Amazon claiming I returned wrong item.

deleted1667304's avatar deleted1667304
Posted 29th Mar 2021
Hi all,

I purchased two 18TB WD hard drive from Amazon which had been substantially discounted.

A couple of days later, they went down further in the Spring Sale, so I opted to return them and purchase them again once I had received my refund. Please note, whilst I had opened the Amazon box, the Hard Drives remained unopened and sealed.

Yesterday I received notification that the refund for one of the drives had been refunded but that I would not receive a refund for the second as I had returned the wrong item. On contacting them, I was told that a different item was inside the second hard drive box.

I’m spite of advising them that they had been returned to them security sealed and exactly as they had been sent they are unwilling to refund me until the right item is sent, which I do not have.

A simple web search (and even posts on here) show that this is an issue prevalent with Amazon, especially with high ticket items/phones/computer hardware with people fraudulently returning items and them not being processed correctly. My purchase has been through many ‘hands’ so to speak, including warehouse workers, pickers/packers/ returns processors etc. so I am entirely unsure as to why the blame lies with me.

I am also reticent to do a chargeback on my credit card as I have quite a lot of ebooks/tv shows/audiobooks with Amazon which I will lose access to if my account is closed or such.

Any advice on how to get this matter rectified would be greatly appreciated.
Community Updates
New Comment

35 Comments

sorted by
's avatar
  1. BanditHeeler's avatar
    BanditHeeler
    Surely the onus is on them to prove you sent the wrong item? You can prove youve sent something in, they can't prove that what you sent in is the wrong item?

    I once ordered some washing machine sock bags and instead of 1 pack (4 per pack), they sent me 1 large pack of 4 packs, with 4 each, so 16 bags in total. 1 returned 1 pack for a refund and kept 3 packs, for free
  2. bigwheels's avatar
    bigwheels
    WOW,
    There is a post or two on here every week.
    People say im mad recording delivery to opening in one go and packing, sealing and weighing returns.
    Helps with these issues when you ask if they would like the video sent to them.
    Cant give a refund quick enough.
  3. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    Azwipe29/03/2021 13:55

    Have to admit i am always a little sceptical of these posts. Saying you …Have to admit i am always a little sceptical of these posts. Saying you don't understand why they would blame you is a little suspect, they are blaming you because you are the most likely person to have swapped the item. Not saying you have swapped it but you can understand Amazon suspecting you.


    You are entitled to your opinion but your opinion is nonsensical and quite frankly, wrong.
  4. Joshua_Blake's avatar
    Joshua_Blake
    Keep speaking with customer services, they're the only ones who can assist you. In future, take pictures or videos of the items before they're returned to prove authenticity. It's a shame this is a step we're forced to do because of their apparent lack of care, but if it means you get your money rightfully returned, then you'd want that peace of mind.
  5. Shure's avatar
    Shure
    Get Jeff on the case: jeff@amazon.com
  6. deleted2663551's avatar
    Anonymous User
    niconelove29/03/2021 13:46

    Order another and say it hasnt turned up, play them at their own game


    I liked your comment initially but as a laugh. I wouldn't recommend to do that because I know my colleague does Amazon delivery for pocket money. And they get charged full whack for any parcel missing, not delivered etc parcels. And they only make £2 or something. If it had been Amazon on the receiving end then I'd agree
  7. niconelove's avatar
    niconelove
    Order another and say it hasnt turned up, play them at their own game
  8. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    Joshua_Blake29/03/2021 13:06

    Keep speaking with customer services, they're the only ones who can assist …Keep speaking with customer services, they're the only ones who can assist you. In future, take pictures or videos of the items before they're returned to prove authenticity. It's a shame this is a step we're forced to do because of their apparent lack of care, but if it means you get your money rightfully returned, then you'd want that peace of mind.


    Thank you for your reply.

