I recently sold my copy of Black Ops to a HUKD user in this thread:http://www.hotukdeals.com/for-sale-trade/wanted-call-duty-black-ops-xbox-360/870393/#post10577558
I've always kept my games in mint condition. I've never had a problem before with the half a dozen or so trades I've done on here before.
All was tickety-boo until I PM'd him asking him if he received it okay. It is claimed that the disc doesn't work and asked what I was going to do about it. I was about to offer a refund, but then got suspicious and reread the thread. From his wording ("Don't care what condition it is in as long as it works" and "don't worry about photos") I now have a feeling I'm being scammed. If I offer him a refund, what are the chances that I'm likely to receive his previously owned damaged disc back? What should I do? I've never been involved in a dispute on here before.