awoodhall2003 is offlineAdd to awoodhall2003's Reputation
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 9081

Problem With New Feedback System

POSTED BY: awoodhall2003 2 weeks, 5 days ago

Say for example someone puts up a wanted thread and an item is offered but the OP does not want it then i buy the item on that thread...i cannot leave feedback for that person.

Now obviously what should thus be done is create a new thread both post in it so feedback can be left.

However i am currently in this situation on this thread:
http://www.hotukdeals.com/item/509219/wanted-gym-gloves

Thus i believe an update in the rules to state a new thread MUST be created.

Tags: (Add a tag)



Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,620
View FS/FT Feedback
you shouldnt be dealing in someone elses thread anyway, tell the seller to start his thread, or you strat your own
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to awoodhall2003
awoodhall2003 is offline  
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
awoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Over The Hill And Faraway
Posts: 9,081
View FS/FT Feedback
sassie:
you shouldnt be dealing in someone elses thread anyway, tell the seller to start his thread, or you strat your own
why not? if i state im interested and they say thats fine then no problems, happens now and again, and its fine, unless the OP doesnt want it.

I have started my own im just proposing an update.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,620
View FS/FT Feedback
awoodhall2003:
why not? if i state im interested and they say thats fine then no problems, happens now and again, and its fine, unless the OP doesnt want it.

I have started my own im just proposing an update.
because its totally unfair on the op, yes they may be fine with it, but then it encourages it across the baords, when things are for sale too, you cant have one rule for one thread and not another
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to awoodhall2003
awoodhall2003 is offline  
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
awoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Over The Hill And Faraway
Posts: 9,081
View FS/FT Feedback
sassie:
because its totally unfair on the op, yes they may be fine with it, but then it encourages it across the baords, when things are for sale too, you cant have one rule for one thread and not another
thus im suggesting the update as i dont believe anything like it exists at the moment?
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to bazzaric
bazzaric is offline  
bazzaric's Avatar
bazzaric
Solar Flare
bazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicybazzaric is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Aberdeen
Posts: 6,631
View FS/FT Feedback
yep, it's an infractable offence
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,620
View FS/FT Feedback
it does come under the rules

(14) Please ONLY post in a thread if you are interested in engaging in the sale/trade listed. Anything else will be considered thread spoiling and will be deleted. Thread spoilers, including threadjackers, face a ban from the FS/FT forum. If a member continually posts questions in multiple threads and then withdraws from the sale this will be considered thread spoiling. Low ball offers will also be considered thread spoiling and will be deleted. It is up to the original poster to use the 'report' button to notify moderators of any thread spoiling.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to awoodhall2003
awoodhall2003 is offline  
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
awoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Over The Hill And Faraway
Posts: 9,081
View FS/FT Feedback
sassie:
it does come under the rules

(14) Please ONLY post in a thread if you are interested in engaging in the sale/trade listed. Anything else will be considered thread spoiling and will be deleted. Thread spoilers, including threadjackers, face a ban from the FS/FT forum. If a member continually posts questions in multiple threads and then withdraws from the sale this will be considered thread spoiling. Low ball offers will also be considered thread spoiling and will be deleted. It is up to the original poster to use the 'report' button to notify moderators of any thread spoiling.
but technically i could be considered in the listing, the listing in the thread...obviously interpretation is key then, but then a clarification should be made still
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,620
View FS/FT Feedback
awoodhall2003:
but technically i could be considered in the listing, the listing in the thread...obviously interpretation is key then, but then a clarification should be made still
where you offering to sell what the op wanted? i think that answers the question
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to awoodhall2003
awoodhall2003 is offline  
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
awoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Over The Hill And Faraway
Posts: 9,081
View FS/FT Feedback
sassie:
where you offering to sell what the op wanted? i think that answers the question
sassie i never understood why you get so personally involved and hard backed over these issues, im merely stating its not very clear and thus a clarification would only be a positive change.
I am merely stating, and not implying i had the item, that it could be misread.
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,620
View FS/FT Feedback
awoodhall2003:
sassie i never understood why you get so personally involved and hard backed over these issues, im merely stating its not very clear and thus a clarification would only be a positive change.
I am merely stating, and not implying i had the item, that it could be misread.
i dont get personally involved, i answered what you asked, im sorry i bothered now, thought it may help you not get infracted for doing something you shouldnt, but hey ho its nearly xmas
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to awoodhall2003
awoodhall2003 is offline  
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
awoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Over The Hill And Faraway
Posts: 9,081
View FS/FT Feedback
sassie:
i dont get personally involved, i answered what you asked, im sorry i bothered now, thought it may help you not get infracted for doing something you shouldnt, but hey ho its nearly xmas
well it seems like you were quite attacking in your approach, but apologies if not. If i get an infraction then i deserve it, so i will not try and dodge it. But as you say its nearly christmas...so a present from the mods would be nice
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to sassie
sassie is offline  
sassie's Avatar
sassie
Solar Flare
sassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touchsassie is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: shrewsbury
Posts: 33,620
View FS/FT Feedback
awoodhall2003:
well it seems like you were quite attacking in your approach, but apologies if not. If i get an infraction then i deserve it, so i will not try and dodge it. But as you say its nearly christmas...so a present from the mods would be nice
werll spam this quickly and no one will ever know
Reply With Quote
Send a message via MSN to awoodhall2003
awoodhall2003 is offline  
awoodhall2003's Avatar
awoodhall2003
Solar Flare
awoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicyawoodhall2003 is getting a little spicy
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Over The Hill And Faraway
Posts: 9,081
View FS/FT Feedback
sassie:
werll spam this quickly and no one will ever know
You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to sassie again.
Reply With Quote
aScottishBloke is offline  
aScottishBloke's Avatar
aScottishBloke
Super Moderator
aScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touchaScottishBloke is too hot to touch
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Scottish Borders
Posts: 8,988
View FS/FT Feedback
There was a potential for thread jacking. The sale by all means took place off the board as the feedback thread was set up for an item already received.

Made a mess of it also.

The correct procedure was to make your own wanted thread, prior to dealing.

Reply With Quote

Thread Tools