Groups

    Any electricians about? Need help with problem with lighting circuit.

    I recently wired (with my dad's help!!!) a new light for a bedroom where there was no light before. When you turn it on the light starts to light up for a split second then gives up. If you turn it off again and wait a few seconds you can then get another split second of light by turning it on again! Can't work out why it isn't working? Surely there's either electricity or there's not? No circuits trip out or anything. I've replaced the bulb holder part (not sure what the technical name is) but that made no difference. Have tried different bulbs and again no difference.

    Is the problem likely to be in the switch, don't think either of us have changed that part. Only other thing it could be is the wires/wiring I assume but I really don't want to have to take the board up in the loft to get at it again.

    Any help appreciated.

    Thanks!!!

    52 Comments

    Sounds like some kind of trip which is reseting when you leave it off for a while. Recheck wiring. Check the switch to see if it has any electronics/dimmer circuit etc. Assume there was some kind of light somewhere as the switch was already in?

    Banned

    ide replace the switch, if that doesnt sort it then its gonna have to be the lifting of the floor boards

    the lights are on a circuit and if the correct wires are used it can send the circuit haywie different switches will control different lights and dim different lights

    Where does the supply to the light come from?

    p.s I wouldn't keep turning it on and off you could be shorting numerous wires out which could lead to the cables melting, fire and ultimately death. Don't want to scare you though. In fact take the bulb out for now as you don't kow whether it's live when off.

    Original Poster

    marmalade47;5641244

    Sounds like some kind of trip which is reseting when you leave it off for … Sounds like some kind of trip which is reseting when you leave it off for a while. Recheck wiring. Check the switch to see if it has any electronics/dimmer circuit etc. Assume there was some kind of light somewhere as the switch was already in?



    Totally new light, basically one big bedroom made into two. Not sure exactly how we did it but the other bedroom's light was done the same way and works fine.

    No dimmer stuff, very basic equipment (that's what she said!).

    Original Poster

    sassie;5641251

    ide replace the switch, if that doesnt sort it then its gonna have to be … ide replace the switch, if that doesnt sort it then its gonna have to be the lifting of the floor boards



    I think that's what's gonna have to happen. Just wondering if anyone knew why it was happening before I go replacing each but one by one!

    Original Poster

    the sedge;5641295

    the lights are on a circuit and if the correct wires are used it can send … the lights are on a circuit and if the correct wires are used it can send the circuit haywie different switches will control different lights and dim different lights



    Everything else works fine mate, just this switch only turns the light on for a split second.

    If it was short circuiting wouldn't the system trip out. From what I remember the whole thing is very sensitive so it would trip at the drop of a feather.

    Benjimoron;5641322

    I think that's what's gonna have to happen. Just wondering if anyone knew … I think that's what's gonna have to happen. Just wondering if anyone knew why it was happening before I go replacing each but one by one!



    Why do you have to lift floorboards, do you live in a bungalow/downstairs bedroom?

    Original Poster

    greg_68;5641307

    Where does the supply to the light come from?p.s I wouldn't keep turning … Where does the supply to the light come from?p.s I wouldn't keep turning it on and off you could be shorting numerous wires out which could lead to the cables melting, fire and ultimately death. Don't want to scare you though. In fact take the bulb out for now as you don't kow whether it's live when off.



    Been off and out for ages mate.

    Supply comes from the same place that the original light came from (and the same place the other bedroom's light comes from (which works fine)).

    If it was shorting wouldn't the system trip out?

    Original Poster

    thesaint;5641338

    Why do you have to lift floorboards, do you live in a bungalow/downstairs … Why do you have to lift floorboards, do you live in a bungalow/downstairs bedroom?



    Converted loft.

    Benjimoron;5641328

    Everything else works fine mate, just this switch only turns the light on … Everything else works fine mate, just this switch only turns the light on for a split second. If it was short circuiting wouldn't the system trip out. From what I remember the whole thing is very sensitive so it would trip at the drop of a feather.



    yeah it would trip the system in milli seconds what sort of light is it a ceiling rose type with a normal bulb or the new low voltage one

    Benjimoron;5641350

    Converted loft.



    So did you lift them originally? If so, then it shouldn't be too hard to lift again?
    Personally, I would start again from scratch.

    So you've broken into the circuit that fed the light in the next door bedroom?

    Original Poster

    the sedge;5641357

    yeah it would trip the system in milli seconds what sort of light is it … yeah it would trip the system in milli seconds what sort of light is it a ceiling rose type with a normal bulb or the new low voltage one



    Just a standard, haven't seen any new low voltage ones but this is the same sort of thing that has always been around.

    Original Poster

    thesaint;5641370

    So did you lift them originally? If so, then it shouldn't be too hard to … So did you lift them originally? If so, then it shouldn't be too hard to lift again?Personally, I would start again from scratch.



    They weren't there when we started the work!

    You need to check you have a crcuit with a meter or voltage checker. Circuit = live wire into switch, live out to Live terminal on light, other terminal on light to neutral. NB any metal parts have to be earthed. If your not sure get help from someone who knows, electricity can be lethal!

    greg_68;5641383

    So you've broken into the circuit that fed the light in the next door … So you've broken into the circuit that fed the light in the next door bedroom?



    if youve broken the circuit you need to bring a wire from the old light and then onto the next light in the circuit after the old light. i dont think you can just spur from the old light if you have then that will be your problem

    Benjimoron;5641403

    They weren't there when we started the work!



