bluetooth hardrive

Banned
I know you gonna laff at me but is there such a thing

51 Comments

:giggle:

Original Poster Banned

is that a no - lol

sassie;3400662

is that a no - lol



tosh, of course it's possible, works the same as a USB hard drive, except it's wireless.

While the concept might exist I'm not aware of any in general distribution so I guess the answer to your question is no - what is it you're looking to do?

John

Johnmcl7;3400721

While the concept might exist I'm not aware of any in general … While the concept might exist I'm not aware of any in general distribution so I guess the answer to your question is no - what is it you're looking to do?John



She's going to invent one:w00t:

The question is not as irrational as you think. Currently, it is not pragmatic because Bluetooth 2 supports 2.1 Mbits/s whereas hard drives (both PATA and SATA) have burst rates of around 50-60 Mbits/s and sustained speeds of around 30 Mbits/s. As you are aware and I believe this may have led you to ask the question (of which I deem to be very logical and cognitive reasoning on your part), bluetooth is used as a means for data transfer, Unfortunately current specifications are not suitable for hard drive transfer but watch out for the next official ratification (the version number has yet to be finalised) because this will support up to 480 Mbit/s which is also the maximum theoretical speed of USB 2. As this exceeds speeds of current hard drives, it is quite capable of supporting file transfers from hard drives.

jtx;3400749

She's going to invent one:w00t:



I lol'd

ElliottC;3400790

The question is not as irrational as you think. Currently, it is not … The question is not as irrational as you think. Currently, it is not pragmatic because Bluetooth 2 supports 2.1 Mbits/s whereas hard drives (both PATA and SATA) have burst rates of around 50-60 Mbits/s and sustained speeds of around 30 Mbits/s. As you are aware and I believe this may have led you to ask the question (of which I deem to be very logical and cognitive reasoning on your part), bluetooth is used as a means for data transfer, Unfortunately current specifications are not suitable for hard drive transfer but watch out for the next official ratification (the version number has yet to be finalised) because this will support up to 480 Mbit/s which is also the maximum theoretical speed of USB 2. As this exceeds speeds of current hard drives, it is quite capable of supporting file transfers from hard drives.



my head hurts now......

apple do them i think. recent advertising describing them as shoebox for storing memories wirelessly. google it.

MCH1;3400811

apple do them i think. recent advertising describing them as shoebox for … apple do them i think. recent advertising describing them as shoebox for storing memories wirelessly. google it.



Sounds like you're thinking of the time capsule? These are wireless but it's wi-fi rather than bluetooth.

John

Johnmcl7;3400843

Sounds like you're thinking of the time capsule? These are wireless but … Sounds like you're thinking of the time capsule? These are wireless but it's wi-fi rather than bluetooth.John



presumed they would be similar.

Nope - they use the same frequency (as do many other systems such as DECT) but they're completely different protocols which use different hardware.

John

Original Poster Banned

Johnmcl7;3400721

While the concept might exist I'm not aware of any in general … While the concept might exist I'm not aware of any in general distribution so I guess the answer to your question is no - what is it you're looking to do?John



transfer via bluetooth, i would have thought that was obvious - lol

It would be pretty slow so im guessing thats why none have hit the market. If it has to be wireless then a wifi drive would prob be the only option

sassie;3401365

transfer via bluetooth, i would have thought that was obvious - lol



Sigh...do you want help or not? Of course you're looking to transfer data but what type of data are you looking to transfer and between what devices? It may be you're wanting to extend the storage of your mobile phone or you're looking for a clutter free storage system for existing PCs. There is no obvious application of a bluetooth hard drive to me, if you let us know what setup you are trying to run then it may be possible to recommend a suitable alternative.

John

Original Poster Banned

Titchimp;3401388

It would be pretty slow so im guessing thats why none have hit the … It would be pretty slow so im guessing thats why none have hit the market. If it has to be wireless then a wifi drive would prob be the only option



this is gonna sound dumber than my op, but why would it need to be wireless

sassie;3401405

this is gonna sound dumber than my op, but why would it need to be … this is gonna sound dumber than my op, but why would it need to be wireless



You asked about a bluetooth hard drive, bluetooth is a wireless protocol which is why any other recommendation would need to be wireless as that was your request.

