Grammar Question - HotUKDeals
We use cookie files to improve site functionality and personalisation. By continuing to use HUKD, you accept our cookie and privacy policy.
Get the HUKD app free at Google Play

Search Error

An error occurred when searching, please try again!

Login / Sign UpSubmit

Grammar Question

dtovey89 Avatar
5y, 9m agoPosted 5 years, 9 months ago
Hi, just typed up a Uni presentation on the response of the press to murder and violent crime in the late 19th century.

One question - when referring to the Press do I use a capital 'P' or a lower cased 'p'.

I am normally quite good with grammar but this one is doing my head in. Surely as it is a noun (name of a specific thing) then it should be a capital 'P'?

Thanks for any help.
dtovey89 Avatar
5y, 9m agoPosted 5 years, 9 months ago
Options

All Comments

(30) Jump to unreadPost a comment
Comments/page:
#1
I would imagine it can be spelt either way - I myself would probably capitalise it, but since it is describing a collective group of nouns it infact does not need to be capitalised.

Edited By: tomwatts on Feb 24, 2011 23:54
#2
It will be much clearer and more sensible to have a capital letter to distinguish it from an ordinary noun or verb.
#3
P for sure
#4
Lower case, unless it is a newspaper called "The Press". Same for "Uni"

chesso
P for sure


Why? Its not a proper-noun...

Edited By: jah128 on Feb 25, 2011 00:01
1 Like #5
I've had a look on some online articles and the results are mixed.

The essay title is:
Examine the response of the press to murder and violent crime in the late nineteenth century. To what extent were such crimes considered to threaten the stability of society? In what ways did the press exacerbate existing fears?

The term 'Press' is indeed lower cased so I shall follow that pattern. If the tutor picks up on it then I'll tell her that the module handbook must be wrong too :P

Cheers for your help guys.
#6
Capital P as they are referred to as an entity.
#7
#8
jah128
Lower case, unless it is a newspaper called "The Press". Same for "Uni"
chesso
P for sure
Why? Its not a proper-noun...
Just have a look at the OPs first two sentences. Lower case p just looks and feels wrong doesn't it?
#9
Meh. Not really, "Uni" feels more wrong to me, but I think it is probably one of those that is correct/incorrect either way depending on the marker's frame of mind. By the 'rules' of English its not really a proper-noun though, so probably should be lower case...

It might just be that I'm used to York, but if someone writes 'The Press' that refers to the newspaper as opposed to the collective...

Edited By: jah128 on Feb 25, 2011 00:16
#10
Yes, 'uni' is the way to go. I wasn't thinking to opt for 'The Press' but 'the Press' to identify as a specific group.
#11
Nope, still going to go for lowercase, 'the journalists', 'the papers' etc. Its not a proper-noun, although I'd concur it is one that sort of works either way...
#12
As I said in #1 :p
[mod] 6 Likes #13
http://images.cheezburger.com/completestore/2010/7/15/0c0dfee9-7797-4e13-bfc8-d1fa31f42d19.jpg
#14
Ignore the grammar in the opening sentence of the OP lol - that was rushed.

When referring to the press I mean the press in general not a specific paper, etc.
Going for lower case although I would have probably used upper case if I didn't realise how it was phrased in the essay title.

Cheers for the input guys - this does seem a tricky one lol
#15
Well I just lost my latest reply but
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proper_noun

I feel that in most sentences where the Press is the subject then it should be a proper noun, also where it is named e.g. the British Press.


Edited By: chesso on Feb 25, 2011 00:44: ....................
suspended#16
maximoshark


I would be following the Oxford dictionary to be honest.
#17
chesso
Well i just lost my latest but

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proper_noun


I feel that in most sentences where the Press is the subject then it should be a proper noun, also wher it is named e.g. the British Press.


Hmm. Still don't really agree its a proper-noun, but it does seem one where both are accepted with close to equal weighting. Searching Google Scholar for both 'the press' and 'the British press' seems to bring a fairly equal weighting of results for capitalised and un-capitalised 'Press' [discounting journal titles where small-caps for major words within the title is the preferred form].

I'd personally still stick to lower-case as I consider it a synonym for both journalists and newspapers, as opposed to a proper-noun collective, but I think its fair to say either form is generally acceptable!

Edited By: jah128 on Feb 25, 2011 00:44
#18
jah128
Hmm. Still don't really agree its a proper-noun, but it does seem one where both are accepted with close to equal weighting. Searching Google Scholar for both 'the press' and 'the British press' seems to bring a fairly equal weighting of results for capitalised and un-capitalised 'Press' [discounting journal titles where small-caps for major words within the title is the preferred form].I'd personally still stick to lower-case as I consider it a synonym for both journalists and newspapers, as opposed to a proper-noun collective, but I think its fair to say either form is generally acceptable!

