Groups

    Calls for Jimmy Carr to quit after joke on forces' amputees

    Banned
    A former Army commander yesterday called for Jimmy Carr to quit for making fun of soldiers who have lost limbs.

    Patrick Mercer, Conservative MP and chairman of the Commons subcommittee on terrorism, said certain subjects should be instinctively "off limits" for stand-up comics.

    Carr told a 2,500-strong audience at the Manchester Apollo: "Say what you like about servicemen amputees from Iraq and Afghanistan, but we're going to have a (expletive) good paralympic team in 2012."

    Mr Mercer, who spoke to serving troops about the line, said they were "amazed" by it.

    "He was one of their favourite comics," said Mr Mercer. "He has spent a great deal of time with troops at Selly Oak and Headley Court, but that just makes it even more bizarre.

    "It's not funny and his career should end right now. I understand his desire to shock but there are certain subjects you can't make fun of and one of those is the sacrifice of our troops - especially this close to Remembrance Sunday.

    44 Comments

    Original Poster Banned

    mirror.co.uk/new…28/

    Bit of an overreaction no?

    Nothing should be off-limits.

    I hope they never listen to Frankie Boyle...

    Flodd;6690807

    I hope they never listen to Frankie Boyle...



    jimmy carr is an amputee, I mean where's his real face?

    Flodd;6690807

    I hope they never listen to Frankie Boyle...



    +1 :lol:

    If anyone has ever been to see Jimmy Carr / Frankie Boyle or similar, you know that no-one gets off lightly.

    The joke prompted a huge response on the Army Rumour Service website. One … The joke prompted a huge response on the Army Rumour Service website. One poster wrote: "I believe this was probably a line he picked up from Headley Court from the guys in rehab and so feels justified in using it."Many branded him "smug" but most agreed if the gag had been made by someone in the military it would be viewed as funny. One said: "It's not the joke that upsets people - it's because Jimmy Carr told it."

    Original Poster Banned

    whatsThePoint;6690817

    Good publicity for Jimmy, might go to his show myself now



    I've seen him a few times at shows and corporate stuff and he is very good value for money. Comes up with new material every year for a new tour unlike some comedians too.

    FilthAndFurry;6690867

    I've seen him a few times at shows and corporate stuff and he is very … I've seen him a few times at shows and corporate stuff and he is very good value for money. Copies material from viz, other comedians and tv shows every year for a new tour .




    Fixed that for ya :thumbsup:

    Laughing in the face of adveristy is a great English tradition; I dount it's the lads and lassies who have been injured that are complaining. they are off getting on with their lives. It is the folk in the media and MPs with tto much time on their hands that always complain.

    Banned

    just as hes been cleared in court of driving his bentley while using his mobile phone.....

    lock him up

    thanks to mr loophole for getting him off........apparently he was recording a joke into the dictafone in his fone..... not talking!!!!

    whatsThePoint;6691011

    No law against using a dictafone while driving and they would of had his … No law against using a dictafone while driving and they would of had his phone call records to check if the phone was in a call



    +1

    same as eating a sandwich etc

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691011

    No law against using a dictafone while driving and they would of had his … No law against using a dictafone while driving and they would of had his phone call records to check if the phone was in a call



    well we will never know......

    driving without due care and attention at the end of the day.......what a crock

    its all about the money and expensive lawyers......mr loophole;-)

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691047

    +1same as eating a sandwich etc



    haha you can get done for that as a guy did for eating a mars bar


    how wrong you are:)

    Banned

    personally think that without comedians like jimmy and frankie you wouldnt here about the bad things that happen as much, so they may joke but at least its gets people seeing the real world, jimmy does do loads of new jokes and one liners every tour which makes it great value for money and well frankie what what can you say about frankie he's a genius

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691101

    Mars bars are bad for you we all know that



    i know and ill take that as a swift u-turn:-D

    I cant help but think that jimmy probably got the joke from the hospitals that treat these soldiers. Has he ever visited them?

    Chidda;6691141

    I cant help but think that jimmy probably got the joke from the hospitals … I cant help but think that jimmy probably got the joke from the hospitals that treat these soldiers. Has he ever visited them?


    Yes he's done alot of promotional work with both military hospitals.

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691174

    No i take that as you've never adjusted the radio while driving, cut the … No i take that as you've never adjusted the radio while driving, cut the corner while turning, check your tyres every day as stated in your handbook, etc etc



    that aint driving with a mobile phone to your ear now is it.......:?

