I'm looking at a few and they all seem to have pros and cons. Midnight Club LA and Fallout 3 receive suspect reviews, and RE5 doesn't come out till Mar 09 :-(
I want something unique ie. I have not played GoW yet, so I don't see a reason to get GoW2 right now. Left 4 Dead appeals, but I really wanted Fallout 3. Are the graphics really suspect, or is that just over-zealous reviews?