My 12 year old wants an mp3/mp4 player. I suspect it won't get used massively after the first month and therefore don't want to spend too much on a nano. So for him the screen size need to be reasonable and I have found an 8gb Samsung Q1 for only £40 and I thought this would be ideal but he has now mentioned an LG Cookie phone as this can play mp3/mp4 plus ofcourse its a phone. So is the cookie any good for mp3/mp4 or should I stick to a real mp3/mp4 player as they are better at what they do? All/any help appreciated. P.S I'm told the tocco lite is also reasonable but let me know..