Posted 24 August 2008

*~*~* Eating Fruit After a Meal *~*~*

My step-mum told me today (who heard this at work) that if you eat fruit after a meal it will take longer to digest therefore will FERMENT in your belly as it is lying on top of your recently eaten meal! Melon especially! She said it is suggested to leave an hour or 2 before you eat the fruit as a dessert! Can i have peoples views and/or opinions on this please as i quite regularly give my 14 month old fruit as her dessert with no gap in between and am now feeling a bit weird about it!!
P.s I did a little looking it up on the net but got mixed thoughts from it all!
Community Updates
New Comment

25 Comments

sorted by
's avatar
  1. deleted52701's avatar
    KELLY 'N' STEVE;2814217

    Evidence please!! How do you know??:w00t:


    I thought my advice given to many members about food and exercise would be enough!

    When you eat, your stomach releases hydrochloric acid to break down the food, your stomach is just one big bag, there are no pockets, so when you eat a meal then a piece of fruit, it will all get mixed.

    the Acid mixes with the food as it breaks down, then carried into the intestines etc etc.

    Fruit usually takes about 15-35mins to digesting depending on what type of fruit it is.

    it does not "lay on top" of the other food.
  2. choc1969's avatar
    It's true, a dietician advised me to actually eat fruit before a meal, leave at least 30 minutes to an hour before eating a main meal. Was also advised not to drink with a meal but wait another 30 minutes to give your body time to digest the food too as it gets mixed signals if you add a liquid to the equation.

    Asked about soup but she just laughed.
  3. irkapirka's avatar
    Yes your mother is absolutely right.
    Fruit should always be eaten before main meal as it does fermait if it is eaten after. Therefore you might experiment lots of gass expsosions if eaten in the wrong order.
    Fruit (especialy melons) is very quickly digested it goes through you very fast
    I always give my kids bowl of mixed fruit about 1 hour before main meal or as soon as I pick them up from school. Then they go very nicely to the toilet in the wright time and regularly.
    ;-)
  4. deleted88602's avatar
    Jus read loads on here, en.wikipedia.org/wik…ion

    No conclusion but read to your hearts content and follow links Zzzzzz :lazy:

    Some stuff is digested in the small bowel even. :?

    Any way, fed up with 5 fruits 3 grains 5Ltrs water (I feel quite ill) fiber and exersize,
    I'm of to Mc Ds :whistling:
  5. deleted66159's avatar
    OK If you want an outline of how the digestive system works:
    bbc.co.uk/sch…tml
    Food in the stomach is constantly churned by peristaltic movements of the muscular stomach wall. Gastric juices are released whiich contain hydrochloric acid to kill bacteria and one or more enzymes active in the digestion of protein. Basically the stomach is the body's liquidiser - look at vomit!! Fermentation is an anaerobic process and not relevant to a functional digestive system. The more there is of anything to digest the longer it will take. The stomach contents are released bit by bit into the small intestine, which is where the real digestion takes place and the digested food is absorbed into the blood stream. Clearly if you eat fruit and nothing else the 'fruit molecules' will get there first. There is no real benefit to this because the body has mechanisms to 'even things out' so that your cells get what they need when they need it.

    So feed your little one in the normal sensible common sense ways that I'm sure you always have. Sometimes I wonder where these 'diet experts' come from.

    Just so you know -
    Poo is egested, not excreted and consists of indigestible food , gut cells etc and bacteria.
  6. deleted20644's avatar
    never heard that :?
  7. xxKellsxx's avatar
    Author
    loupomm;2814199

    never heard that :?



    Exactly nor had i thats why i want a bit of advice from others!! Weird in it!!?:thinking:
  8. deleted52701's avatar
    nope, not true at all.
  9. borolad94's avatar
    Me neither :?
  10. xxKellsxx's avatar
    Author
    black gerbil1;2814210

    nope, not true at all.



    Evidence please!! How do you know??:w00t:
  11. xxKellsxx's avatar
    Author
    choc1969;2814219

    It's true, a dietician advised me to actually eat fruit before a meal.