    No need for the exclamation mark, was only trying to help.
    Sorry you can't reply to this thread. :-(

    sorry not very clear forget what uve done you need to ... bring cable from old light into the new bedroom light and then from the new bedroom light take a new cable to the next light on the circuit after the old light and take away the old cable between the old light and the next one in the circuit.

    thats not very clear either ill try and think of a better way to explain

    right the circuit goes from the concumer box toone light to another to another etc and then back to the consumer box . you need to break that circuit with the other light so eg light A goes to light B then to light C. say you want to add a light between B and C we call Z . the main cable needs be taken away between B and C and a new one Btween B and Z and between Z and C is that easier to understand

    heres a link how to wire the rose and switch can be a bit tricky if youve not done it b4
    ultimatehandyman.co.uk/diy…htm

    the sedge;5641527
    is that easier to understand


    He's suspended, he can't reply.

    wow they suspend you for asking for electrical help now.:w00t:

    Man this sites tough.

    oh wot did he do wrong

    huh :?

    seemed an ok thread to me :thinking:

    I had the exact same problem with a low voltage light, turned out the transformer was faulty inside it.
    New transformer and light has worked ok ever since. :thumbsup:

    I recently wired (with my dad's help!!!) a new light for a bedroom where … I recently wired (with my dad's help!!!) a new light for a bedroom where there was no light before.



    Is the problem likely to be in the switch, don't think either of us have … Is the problem likely to be in the switch, don't think either of us have changed that part.



    If there was no light, what was the purpose of the switch

    Probably is the switch btw. Sounds like a bad contact that's making then instantly breaking.

    Shengis;5642323

    If there was no light, what was the purpose of the switch :pProbably is … If there was no light, what was the purpose of the switch :pProbably is the switch btw. Sounds like a bad contact that's making then instantly breaking.



    Yeah that sounds likely to me too, its probably 'making' as its partway pressed and 'breaking' when fully 'on'. Try pressing it halfway...

    But if they are low-voltage lights (ie halogen spots) then it may very well be the transformer/circuit internal to the light fitting :thumbsup:

    Banned

    is your dad an electrician then?

    Bit dodgy if not and would probably invalidate your insurance in the event of a fire etc

    dont the council have to issue a safety certificate these days for electrical work?

    Original Poster

    Shengis;5642323

    If there was no light, what was the purpose of the switch :pProbably is … If there was no light, what was the purpose of the switch :pProbably is the switch btw. Sounds like a bad contact that's making then instantly breaking.



    I mean as in I have replaced the light fitting from the one we put in first. ie I have tried 2 light fittings and 2 bulbs. I have only tried the original switch that we put in (for this light), I haven't tried replacing the switch but may do soon.

    Original Poster

    csiman;5642927

    dont the council have to issue a safety certificate these days for … dont the council have to issue a safety certificate these days for electrical work?



    Don't know mate, you offering to come fix it for me??

    Benjimoron;5651255

    I mean as in I have replaced the light fitting from the one we put in … I mean as in I have replaced the light fitting from the one we put in first. ie I have tried 2 light fittings and 2 bulbs. I have only tried the original switch that we put in (for this light), I haven't tried replacing the switch but may do soon.



    Tried bridging the wires at the switch? If it stays on the switch is ******ed, if not theres something wrong in your dodgy wiring. Lighting circuits are a pain.

    Banned

    Benjimoron;5651263

    Don't know mate, you offering to come fix it for me??


    no lol!

    I take it you used a new one way switch and the correct thickness of cable? I hope you didnt use mains cabling lol.

    tell you what mate
    im two years through an an electrician course and i still dont get it!!
    i think as THE SEDGE has said,check the site he said

    ]http//ww…:27


    i been following this thread,hoping i might learn sumtin
    but i agree,its probably connections IN the switch
    but f**ked if i know

    Original Poster

    csiman;5651874

    no lol!I take it you used a new one way switch and the correct thickness … no lol!I take it you used a new one way switch and the correct thickness of cable? I hope you didnt use mains cabling lol.



    Don't know mate, ask my dad!

    Normal standard switch afaik. Don't have a clue about the cable, although it's the same cable as we used for the other light and that works fine.

    Original Poster

    Shengis;5651304

    Tried bridging the wires at the switch? If it stays on the switch is … Tried bridging the wires at the switch? If it stays on the switch is ******ed, if not theres something wrong in your dodgy wiring. Lighting circuits are a pain.



    You mean just join the wires in the switch somehere when the power is off then turn power on and see if the light is on? Like doing a switch but manually?

    Banned

    actually Benji,

    I should have mentioned screwfix from the off.

    great forum with lots of pros on there with really quick and helpful advice.

    screwfix.com/tal…959

    Benjimoron;5651962

    You mean just join the wires in the switch somehere when the power is off … You mean just join the wires in the switch somehere when the power is off then turn power on and see if the light is on? Like doing a switch but manually?



    Yeah.

    Original Poster

    Shengis;5652260

    Yeah.



    Ah, good idea! Wish me luck, lol!!!

    Banned

    jeeps, the easiest way to check is change the switch, whats with all the faffing about
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Working conditions, workers rights. Standing at work causing pain. Is this …1020
      2. Legal advice?11
      3. Can anyone share their Sky Go with me for £7.50 a month?33
      4. Fitting a wired doorbell advice needed22

      See more discussions