    I am in contact with their logistics department however I’ve read some customer testimonials of people who have been in the same situation I am in and they have been unable to gain any resolution as Amazon claim they have disposed of the supposed wrong item or they can no longer locate it. Not only does this seem extremely suspicious but I’m concerned this will happen to me too.
  9. sfndkks's avatar
    sfndkks
    deleted166730429/03/2021 13:13

    Thank you for your reply. I am in contact with their logistics department …Thank you for your reply. I am in contact with their logistics department however I’ve read some customer testimonials of people who have been in the same situation I am in and they have been unable to gain any resolution as Amazon claim they have disposed of the supposed wrong item or they can no longer locate it. Not only does this seem extremely suspicious but I’m concerned this will happen to me too.


    How do you think Jeff racked billions up?
    Hopefully it’ll get sorted for you (edited)
  10. deleted75953's avatar
    Anonymous User
    save yourself a lot of grief and email jeff@amazon.com it will be fixed in 24 hours normally.
  11. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    Shure29/03/2021 13:27

    Get Jeff on the case: jeff@amazon.com


    I have and it’s been passed to the logistics department.
  12. MungoSplodge's avatar
    MungoSplodge
    To be fair, they are just saying that is why this control is in place. Not specifically stating you have done it so hes not wrong is he.... or... unless you are saying that him saying you didnt do it is wrong.... which means you DID do it.

    Case closed, thank me later Jeff.
  13. Azwipe's avatar
    Azwipe
    deleted166730429/03/2021 14:08

    As I have said you’re entitled to your opinion but whilst others may do t …As I have said you’re entitled to your opinion but whilst others may do this I know I have not, hence saying you are wrong.


    I specified i wasn't saying you had done it, just that you can understand Amazons stance.
  14. chrb's avatar
    chrb
    It wasn’t worth trying to get a discounted price was it? You might end up losing out on this one or if you push it your account closed!
  15. rev6's avatar
    rev6
    chrb29/03/2021 16:34

    It wasn’t worth trying to get a discounted price was it? You might end up l …It wasn’t worth trying to get a discounted price was it? You might end up losing out on this one or if you push it your account closed!


    It was worth it if the process happened as it should. I'd do the same to be honest, If I never opened it.
  16. packard's avatar
    packard
    Ask for photographs of what they received. Are you 100% certain they have unwrapped your parcel ?
  17. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    packard29/03/2021 13:13

    Ask for photographs of what they received. Are you 100% certain they have …Ask for photographs of what they received. Are you 100% certain they have unwrapped your parcel ?


    I cannot be certain of anything as this is occurring behind closed doors at Amazon.
  18. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    sfndkks29/03/2021 13:19

    How do you Jeff racked up billions? Hopefully it’ll get sorted for you


    Very true!
  19. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    bigwheels29/03/2021 13:22

    WOW, There is a post or two on here every week.People say im mad recording …WOW, There is a post or two on here every week.People say im mad recording delivery to opening in one go and packing, sealing and weighing returns.Helps with these issues when you ask if they would like the video sent to them.Cant give a refund quick enough.


    It’s a shame you have to resort to that but can totally understand why you do!
  20. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    BanditHeeler29/03/2021 13:40

    Surely the onus is on them to prove you sent the wrong item? You can prove …Surely the onus is on them to prove you sent the wrong item? You can prove youve sent something in, they can't prove that what you sent in is the wrong item?I once ordered some washing machine sock bags and instead of 1 pack (4 per pack), they sent me 1 large pack of 4 packs, with 4 each, so 16 bags in total. 1 returned 1 pack for a refund and kept 3 packs, for free


    That’s the thing. As I said in my post, this could have been done during the manufacturing process, by someone working in the warehouse, by the person packing it to be sent to me, by however many people it passes through to get back to the Amazon warehouse, the person completing the returns, however for some reason the blame has been put onto me.
  21. BanditHeeler's avatar
    BanditHeeler
    deleted166730429/03/2021 13:44

    That’s the thing. As I said in my post, this could have been done during t …That’s the thing. As I said in my post, this could have been done during the manufacturing process, by someone working in the warehouse, by the person packing it to be sent to me, by however many people it passes through to get back to the Amazon warehouse, the person completing the returns, however for some reason the blame has been put onto me.


    Just demand a refund or proof otherwise threaten a chargeback. That's what I would do.
  22. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    BanditHeeler29/03/2021 13:46

    Just demand a refund or proof otherwise threaten a chargeback. That's what …Just demand a refund or proof otherwise threaten a chargeback. That's what I would do.