    Thats how the subject was brought up in the first place as she is on the "grapefruit diet" - eat half a grapefruit before every meal and it burns the calories quicker than normal!
  12. choc1969's avatar
    The stomach releases gastric acid.....hydrochloric acid is only a component of this ;-)
  13. deleted46040's avatar
    black gerbil1;2814240

    I thought my advice given to many members about food and exercise would … I thought my advice given to many members about food and exercise would be enough!When you eat, your stomach releases hydrochloric acid to break down the food, your stomach is just one big bag, there are no pockets, so when you eat a meal then a piece of fruit, it will all get mixed.the Acid mixes with the food as it breaks down, then carried into the intestines etc etc. Fruit usually takes about 15-35mins to digesting depending on what type of fruit it is.it does not "lay on top" of the other food.



    Well said, how and wear is the food going to "lay on top"? It does not form an orderly line down your throat waiting its turn, and its not like your local deli grabbing a number waiting to be served.
  14. xxKellsxx's avatar
    Author
    black gerbil1;2814240

    I thought my advice given to many members about food and exercise would … I thought my advice given to many members about food and exercise would be enough![SIZE="3"]Ha Ha![/SIZE]When you eat, your stomach releases hydrochloric acid to break down the food, your stomach is just one big bag, there are no pockets, so when you eat a meal then a piece of fruit, it will all get mixed.the Acid mixes with the food as it breaks down, then carried into the intestines etc etc. Fruit usually takes about 15-35mins to digesting depending on what type of fruit it is.it does not "lay on top" of the other food.



    Thank you that does make sense actually!:thumbsup:
  15. choc1969's avatar
    People need to remember....biology basics. Food takes at least 18 hours to pass through your system from consumption to excretion.....so in fact there is a layering effect if you eat 3 square meals a day. It doesn't all come out in one sitting.....lol unless you have a gastric problem.
  16. deleted52701's avatar
    choc1969;2814439

    People need to remember....biology basics. Food takes at least 18 hours … People need to remember....biology basics. Food takes at least 18 hours to pass through your system from consumption to excretion.....so in fact there is a layering effect if you eat 3 square meals a day. It doesn't all come out in one sitting.....lol unless you have a gastric problem.



    thats very debatable. Eat a banana on a empty stomach in the morning, and the sugar will be in your blood stream within 30mins.:thumbsup:

    from in to out, food times vary, not all will be 18 hours. Perhaps if you don't chew your food correctly, then maybe
  17. choc1969's avatar
    black gerbil1;2814466

    thats very debatable. Eat a banana on a empty stomach in the morning, … thats very debatable. Eat a banana on a empty stomach in the morning, and the sugar will be in your blood stream within 30mins.:thumbsup:from in to out, food times vary, not all will be 18 hours. Perhaps if you don't chew your food correctly, then maybe



    you know excretion means to poop ???? :whistling: I said nothing about the release of sugars etc
  18. deleted52701's avatar
    choc1969;2814475

    you know excretion means to poop ???? :whistling: I said nothing about … you know excretion means to poop ???? :whistling: I said nothing about the release of sugars etc


    yes, hence the "in to out".
  19. choc1969's avatar
    :giggle:
  20. xxKellsxx's avatar
    Author
    Thanks every one!
    Will have a read of that link later when little one goes bed!
  21. Mclovin's avatar
    dont eat apple seeds or a tree will grow in your belly!
    lol
  22. Walt-Kowalski's avatar
    choc1969;2814439

    People need to remember....biology basics. Food takes at least 18 hours … People need to remember....biology basics. Food takes at least 18 hours to pass through your system from consumption to excretion.....so in fact there is a layering effect if you eat 3 square meals a day. It doesn't all come out in one sitting.....lol unless you have a gastric problem.



    The vindaloo I had last night would disagree with the 18 hours theory

    [image missing]

    :whistling:

  23. Mclovin's avatar
    fox2020;2814665

    The vindaloo I had last night would disagree with the 18 hours theory … The vindaloo I had last night would disagree with the 18 hours theory :whistling:



    LOL.:w00t:
  24. xxKellsxx's avatar
    Author
    Mclovin;2814641

    dont eat apple seeds or a tree will grow in your belly!lol



    fox2020;2814665

    The vindaloo I had last night would disagree with the 18 hours theory … The vindaloo I had last night would disagree with the 18 hours theory :whistling:



    You two make me laugh especially after reading the infraction thread!!:w00t:
  25. choc1969's avatar
    chesso;2815160

    Just so you know - Poo is egested, not excreted and consists of … Just so you know - Poo is egested, not excreted and consists of indigestible food , gut cells etc and bacteria.



    Thanks for my new word of the day :thumbsup:
's avatar