John

Original Poster Banned

Johnmcl7;3401397

Sigh...do you want help or not? Of course you're looking to transfer … Sigh...do you want help or not? Of course you're looking to transfer data but what type of data are you looking to transfer and between what devices? It may be you're wanting to extend the storage of your mobile phone or you're looking for a clutter free storage system for existing PCs. There is no obvious application of a bluetooth hard drive to me, if you let us know what setup you are trying to run then it may be possible to recommend a suitable alternative.John



oh john, lighten up, was only trying to be humerous, obviously unsuccessfully :oops:

Im not really trying to do anything, a friend has advised my daughter to maybe think about getting an extrenal hard drive to back up her new laptop, i got everything in it (blue tooth, webcam et) so she wouldnt have to keep pluggin unto the usb, as know from experience this loosens USB ports over time so just wondered if they did such a thing as a USB external hard drive :thumbsup:

Ok - that certainly makes plenty of sense, unfortunately we're not quite there yet. There is a wireless USB standard which is upcoming which would do what you want but it's not out yet. It may be available in small areas but it's not really the mainstream system it will eventually be. You do get wireless nas drives such as the Apple Time Capsule recommended above but these tend to be a bit of a hassle especially for a laptop.

While I agree it is good to be cautious with hardware I don't find loose USB ports to be a problem with any of my machines. The main issue is just being careful the device isn't knocked when it's in and the cable is pulled straight out or wiggled gently if needed. Personally I use a 2.5in USB portable drive to regularly back up my machines without issue.

John

sassie;3401435

just wondered if they did such a thing as a USB external hard drive … just wondered if they did such a thing as a USB external hard drive :thumbsup:



You mean bluetooth?

Original Poster Banned

Titchimp;3401465

You mean bluetooth?



ooops yes, gawd im such a div, no nned for a response we all know the answer;-)

Banned

sassie;3401435

oh john, lighten up, was only trying to be humerous, obviously … oh john, lighten up, was only trying to be humerous, obviously unsuccessfully :oops:Im not really trying to do anything, a friend has advised my daughter to maybe think about getting an extrenal hard drive to back up her new laptop, i got everything in it (blue tooth, webcam et) so she wouldnt have to keep pluggin unto the usb, as know from experience this loosens USB ports over time so just wondered if they did such a thing as a USB external hard drive :thumbsup:



get a NAS (network attached storage) and so every time she is connected to her home network (even via wireless) she can connect to the hard drive and transfer data. :thumbsup:


one like this: ebuyer.com/pro…482

Original Poster Banned

Aftr 10 months of pluggin and unplugging an internet connection into my laptop it hard to go back to have a new motherboard as the usb stpped working, and dont want this happening to daughters. So was just curous, im not techy minded and still dont get the wirless thing, sorry do you mean it connects to my laptop wireless..............this is where i got lost:oops:



Johnmcl7;3401462

Ok - that certainly makes plenty of sense, unfortunately we're not quite … Ok - that certainly makes plenty of sense, unfortunately we're not quite there yet. There is a wireless USB standard which is upcoming which would do what you want but unfortunately it's not out yet. It may be available in small areas but it's not really the mainstream system it will eventually be.While I agree it is good to be cautious with hardware I don't find loose USB ports to be a problem with any of my machines. The main issue is just being careful the device isn't knocked when it's in and the cable is pulled straight out or wiggled gently if needed.John

sassie;3401435

oh john, lighten up, was only trying to be humerous, obviously … oh john, lighten up, was only trying to be humerous, obviously unsuccessfully :oops:Im not really trying to do anything, a friend has advised my daughter to maybe think about getting an extrenal hard drive to back up her new laptop, i got everything in it (blue tooth, webcam et) so she wouldnt have to keep pluggin unto the usb, as know from experience this loosens USB ports over time so just wondered if they did such a thing as a USB external hard drive :thumbsup:




Now I know you are being humorous I am not sure if your original question was a very good question or you were jesting but regardless, I will answer your question with earnestness. A networked hard drive connected to a wireless router springs to mind. The drive will be connected to the switch on your router allowing any PCs connected to the network accessibility to the drive. If you search for NAS drives in search engines you will find more information about them. They are drives in an enclosure which contains a processor and an Operating System (usually Linux) which allows for networking features.

Another method is to simply network a hard drive that maybe installed or attached to another PC and allowing that drive to be viewable on the network.

Original Poster Banned

sorry yes, my originol question in the op, was dumb but i was being serious, i was jesting when i posted post 19, anyway thank you all for your feedback, will look into the NAS thing

sassie;3401542

sorry yes, my originol question in the op, was dumb but i was being … sorry yes, my originol question in the op, was dumb but i was being serious, i was jesting when i posted post 19, anyway thank you all for your feedback, will look into the NAS thing



It is actually a very logical question to ask - not dumb at all! I am sure the NAS option or using a shared drive from another PC provides the least fractious solution. Of course, both methods require, respectively, either the router to be switched on or the PC allowing the drive share to be switched on.

