Do Heinz still do Mustard Pickle?

I was always under the impression that “mustard pickle” is American for “piccalilli”. I make my own as I like bigger chunks and it sweeter than the supermarket stuff. I love it and use white wine or cider vinegar instead of normal vinegar. Last years batch is gone so need to do another one. But I definitely don’t think they’re all the same!

looks like they stopped making it years ago

really not hard to making you own piccalilli.
bbcgoodfood.com/rec…kle

Morrisons maybe:

groceries.morrisons.com/pro…011

Also Sainsburys:

sainsburys.co.uk/gol…10g


I seem to remember also seeing the Heinz version recently in B&M, so maybe worth a try.. (edited)

yorkie1205/04/2021 08:54

Piccalilli is widely available in supermarkets and is virtually the same …Piccalilli is widely available in supermarkets and is virtually the same as mustard pickle.Read lessRead more

It’s not though I bought it and it’s nothing like it

Heinz sell a mustard based Hot Dog Relish which seems to have the same ingredients as their original Mustard Pickle (different to Piccalilli). You can buy from Amazon or US food import shops.

frrft05/04/2021 09:11

It’s not though I bought it and it’s nothing like it

I thought same as Bambibear that Mustard Pickle was just the US name for Piccalilli, maybe it's just the flavour of the Heinz brand you prefer, like people have their favourite brand of Mayo.

yorkie1205/04/2021 10:06

I thought same as Bambibear that Mustard Pickle was just the US name for …I thought same as Bambibear that Mustard Pickle was just the US name for Piccalilli, maybe it's just the flavour of the Heinz brand you prefer, like people have their favourite brand of Mayo.Read lessRead more

Possibly yes. Heinz used to do both mustard pickle and piccalilli so there was clearly a difference otherwise they wouldn’t have sold both. I can’t even describe the taste it was just perfection

Have you tried tracklements sweet mustard ketchup? It is lovely tracklements.co.uk/pro…up/

psychobitchfromhell05/04/2021 21:12

Have you tried tracklements sweet mustard ketchup? It is lovely …Have you tried tracklements sweet mustard ketchup? It is lovely https://www.tracklements.co.uk/product/sweet-mustard-ketchup/Read lessRead more

Interesting that looks v similar thanks

frrft06/04/2021 19:32

Interesting that looks v similar thanks

It is really really tasty.

FTCom05/04/2021 07:55

Morrisons …Morrisons maybe:https://groceries.morrisons.com/products/heinz-piccalilli-301331011Also Sainsburys:https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/product/chutney-pickle-relishes/heinz-piccalilli-pickle-310gI seem to remember also seeing the Heinz version recently in B&M, so maybe worth a try..Read lessRead more

I bought this a few years ago thinking it was mustard pickle but it’s not the same 🥲 I’m so gutted.

Piccalilli is widely available in supermarkets and is virtually the same as mustard pickle.

frrft05/04/2021 10:14

Possibly yes. Heinz used to do both mustard pickle and piccalilli so there …Possibly yes. Heinz used to do both mustard pickle and piccalilli so there was clearly a difference otherwise they wouldn’t have sold both. I can’t even describe the taste it was just perfection Read lessRead more

I like my Piccalilli but must admit I've never tried Heinz or their Mustard Pickle but if I ever see it on sale a certainly get some.

Haven't

FTCom05/04/2021 07:55

Morrisons …Morrisons maybe:https://groceries.morrisons.com/products/heinz-piccalilli-301331011Also Sainsburys:https://www.sainsburys.co.uk/gol-ui/product/chutney-pickle-relishes/heinz-piccalilli-pickle-310gI seem to remember also seeing the Heinz version recently in B&M, so maybe worth a try..Read lessRead more

Don't think this is the same stuff. Had the mild mustard stuff for years and it's slowly disappeared from shops. Last place I got it from was Tesco but they no longer stock it.

The Heinz mustard relish doesn’t taste anything like picallilli, it’s much more sweet and smooth and unfortunately Heinz has discontinued it, along with their tomato relish and ploughman’s relish, all 3 were staples in our larder and we’ve been buying all the old stock up at every B&M and pound shop we could find until now there’s nothing anywhere from what I can see. I think that Heinz mustard hotdog relish at the top of this thread looks like it’s similar so I’ll try it.

When I was younger, mum used to buy Barton’s piccalilli. It’s available in Iceland and Asda.

Picallili is chunky .Mustard pickle is smooth