I think that's about the long and short of it! :)
#19
chesso
jah128
Hmm. Still don't really agree its a proper-noun, but it does seem one where both are accepted with close to equal weighting. Searching Google Scholar for both 'the press' and 'the British press' seems to bring a fairly equal weighting of results for capitalised and un-capitalised 'Press' [discounting journal titles where small-caps for major words within the title is the preferred form].I'd personally still stick to lower-case as I consider it a synonym for both journalists and newspapers, as opposed to a proper-noun collective, but I think its fair to say either form is generally acceptable!


I think that's about the long and short of it! :)


:)
#20
Lower case 'p' would be the correct way of writing it. Same goes for "uni" - you don't even write 'university' with a capital unless referring to a particular one (e.g. University of Somewhere)

p.s. if the essay title uses lowercase, then that should say it all really

Edited By: oldmanhouse on Feb 25, 2011 02:25
1 Like #21
is it only me thats gor a headache after reading all that

http://i237.photobucket.com/albums/ff69/KTQ_Sue/Stupid%20stuff/stress/stressreductionkit.jpg
#22
I would say capital P as you are referring to a group of people, if that makes sense :D
1 Like #23
nikkib123
I would say capital P as you are referring to a group of people, if that makes sense :D


It does, I referred to them as an entity, prob not the best word - but more of an organisation like the Police, the Government etc.
banned#24
Collective noun therefore P
#25
csiman
Collective noun therefore P


Really intrigued as to where this idea that collective nouns or groups of people are capitalised; I certainly was not taught that they were, and in general the Oxford Dictionary and sites such as the BBC seem to agree with my thoughts. You would generally use 'the police', 'the government' etc. An exception might be 'the Metropolitan Police' where the name is itself a proper noun, but when simply refering to a generic group, I don't see why it should be capitalised?

If you were referring to a group of builders you wouldn't say 'the Builders', so why would you capitalise police or press?

Edited By: jah128 on Feb 25, 2011 21:05
#26
jah128
csiman
Collective noun therefore P


Really intrigued as to where this idea that collective nouns or groups of people are capitalised; I certainly was not taught that they were, and in general the Oxford Dictionary and sites such as the BBC seem to agree with my thoughts. You would generally use 'the police', 'the government' etc. An exception might be 'the Metropolitan Police' where the name is itself a proper noun, but when simply refering to a generic group, I don't see why it should be capitalised?

If you were referring to a group of builders you wouldn't say 'the Builders', so why would you capitalise police or press?


Looking into it even more you seem to be correct.

A proper noun or proper name is a noun representing a unique entity (such as London, Jupiter, John Hunter, or Toyota), as distinguished from a common noun, which describes a class of entities (such as city, planet, person or corporation)
banned 1 Like #27
jah128
csiman
Collective noun therefore P


Really intrigued as to where this idea that collective nouns or groups of people are capitalised; I certainly was not taught that they were, and in general the Oxford Dictionary and sites such as the BBC seem to agree with my thoughts. You would generally use 'the police', 'the government' etc. An exception might be 'the Metropolitan Police' where the name is itself a proper noun, but when simply refering to a generic group, I don't see why it should be capitalised?

If you were referring to a group of builders you wouldn't say 'the Builders', so why would you capitalise police or press?


OOOPS! I did mean a small 'p' :|
banned#28
csiman
Collective noun therefore P


So if I'm referring to the people saying it should be a capital letter, do I call them 'Idiots' because that's a collective noun too?

Lower case. Ignore the 'helper'.
banned#29
FilthAndFurry
csiman
Collective noun therefore P


So if I'm referring to the people saying it should be a capital letter, do I call them 'Idiots' because that's a collective noun too?

Lower case. Ignore the 'helper'.

moral of this story is to read the whole thread to stop yourself looking rather foolish :p

irony galore at the 'helper' comment oO

Edited By: csiman on Feb 26, 2011 11:24
banned#30
If ever in doubt just refer to a source that you know will be correct. Google a sentence and refer to the quality essays, newspaper articles etc.



Edited By: Elton Chong on Feb 27, 2011 13:03

Post a Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.

...OR log in with your social account

...OR comment using your social account

Thanks for your comment! Keep it up!
We just need to have a quick look and it will be live soon.
The community is happy to hear your opinion! Keep contributing!