FT Feedback
pghstochaj:
The government has suggested they will take action with law if supermarkets don't...
Good, that's my point. Leave your groceries behind and before you know it the supermarkets will be forcing their 'special' bags upon you 'free of charge'.
Reply With Quote
Chiptivo is offline  
Chiptivo's Avatar
Chiptivo
Solar Flare
Chiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud ofChiptivo has much to be proud of
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,029
View FS/FT Feedback
pghstochaj:
The government has suggested they will take action with law if supermarkets don't...

This govenment is really struggleing and we are getting a bit fed up with being told what to do.. I would guess they would be putting this on hold... A bag tax that they are thinking of introducing will not be put forward until after the next general election.
Reply With Quote
pghstochaj is offline  
pghstochaj
Flame Thrower
pghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to allpghstochaj is a name known to all
 
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 560
View FS/FT Feedback
Sorry, but you misunderstand the situation. Firstly, plastic bags are not "recycled" - they are re-used in a technical definition, a lower step in the waste hierarchy and thus less preferred. It is a finite resource being wasted, compared to genuine recycling (laymen's term: reusing your bag). The sainsburys bags are 33% reused (technical definition), thus far from being sustainable, that's the problem with polymers, difficult to reuse.

Unfortunately you can't argue that, hence why the landfill directive exists, new landfill taxes and the year on year increase and the absolute lack of volume left in landfill, it simply doesn't exist anymore. Your biodegrading plastic bags adds nothing to calorific values in a waste-to-energy system.

Government has quite rightly said, self-reg or we will reg you. Asda are doing the right thing for the world.

I have been in asdas at night and main lighting is turned off for energy saving. Again, revolving doors lower convective heat transfer and are of benefit.

The major place that supermarkets could improve is the refrigeration systems. They are very inefficient due to the boundary defined, cooling and heating itself constantly, with AC cooling the shop.

Personally I am happy to recycle bags (technical definition) and don't see the problem.

Chiptivo:
Yes, I thought of that today.. If they would not let me have the "Free under the counter bags" I may of considered leaving the sale and walking out.
I would of been embarrased if a assistant or manager came along and paid for the 5p ones for me, but it is the point...

Sainsbury's carrier bags are made from recycled plastic, and biodegrade within a couple of years..

Landfill is interesting also, I could argue that landfill is not a bad conpromise for our waste. Our local landfill is now a very nice nature reserve, and also provides methane gas for our local cake and biscuit factory.. A win win situation.


Found a quote from asda managment today "We want to make protecting the planet easier and more affordable for our 15m customers."????
With revolving doors, and stadium floodlighting in the stores.
Reply With Quote
Shengis is offline  
Shengis's Avatar
Shengis
Solar Flare
Shengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicyShengis is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Miles from anywhere....
Posts: 7,954
View FS/FT Feedback
Chiptivo:
This govenment is really struggleing and we are getting a bit fed up with being told what to do.. I would guess they would be putting this on hold... A bag tax that they are thinking of introducing will not be put forward until after the next general election.
How innocent. Do you really not think this would be another good way for the current administration to 'throw' the next election? Lets face it, they know they won't win so will now try to cause as much trouble for the next lot as they can
Reply With Quote

Thread Tools