Hooked on hotukdeals|Join HUKD!

Settle an argument for me.....how old are you when you're born?

realfriendlymanrealfriendlyman

I'm insisting you turn 1 when you have your first birthday but they're insisting the way Asians look at it, you're a year old instantly upon being born because "you're stepping into a new age"

What do you think, opinions of all races would be appreciated to settle the argument, so if you can say where you're from, your opinion and why, that would be great. :)

All Comments (89)

Jump to unread Post a Comment
    sassie
    just agree to disagree, it is not going to change who you are or how old you are
    realfriendlyman
    melipona
    If you were in your first year of school you would say you were in year 1, so you are in the first year of life.
    If you bought something and it broke before the year guarantee you would say it was under a year old.

    Both are truisms, but in the english culture and language you would only be 1 a year after you are born, before that you are less than 1 year old. Other cultures are also right from their perspective.
    A dog however is still 1 year old and not 7 :)


    A dog can't change the laws of time.....they just die 7 times quicker than humans.
    EN1GMA
    age is just a number......:p
    melipona
    The other others

    http://t1.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQNwSoSpObU288TfhM4nehOkI3E-2O4Oi_esEv8b0_Lw4zKgzCgONLS7TuEQA
    jonny619447
    When you are born its your 1st birthday, and when you are 1 years old its your second birthday.

    I'm from England, Athiest, and speak common sense.


    Edited By: jonny619447 on Mar 07, 2012 10:30: .
    dtovey89
    Misc needs F&F
    dxx
    dxx1 year, 3 months ago #27Show comment toolsReply
    Your friend is stupid.
    MinstrelMan
    realfriendlyman
    melipona
    If you were in your first year of school you would say you were in year 1, so you are in the first year of life.
    If you bought something and it broke before the year guarantee you would say it was under a year old.

    Both are truisms, but in the english culture and language you would only be 1 a year after you are born, before that you are less than 1 year old. Other cultures are also right from their perspective.
    A dog however is still 1 year old and not 7 :)


    A dog can't change the laws of time.....they just die 7 times quicker than humans.


    So if they're hit by a car, was the car going 210mph in a 30 zone?
    realfriendlyman
    EN1GMA
    age is just a number......:p


    I used to believe that but now that I'm in my late 20's....it doesn't quite feel like that....at least I'm looking younger now that my goatee is gone and being asked for ID again. :)
    realfriendlyman
    MinstrelMan
    realfriendlyman
    melipona
    If you were in your first year of school you would say you were in year 1, so you are in the first year of life.
    If you bought something and it broke before the year guarantee you would say it was under a year old.

    Both are truisms, but in the english culture and language you would only be 1 a year after you are born, before that you are less than 1 year old. Other cultures are also right from their perspective.
    A dog however is still 1 year old and not 7 :)


    A dog can't change the laws of time.....they just die 7 times quicker than humans.


    So if they're hit by a car, was the car going 210mph in a 30 zone?


    Exactly....and the blood trickles out 7 times quicker :p

    Jokes aside, my 3 dogs lived until the age of 6,8 and 11 with the latter being considered as very old for his breed and outlived his life expectancy but it doesn't mean that we had to celebrate his birthday every 7 and half weeks :P
    CrazyHorses
    I don't know why women lie and say they are younger than what they are. I tell people I am five years older and enjoy the compliments! :)

    As for being born a year old, that is not my belief but if different teluons or cultures believe otherwise then so be it.
    realfriendlyman
    funny.onion
    I don't know why women lie and say they are younger than what they are. I tell people I am five years older and enjoy the compliments! :)

    As for being born a year old, that is not my belief but if different teluons or cultures believe otherwise then so be it.


    That's true....how can they try to make you a year older and then lower there own age....I think my friend is purely trying to depress me about getting older. haha

    Well this is the thing, I am trying to findout if it's a cultural thing that they believe in making people older than they are...for me....I may be turning 29 next week but I look 21-25 :)
    csiman
    its called a Birthday for a reason. The anniversary of the day of your birth!

    To get really pedantic, you are generally 9 months old when you are born :)

    Ignore the Asians - they generally spout nonsense anyway ;)
    kllewis
    mumbojumbo
    In Chinese Astrology a person is a year old when they are born because they have spent a year in their mother's womb. It doesn't matter really of course, but it gives fortune tellers that extra mystique. :)

    my first kid was born 2 weeks late so 9 months and 2 weeks, no one has ever spent a year in their mother's womb,
    if you were born at around 9 months and you believe your age starts when you were conceived then surely that would make you 1 when you are about 3 months old in the rest of our eyes - not at birth
    darren9030
    A good friend of mine ( who is Polish ) has exactly the same theory as the Asians you speak about. Have argued the toss many times with her but she still insists she is right X)
    mosskeeto
    We always refer to birthdays as being e.g. 1 year old today so we refer to living years.
    CrazyHorses
    I have a question. My son was always the youngest in his school class. A few weeks after his birthday others would have their birthdays and be almost a year older than him. The older ones were noticeably more mature mentally and physically.

    If you have a very premature baby then their first birthday is recorded a year after their birth. I don't know anyone who has had a prem baby.

    Does a prem baby/child have a disadvantage when they start school?

    Not sure if I'm making sense!
    realfriendlyman
    dga
    jonny619447
    When you are born its your 1st birthday, and when you are 1 years old its your second birthday.

    I'm from England, Athiest, and speak common sense.


    True, same, same but only in your own version of reality.

    Born -- First year of existence -- First birthday -- Second year of existence -- Second birthday (and so on)

    Birthdays relate to the birth date, without the concept of zero the ternary based decimal system does not function.


    Yeah but despite it being your first year of existence, it doesn't mean you're a year old....if you said to me "I bought milk yesterday, this milk is already a year old" I would of told you to get it away from me before it implodes :p
    magicbeans
    true asians do this.....
    EN1GMA
    magicbeans
    true asians do this.....


    he means the other asians.......:p we're assimilated and go with the 'you're one after one year theory......X)

Post a Comment

You don't need an account to leave a comment. Just enter your email address. We'll keep it private.

I Approve
Your Comments On This Post
Comment Preview
Close

PRIVATE MESSAGE

Close
Sorry, you can’t currently send PMs. Once you’re a more active member of the forum, the PM service will be unlocked for you.
Welcome to HUKD!
Close
Join the Community