    I’m concerned that if I do a chargeback my Amazon account will be closed and I have lots of ebooks/audiobooks/tv shows I have purchased and I’ll lose them.
  23. Azwipe's avatar
    Azwipe
    Have to admit i am always a little sceptical of these posts. Saying you don't understand why they would blame you is a little suspect, they are blaming you because you are the most likely person to have swapped the item. Not saying you have swapped it but you can understand Amazon suspecting you.
  24. BanditHeeler's avatar
    BanditHeeler
    deleted166730429/03/2021 13:52

    I’m concerned that if I do a chargeback my Amazon account will be closed a …I’m concerned that if I do a chargeback my Amazon account will be closed and I have lots of ebooks/audiobooks/tv shows I have purchased and I’ll lose them.


    Threaten. It's up to you if you think the refund is worth it. Shouldn't get that far. Probably just needs a higher up customer service person to authorize the refund.
  25. Azwipe's avatar
    Azwipe
    deleted166730429/03/2021 13:57

    You are entitled to your opinion but your opinion is nonsensical and quite …You are entitled to your opinion but your opinion is nonsensical and quite frankly, wrong.


    How is it nonsensical and wrong? Are you seriously saying customers do not swap out goods and return them? Of course they do. It's far more likely than a delivery driver who could just swipe the parcel or warehouse staff being monitored with CCTV and having to pass through security.
  26. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    Azwipe29/03/2021 14:03

    How is it nonsensical and wrong? Are you seriously saying customers do not …How is it nonsensical and wrong? Are you seriously saying customers do not swap out goods and return them? Of course they do. It's far more likely than a delivery driver who could just swipe the parcel or warehouse staff being monitored with CCTV and having to pass through security.


    As I have said you’re entitled to your opinion but whilst others may do this I know I have not, hence saying you are wrong.
  27. deleted1667304's avatar
    Anonymous User Author
    Azwipe29/03/2021 14:19

    I specified i wasn't saying you had done it, just that you can understand …I specified i wasn't saying you had done it, just that you can understand Amazons stance.


    Apologies, I misread they end of your post. Of course I can understand but I can also be upset/angry when I returned it to them unopened and the security seals still intact.
  28. SpyJoe's avatar
    SpyJoe
    Did you pay the return fees and what reason did you state for returning the goods?
  29. Russ2626's avatar
    Russ2626
    Did they tell you what the wrong item was that they are claiming to have received?

    This is at least the third post I've seen on here in recent months of this exact problem with Amazon returns (I think the others were resolved by emailing jeff@amazon.com). (edited)
  30. deleted2663551's avatar
    Anonymous User
    niconelove29/03/2021 13:46

    Order another and say it hasnt turned up, play them at their own game


    Wrong item arrived, bath towel
  31. Robildn's avatar
    Robildn
    This is why I always open anything I get delivered as soon as I receive it, that way if wrong item/faulty/broken stuff is received you can call up CS and they will most likely resolve it straight away.
  32. Khuzama's avatar
    Khuzama
    Hello.. I am facing the same problem with Amazon.. No solution untill now.. Anyone can help me please
  33. Ja_hl's avatar
    Ja_hl
    Please help me, Amazon have done the same for me, they took my £300 and kept my returned item.
  34. Conkers816's avatar
    Conkers816
    Just wanted to add to this thread as well as it's just happened to me, although I've already received the refund for the item they're saying I swapped out.
    ninjatiger's avatar
    ninjatiger
    Same as me.

    Mines just as fun and no one wil listen I brought a wireless mesh (linksys mx5500) 2 pack it developed a fault so sent back u boxed (advised them of this) I now have a wrong item returned email and will be charged as they had pre refunded. The issue is the model they are looking for is mx5502. This is what’s on the box. The 2 corresponds to how many in the pack. I explained this to them but got a decision stands we are unlikely to respond further.

    No idea what to do. I have a ring alarm system and don’t feel chargeback and a ban will be a good idea. But don’t want to loose the money.

    I’ll def cancel prime and use them less after this though!
's avatar
Top Merchants