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691123

    What about all the jokes about people who have died, isn't that worst yet … What about all the jokes about people who have died, isn't that worst yet we all laughed at M Jacksons death, well apart from those who support child molesters



    to be fair that was really funny:santa:

    Suppose it depends how you take what's said to me he's saying well other people may make fun of unfortunate incidents but they're damn commuted tithe cause and it put in the olympics with all their training amputees or not the would win as their disability wouldn't affect them in the slightest

    that's how see it anyways

    casparwhite;6691068

    haha you can get done for that as a guy did for eating a mars bar how … haha you can get done for that as a guy did for eating a mars bar how wrong you are:)



    I'm not wrong at all, you fool, due care and attention yes but not comparative to the actual LAW of using a mobile phone while driving which carries a fixed penalty of 3 points at least.........

    maybe if you can stay in context you wouldn't look so 'clever' :roll:

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691362

    I'm not wrong at all, you fool, due care and attention yes but not … I'm not wrong at all, you fool, due care and attention yes but not comparative to the actual LAW of using a mobile phone while driving which carries a fixed penalty of 3 points at least.........maybe if you can stay in context you wouldn't look so 'clever' :roll:



    you implied you couldn't be "done" for eating a sandwich and you actually can

    end of

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691241

    Tecnically if you adjust the radio you are not in full control of your … Tecnically if you adjust the radio you are not in full control of your car so just like talking into a dictafone or eating a mars bar you are commiting a driving offence So yes its the same thingIn fact i would call tuning the radio more dangerous as you look away from the road



    so he got off when he shoudnt have then yes.......

    youve just proved my point:roll:

    whatsThePoint;6691011

    No law against using a dictafone while driving and they would of had his … No law against using a dictafone while driving and they would of had his phone call records to check if the phone was in a call

    Im going to see Jimmy tonight.
    Cant wait, the guy is class!!!!

    casparwhite;6691401

    you implied you couldn't be "done" for eating a sandwich and you actually … you implied you couldn't be "done" for eating a sandwich and you actually canend of



    quote my implication of no guilt for eating a sandwich while driving........what was that oh yeah end of

    :roll:

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691436

    quote my implication of no guilt for eating a sandwich while … quote my implication of no guilt for eating a sandwich while driving........what was that oh yeah end of:roll:



    what are you babbleing on about now.........you've lost me?

    you were wrong take it on the chin and move on......

    casparwhite;6691458

    what are you babbleing on about now.........you've lost me?you were wrong … what are you babbleing on about now.........you've lost me?you were wrong take it on the chin and move on......



    lolzer

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691470

    lolzer



    winner i think you'll find.....saved himsen a £60 fine and 3 points
    http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2009/10/16/article-0-06D9724F000005DC-900_468x430.jpg

    lol you need to look up context and understand its definition, I've obviously rocked the caspar

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691503

    He was charged will making a call while driving, not the same as charging … He was charged will making a call while driving, not the same as charging him with using a dictaponeSo are you saying if your charged with something you didn't do, you should be found guilty



    im saying if he didnt have an expensive lawyer, like mr average joe public then he would've taken it on the chin

    celebrities would rather spend thousands on a solicitor to get them off......its a joke

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691519

    lol you need to look up context and understand its definition, I've … lol you need to look up context and understand its definition, I've obviously rocked the caspar



    still dont know what u are on about.....gonna have to spell it out for me

    "+1 same as eating a sandwich" doesnt quite get me rocking

    casparwhite;6691534

    im saying if he didnt have an expensive lawyer, like mr average joe … im saying if he didnt have an expensive lawyer, like mr average joe public then he would've taken it on the chincelebrities would rather spend thousands on a solicitor to get them off......its a joke



    True maybe,
    But if you had loads of cash you would do the same!!

    Can't knock him for it really!

    casparwhite;6691558

    still dont know what u are on about.....gonna have to spell it out for … still dont know what u are on about.....gonna have to spell it out for me"+1 same as eating a sandwich" doesnt quite get me rocking



    lol I've not had the pleasure of such wit since Sesame Street

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691609

    lol I've not had the pleasure of such wit since Sesame Street



    i see you've moved onto "the muppets" these days:)

    Oh its silly and all armless fun.

    but seriously people with problems limbs missing, blind, ill , all sorts are quite happy to joke about it.

    casparwhite;6691616

    i see you've moved onto the muppets these days:)



    ouch you cut me there

    It's the drugs.....

    Banned

    Alfonse;6691634

    ouch you cut me there



    lolzer

    Err......

    Have they never heard Jimmy Carr's stand up routine before?

    If an amputee joke gets him this riled up I dread to think what would happen if he heard some of his more extreme jokes.

    Banned

    whatsThePoint;6691781

    LOL your really missing the pointHe was charged will something he didn't … LOL your really missing the pointHe was charged will something he didn't do and you've spat your dummy because he wasn't falsely convicted



    i think you are buddy...... i made a flippant comment ....."lock him up"

    you took me seriously.....i had some fun

    now im bored.....run along little boy:santa:

    dark humour - you gotta love it
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Microsoft Gamescom - Possibly more free games / Project Scorpio44
      2. ❅☁☁❅ I want☼to talk☼about the☔WEATHER☔no politics☃no religion❅☁☁❅18846165
      3. Just heard this...2 ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★ congrats to all on 392k ★★★★★★★★★★★★★★7764205
      4. How dangerous is Donald trump?31136

      See more discussions