guv:
Hmm. So how many people have a sky HD box? And the cost? This is £149 and comes with no strings or subscriptions attached - or extra tenner because its HD. I'm not sure what you pay for your Sky service - but I bet its more than you would have to pay on Freesat!
Remember this is still early doors. That price will soon be the standard for a PVR version (and no £10 extra sub for that either!).
Many people have taken sky purely because their terrestrial reception is poor. I'm guessing they will be definates, along with anyone else that wants HD without being forced to pay a tenner for the facility.
I totally agree with you and hope this will be a serious competitor to sky. I am one of those that had to go down the sky route as my terrestrial picture was awful and no signs of freeview until after the analogue turn off. If I was going to go down the freesat HD route I think I would wait to see what's on offer and go for one that's got recording capabilities.
All that freesat has at the moment on HD is a very limited BBC and ITV to come which will work interactively through the red button which unless the freesat box is different to the sky box it will not allow you to record onto the hard drive.
At the moment if you bought a sky HD receiver independently and used it as a freeview box you would still have more HD choice than freesat . A sky HD box will cost you about £220 ish.. I know this is quite a lot more but it does give you the option of subscribing to sky later if you want to as it would have the card reader and the freesat probably wouldn't..
I do pay sky the £10 sub to watch the 18 HD channels I have got access to. I don't do this because I'm forced to, I do this by choice and I could cancel tomorrow if I choose to.
Until freesat offer a better freeview HD service than sky I don't think the 600,000 ish sky HD subscribers will jump ship.. I hope they do offer a good freeview HD package..