I am looking to block access to all social media sites, specifically, snapchat and instagram but regardless of what I try they are still accessible. Using the same approach I managed to block
google.com and it worked wonders but no clue why it is not working with the social sites.
The approach I am taking is.
1. Obtaining IP address of the site using terminal, i.e., ping
snapchat.com2. Navigating to IP and port filtering on my virgin hub settings and choosing protocol as all, source ip as all and inputing the ip of the site (216.239.36.21 in the case of
snapchat.com)
Has anyone been able to get it to work using this or a different method, it's making me go nuts
38 Comments
sorted byAlready tried that to no avail, still trying more though
Although it's very hard to block specific services while leaving everything else open, you just have to look at the threads on here about getting around blocks erected by big organisations with the resources to do it well like netflix.
Unless you're willing to do it the other way around and block everything except specified exceptions then this is best treated as a mild discouragement. Anyone with a small amount of knowledge or motivation can easily get around it.
I know, kids these days are getting very clever with these work arounds and these social media companies aren't very helping. They keep on bouncing different servers.
I know but you got to do what you got to do they know its coming anyways.
Done that, the lowest was 4+ and some of these apps are set to this limit. My main concern is blocking the websites.
Thanks I'll have a look.
Done all of that, I am with you for 'if you have brought up the child right...' But regardless of that, I'll have you know the influence these small brains get from the outside world far more weighs the upbringing on some kids.
I'm afraid that the adults are to blame for this when all the children see is their parents on their phones/social media all the time. People tend to think I am a bit peculiar as I don't use any dedicated social media apps at all. I'm really not interested in what so-and-so's dog got up to at the weekend etc. but a lot of people are obviously. I have better things to do with my time. I did try Facebook for about 3 weeks about 5 years ago and couldn't see the point in it at all. It is a serious addiction for many people though, akin to mind altering drugs in some respects. The cat is out of the bag I'm afraid with this. How many parents have smartphones waiting under the tree this Christmas for their kiddies? Quite a lot I would guess. Also, from a male perspective, it seems that it is women who seem to need that particular type of interaction more than men, although, of course, there are exceptions. I have seen plenty of young mothers semi-ignoring their children as they scan their phones constantly.
Completely understand where your coming from. I myself personally do not use ANY social media sites, just like you, don't see the need but it's extremely tough to get this into the heads of small brains. They just don't get it, no matter how much you try?
I have but its not blocking snapchat. I have tried various options on there too.
I did that earlier today but really if there is a way of doing it from network level that'll be better.
I dint think you can do it on the Virgin hub but you might be able to get a 3rd party router with the ability
I couldnt see any option for that either and was looking at a different router - do you have any suggestions?
I’ll have a look and if I find anything I’ll let you know
Thanks, I'll give it a look at as well.
when you have children you will understand the OP's dilemma. explaining to children why they shouldn't access something on the net will not work. to young children the dangers of something never frighten them until they actually experience the danger themselves. if they see their friends access these sites and nothing bad has happened to their friends then they will just dismiss anything you tell them as being made up, over protection or over controlling.
i don't have any children but i can still remember the way i think when i was a child and my parents telling me that i shouldn't do something meant very little, and any cautionary explanation from them was just dismissed.
Good luck with that, you dont have the slightest clue.
Whenever ive tried anything like that with my kids over the last 10 years they pay no attention and dont care, lately they just say "ok boomer" whenever i try to learn them anything or give them advice. Thats a phrase they've picked up from social media too, the children these days have no skills that we had growing up, show no interest in learning any physical skills like i did with my dad, the futures looking bleak really.
I ban them off phones and computers for being cheeky etc.. then the day they get them back the same thing happens, its like they dont learn how it works, just unbelievable and most parents i speak to have similar experiences.
Watching other people on social media is the main issue (edited)
If you look at a router that isnt provided by your service provider you will have a lot more features. I have a netgear nighthawk - you can go into settings and just restrict everything by category - one of which is social media. You can block the whole category, by time period, for certain devices or permanently, there are plenty of options and im sure other devices have this feature. The router will then look at how the request is categorised and block it every time the request is made, regardless of IP address changes and so on.
Outside of that Instead of punishing them by taking the device away when they misbehave, they earn phone time / access as a reward for good behaviour? When they behave they earn the phone, but don't take away if they misbehave as you undo the positive reinforcement. Its a subtle difference but a much better way of encouraging behaviours.
Do you have simple house rules like sitting at the table to eat with no phones during that time or TV in the background. Do you ban devices when out in public at a restaurant or cinema etc etc? Or do you sometimes opt for the easy option and just let them watch the iPad at the table that one day because its easier? If so you are causing the behaviour - as they know if they play up they will get the easy option next time too, or you normalise that the phone / device is a part of everything. Draw your boundaries and stick to them.
Unless you are willing to invest the time in educating why you don't want them to do it etc etc, just blocking it will encourage them more to want to access it - the forbidden fruit and all that. (edited)
You say 'when you have children you will understand the OP's dilemma' then go on to say 'i don't have any children'. So how do you understand the OP's dilemma?
As to wifi blocking, as has been mentioned they will drop off and use mobile data.
If you are looking for a router with more facilities, I have an ASUS and that allows url blocking. If you want to check that out, here is a link to the manuals. Good Luck.
asus.com/Net…al/
They dont have mobile data will look at the router.
Done the educating part but no luck - they just seem to follow whatever their classmates are doing.
No mobile data
Good luck with that, these apps are by design incredibly addictive