bod emrys is offlineAdd to bod emrys's Reputation
bod emrys's Avatar
bod emrys
Solar Flare
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 2522

Why are tags not in the advanced search?

POSTED BY: bod emrys 5 months, 3 weeks ago

Well?

Tags: (Add a tag)



Admin is offline  
Admin's Avatar
Admin
Administrator
Admin has disabled reputation
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 12,886
View FS/FT Feedback
Do you mean as a special search box? Or just in keyword search?
__________________
Search Tips | Voucher Codes | Travel Deals
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,761
View FS/FT Feedback
i didnt think the search used tags
Reply With Quote
jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Foxy stoat.
Posts: 6,210
View FS/FT Feedback
Admin:
Do you mean as a special search box? Or just in keyword search?
Either/or, tags would be so much more useful if they could be searched. A dedicated box on advanced-search page would be a good start!
Reply With Quote
bod emrys is offline  
bod emrys's Avatar
bod emrys
Solar Flare
bod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating up
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 2,522
View FS/FT Feedback
jah128:
Either/or, tags would be so much more useful if they could be searched. A dedicated box on advanced-search page would be a good start!
Exactly. At the moment, if I want to search for threads tagged with a word, lets say 'microsoft', I first need to find a thread that already has that tag - not always that easy if the tag is not a word in the title.

I find tags very useful (when used properly) and the ability to search for threads with a particular tag would be a useful adition to the site imho.

Edit - personally I think a dedicated tag search box would be more useful than lumping it together with the keyword search, but either would be good
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to thesaint
thesaint is offline  
thesaint's Avatar
thesaint
Solar Flare
thesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Mr Teflon
Posts: 16,098
View FS/FT Feedback
bod emrys:
Exactly. At the moment, if I want to search for threads tagged with a word, lets say 'microsoft', I first need to find a thread that already has that tag - not always that easy if the tag is not a word in the title.

I find tags very useful (when used properly) and the ability to search for threads with a particular tag would be a useful adition to the site imho.

Edit - personally I think a dedicated tag search box would be more useful than lumping it together with the keyword search, but either would be good
Alternatively, you can add a "microsoft" tag to any thread, and then search it from that thread.
You then have to remember to delete it though.

There have been several threads with suggestions to make the tags useful though. I remember ducky had some good suggestions that included tag "clouds".

I also would like it if a member could see what tags they had used previously.
Reply With Quote
jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Foxy stoat.
Posts: 6,210
View FS/FT Feedback
Another good idea would be having an auto-complete list appear when a user starts adding a tag (as happens when a username is entered in advanced search). Unfortunately this hasn't been implemented from the start, and with 75,000 tags there are no doubt lots that are very similar/redundant...
Reply With Quote
Admin is offline  
Admin's Avatar
Admin
Administrator
Admin has disabled reputation
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 12,886
View FS/FT Feedback
Well get the search bit fixed.

Agree that autocomplete would be good. We'd have to spend some time cleaning everything up though for it to work really well.
__________________
Search Tips | Voucher Codes | Travel Deals
Reply With Quote
jah128 is offline  
jah128's Avatar
jah128
Solar Flare
jah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touchjah128 is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Foxy stoat.
Posts: 6,210
View FS/FT Feedback
Admin:
Agree that autocomplete would be good. We'd have to spend some time cleaning everything up though for it to work really well.
Filtering out irrelevant tags would be next to impossible I imagine - but you could start the 'autocomplete' with an empty list, which is populated with tags as they are searched for, added, or directly accessed...

Regardless, tag search will be very useful, thanks for looking into it
Reply With Quote
bod emrys is offline  
bod emrys's Avatar
bod emrys
Solar Flare
bod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating upbod emrys is heating up
 
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 2,522
View FS/FT Feedback
Admin:
Well get the search bit fixed.

Agree that autocomplete would be good. We'd have to spend some time cleaning everything up though for it to work really well.
Excellent, thanks for listening.

I agree with jah on the autocomplete idea too
Reply With Quote
starsparkle2311 is offline  
starsparkle2311's Avatar
starsparkle2311
Solar Flare
starsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touchstarsparkle2311 is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: How's that for a slice of fried gold?
Posts: 19,010
View FS/FT Feedback
excuse me, while this is a great convo, what porpoise do tags serve now?
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to thesaint
thesaint is offline  
thesaint's Avatar
thesaint
Solar Flare
thesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touchthesaint is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: Mr Teflon
Posts: 16,098
View FS/FT Feedback
starsparkle2311:
excuse me, while this is a great convo, what porpoise do tags serve now?
Porpoise?

Reply With Quote
lumoruk is offline  
lumoruk's Avatar
lumoruk
Solar Flare
lumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicylumoruk is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Oxford area Reputation: 6,489,944
Posts: 9,535
View FS/FT Feedback
starsparkle2311:
excuse me, while this is a great convo, what porpoise do tags serve now?
if I create another thread and put the same tag as this one then the two threads will show up when I click the tag.

say a thread is about Tesco, someone will put Tesco as a tag, you click the Tesco tag and all threads about Tesco will be displayed.

a problem arises though when Tesco, Tescos or Tesco's is used
Reply With Quote