Original Poster Banned

only got a desktop it could sit with, but its rarely used. If it was set up through that and that computer crashed and lost everything on its hardrive would we also loose whats on the external one (sorry again im not very technical minded as you can see)

Banned

ElliottC;3401573

It is actually a very logical question to ask - not dumb at all! I am … It is actually a very logical question to ask - not dumb at all! I am sure the NAS option or using a shared drive from another PC provides the least fractious solution. Of course, both methods require, respectively, either the router to be switched on or the PC allowing the drive share to be switched on.



it's almost reasonable to assume the laptop would be connected to the internet.

imranmaz;3401596

it's almost reasonable to assume the laptop would be connected to the … it's almost reasonable to assume the laptop would be connected to the internet.



That isn't what I enumerated. I was suggesting that a server PC can be used wherby the laptop as a client to access the hard drive on the server PC.

What's going on here then :whistling:.

By the way ElliottC I think 30 Mbit/s is a little low for a hard drive these days, don't you think.

sassie;3401595

only got a desktop it could sit with, but its rarely used. If it was set … only got a desktop it could sit with, but its rarely used. If it was set up through that and that computer crashed and lost everything on its hardrive would we also loose whats on the external one (sorry again im not very technical minded as you can see)



Well yes and no. By the same token, a networked hard drive could develop a fault too although there's less risk of your router corrupting the hard drive than a server PC corrupting the hard drive. That answers the "yes" part but the "no" part is that data from corrupted or faulty hard drives can usually be recovered quite easily.

Original Poster Banned

ok, youve lost me again :oops:

abomination;3401622

What's going on here then :whistling:.By the way ElliottC I think 30 … What's going on here then :whistling:.By the way ElliottC I think 30 Mbit/s is a little low for a hard drive these days, don't you think.



Qhite right and well done for spotting the mistake!

Original Poster Banned

ElliottC;3401641

Well yes and no. By the same token, a networked hard drive could develop … Well yes and no. By the same token, a networked hard drive could develop a fault too although there's less risk of your router corrupting the hard drive than a server PC corrupting the hard drive. That answers the "yes" part but the "no" part is that data from corrupted or faulty hard drives can usually be recovered quite easily.



ermmm dont know if you noticed who the op is :w00t:

Banned

ElliottC;3401615

That isn't what I enumerated. I was suggesting that a server PC can be … That isn't what I enumerated. I was suggesting that a server PC can be used wherby the laptop as a client to access the hard drive on the server PC.



A server would use far more electricity than a nas. A nas is obviously the better option.

sassie;3401642

ok, youve lost me again :oops:



Effectively, a drive connected to your router could develop a fault too, just like a drive connected to your sever PC (via internal connections or external) but you won't necessarily lose all your data because this can be recovered by reconstructing the file structures, depending on the severity of the fault.

Essentially you have a server PC with a hard drive. As the nomenclature suggests this serves other computers by allowing connection to its hard drive via the network. Anything that connects to the server PC is the client as they retrieve data from the server. A NAS drive connected to a router operates on a similar principle whereby the router is the server (to all intents and purposes, a router is a PC as it contains an Operating System and a processor). Imagine a network whereby you have one computer (which can be your router) which serves everything that connects to it. It can be enabled to offer access of its connected hard drive to other machines connected to the network.

I've not really come across any decent current consumer NAS boxes, any time I read up on a certain one they seem to have various issues with speed, management and software support.

Another option if concerned about wearing out a USB port is to use an Express card USB adapter - if the USB port does break then you can just buy another express card. I would imagine the laptop has a slot for this, they just slide in and out as needed.

John

Banned

Johnmcl7;3401723

Current consumer NAS boxes are pretty awful in various different areas, I … Current consumer NAS boxes are pretty awful in various different areas, I don't think they're a great recommendation for someone who's not particularly technical.Another option if concerned about wearing out a USB port is to use an Express card USB adapter - if the USB port does break then you can just buy another express card. I would imagine the laptop has a slot for this, they just slide in and out as needed.John



but what if she breaks the express slot? :w00t:

I've found that once a nas has been set up they work pretty well unattended.

a even simpler option (sacrificing some efficiency/speed) would be to use an NDAS device.... and they usually have two keys that you can connecto to... one with only read access and one with read write... so children can view content and not destroy it at the same time.
Post a comment
Avatar
@
    Text
    Top Discussions
    1. ❅☁☁❅ I want☼to talk☼about the☔WEATHER☔no politics☃no religion❅☁☁❅18846061
    2. Xbox One X pre order £449.99 @ Game (out 9th Nov)2342
    3. (heads up) Mini SNES price finally dropped on Amazon pre orders33
    4. Just heard this...2 ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ congrats to all on 392k ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★7763841

    See more discussions