Call of Duty 4 or Battlefield Bad Company? Which is the better game?

COD4 or Battlefield BC? Which is the better game? Interesting discussions / views / moans / groans to follow.............. What's your opinion?

32 Comments

Banned

Never liked CoD4.. waiting on CoD5.

Bought BF:BC for the PS3, love it.. haven't bothered with SP... played MP for hours and hours.

(so much so that I'm not playing GTA IV much / at all now.... oh dear)

battlefield hands down.

Battlefield single playrs rubbish but multiplayers great

and when the downloadable content with the new game mode is released it will be even better

I'll be the first to stick up for COD4 then. Played Battlefield and just wasn't impressed.

COD 4 for me.

COD 4 by a MILE !!!

BF3 is nowhere near as good as BF2

COD 4 is the best game EVER ! Great single player mode (but short) - multiplayer online rocks !!!

CoD4, even though I haven't played it!

Haven't played Battlefield but i don't see how anything could be better than COD4!

battlefileds called a SANDBOX game, its like being in a real war with all the vehicles and 90% of the levels being destructable. i love COD4 but for war realism battlefield has it in the bag

Original Poster

I've now sampled the demo of Battlefield Bad Company (multiplayer). I have to say I'm impressed, and dare I say it, the game has the potential of taking me away from COD4. Judging by the demo, I wouldn't quite say the graphics match COD4, and movement and views aren't as smooth on multiplayer or singleplayer, but the gameplay offers so much more, without it being overly complicated. Even the extra option of using vehicles adds a whole new perspective to the game. Only being able to comment on the demo shows that the potential is huge. Only 1 map but it has been replayed more times than I can remember without getting the 'bored with this map' feeling everyone experiences in COD4. Just hope the full game is up to scratch............

easy COD4

Havince;2502797

battlefileds called a SANDBOX game, its like being in a real war with all … battlefileds called a SANDBOX game, its like being in a real war with all the vehicles and 90% of the levels being destructable. i love COD4 but for war realism battlefield has it in the bag



ummm, durning world war 2 40% of london was destroyed.
So having a sand pit with upto 90% doesn't seem realism...
Even nowdays maybe a factory or building, but unless they use BIG bomb, realisity ony under 10% of buildings get destroyed.
Its about the guy fighting the war not he building destroyed.
May it should be call battlefield demolision....
But fair point.... know what your saying

CoD4 wins, BF:BC's multiplayer is guff and single player campaign doesn't compete...

Battlefield.

Battlefield has all the great elements cod4 has , but also from other games.

Vehicles and destructible enviroments push it just out of reach of cod4.

Original Poster

Here are the opinions so far:-

Call of Duty 4 - 7 votes (9 including 2 who haven't played BF).
Battlefield Bad Company - 6 votes

Any more opinions?

cod4:thumbsup:

ChrisUK;2502614

COD 4 by a MILE !!!BF3 is nowhere near as good as BF2



hit the nail on the head there mate!

Havince;2502797

battlefileds called a SANDBOX game, its like being in a real war with all … battlefileds called a SANDBOX game, its like being in a real war with all the vehicles and 90% of the levels being destructable. i love COD4 but for war realism battlefield has it in the bag



LOL. Realism?

In battlefield the only game mode is to smash boxes and steal gold. This isnt three kings. I think if you want realism your playing the wrong game, yeah walls blow up, but they can also be drilled down with a Hand drill.

I will say COD4. I was a big fan of BF2 and i played BF:BC demo which was fun, but untill the new mode is released i will leave it

COD4 all the way if we are talking solo campaign. It had much more variety of enjoyable missions I'd say. To expand a little I got sick of constantly looking out for the gold boxes and pickups in BBC, it was a cheap way of extending the total playtime

battlefield. awesome online play and ok story mode! the online is not just good but it is actually very fun awell due to everything blowing up around you! i didn't even think about GTA4 or MGS4 when i was playing on it! and that is saying something! i have it for ps3 and it is great but i would advise you to get for 360 just for xbox live.

CoD4 is MUCH better

cod4 by far, but bf is good .. dont think they could of got it much better for a console. It would be nice if battlefield had some half sized maps for split screen too

Banned

Only played the Demo of Battlefield...wasnt impressed enough to buy

CoD4 for me

COD4...defo.

BF3 ends up being virtual jogging unless you are in a decent squad, rare though.

Can I say both? I've never really compared them. I like COD for its shear awesomeness, its always intense battles, the graphics, and the multiplayer works wonders.
But then I like BF cos its so cool! The town levels where you can run through houses clearing them with your squad, taking out walls with you. Or head to a quiet spot and hide and snipe. Or drive tanks through houses and obliterate everything within your path. COD is more of an out and out FPS, whereas Battlefield, funnily enough, is more of a war simulator...if that makes sense?

having played them both, call of duty 4 for me, no question

The best multiplayer out there

UT3 owns both Someone had to say it

COD4. No comparison for me. The destructible environments don't really add much to the gameplay in my opinion, it's just eye candy.

COD 4, BF Sp is pants

I do like BF.......it's a good game but not a patch on COD 4.

COD4 all the way....
Post a comment
Avatar
@
    Text
    Top Discussions
    1. ❅☁☁❅ I want☼to talk☼about the☔WEATHER☔no politics☃no religion❅☁☁❅18846208
    2. Just heard this...2 ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ congrats to all on 392k ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★7764302
    3. Sad Gazza anecdote August 8th 2017 - Beyond help?2235
    4. What do you feel like whinging about today?1917266

    See more discussions