Basically I sold something on AVForums and now he has told me the game is heavily scratched there are minor cracks in the inner ring and also that it skips. I've never had any problems with playing the game never skipped on me. And I checked the game before putting it up for sale and before sending it off and it wasn't heavily scratched and there definitely weren't any cracks.
He's told a mod and we're discussing it, the buyer isn't even involved in the discussion and no-ones asked him for any proof just taking his word over mine (Which IMO is because I have 1 trader feedback and am quite new on there).
He also complained a day after he got it? So what's to say his console didn't scratch it and hes trying to claim or he already had a scratched disc and might be trying to switch it.
I'm worried about giving him a full refund and then receiving a disc that never had any scratches now with scratches which is then useless to me.