Groups
    EXPIRED

    Can anyone recommend some cat food for fussy cats?

    My cat is being really fussy with the wet cat food at the moment.
    She won't touch the felix, whiskers, gourmet (the ones with chunks, though she might nibble the fishy pate ones) and other supermarket ones. Up until a few months ago she loved them, so long as we rotated brands every few weeks, but now she sniffs it and looks at me like I've given her a pile of poo to eat.
    She will happily eat freshly cooked chicken, pheasant, meaty leftovers etc. and is eating the dry food so it's not that she's off her food, just she's being fussy and stubborn. She's old so I'm happy to give in to her, so if you have any any recommendations on wet food for fussy cats it would be appreciated.
    She loves the applaws food but at 90p a sachet and 4 - 5 sachets a day it'd be cheaper to cook fresh food for her.

    26 Comments

    Banned

    Just tell them to stay out of my garden

    Original Poster

    churchill

    Just tell them to stay out of my garden



    OK, I'll tell her not to go on a dirty weekend to Blackpool so she can sh*t in your garden.

    Don't have a cat myself, but encore looks tasty!

    The only one you haven't listed my cats likes are the sainsburys own brand chicken cat food very surprised at this , also have you tryed the whiskers oh so fishy and meaty?

    Original Poster

    MrBuck

    The only one you haven't listed my cats likes are the sainsburys own … The only one you haven't listed my cats likes are the sainsburys own brand chicken cat food very surprised at this , also have you tryed the whiskers oh so fishy and meaty?



    Tried the whiskers oh so fishy and the felix as good as it looks and no joy, just boxes piling up of food she won't eat soon to be donated to the cat's protection. I think we spoilt her with some applaws food when it was on offer and she realised what she could be having X) She's just not having any of the cheaper foods now and we don't have a Sainsburys near otherwise I'd buy some single sachets and see if it'd tempt her.

    Thanks chuckiedoll for the encore tip, it looks like the applaws but a bit cheaper (I know, it's not all about price but I'd rather not be spending near £5 a day on food for the cat).

    Fussy cat = cat that has been spoiled by owner.

    Starve cat for a few days. Result = non fussy cat that will be glad to eat anything.

    Problem solved... end of thread
    Edited by: "modoc" 8th May 2012

    Have you tried Sheba? Quite a few special offers on at Tesco atm

    tesco.com/gro…eba

    Original Poster

    realblender

    Very different to normal cat … Very different to normal cat foodhttp://www.mysupermarket.co.uk/asda-compare-prices/cat_food/feline_fayre_simply_tuna_in_jelly_4x170g.htmlor just tinned tuna rinsed in tap water



    We only have a Tesco near us (or Waitrose)
    Oooh, maybe M&S do one, might be worth a look.

    We tried her with the tinned tuna but she gets bored quickly. Seriously, it's like having a fussy child in the house

    Banned

    My cat doesn't like the expensive catfood out there, he just seems addicted to tinned whiskas , especially supermeat, when I open up a tin of that stuff he goes mental ! Cats do seem to go round and round with their tastes so you should keep the food for a few months

    Original Poster

    modoc

    Fussy cat = cat that has been spoiled by owner.Starve cat for a few days. … Fussy cat = cat that has been spoiled by owner.Starve cat for a few days. Result = non fussy cat that will be glad to eat anything.Problem solved... end of thread



    I would normally agree but we've had a meeting of stubbornness and she's refused to eat wet food for 4 days (I've put it out fresh for her 3x a day since Friday), she won't even look at it and I'm fed up of her yowling. Plus she's old and I feel mean and the poor birds are suffering as she just goes on a rampage killing spree - there was even a baby rabbit on the doorstep this morning which the dog promptly swallowed and puked up on the carpet so, well, it's time to give in!

    My cat eats anything. No food is safe from her tasting and usually eating. She once ate two chocolate croissants that my daughter accidently left out in a plastic bag.

    My cat was forced to live outside by her previous owners which is why I think she is so greedy now.

    I would persevere with a cat food you are happy with unless your cat has an underlying medical problem which affects her taste and/or smell.


    modoc

    Fussy cat = cat that has been spoiled by owner.Starve cat for a few days. … Fussy cat = cat that has been spoiled by owner.Starve cat for a few days. Result = non fussy cat that will be glad to eat anything.Problem solved... end of thread



    Couldnt do that with my cat her meowing would drive me mad

    My mums cat won't eat anything but the Aldi catfood! Sheba, felix, Whiskas, Kitekat etc... all rejected for Aldi's own food.

    Clearly fussy, clearly Irish

    whatsThePoint

    i make my own in the blender using mice



    Well trained mice!

    [img]d4k7s9ho8qact.cloudfront.net/wp-…jpg?9d7bd4[/img]

    "What would you like us to blend tonight, 'puss?"

    Original Poster

    funny.onion

    My cat eats anything. No food is safe from her tasting and usually … My cat eats anything. No food is safe from her tasting and usually eating. She once ate two chocolate croissants that my daughter accidently left out in a plastic bag.My cat was forced to live outside by her previous owners which is why I think she is so greedy now.I would persevere with a cat food you are happy with unless your cat has an underlying medical problem which affects her taste and/or smell.



    Awww, mine was a rescue cat and she's always been happy with whatever food we give her so long as it's rotated every few weeks.
    She's been off the felix/whiskars stuff for over a month so it's not a whim and she's sticking to it so it's time to give in to her but finding a food she likes is proving damned hard. I think she'd like to be fed on fresh chicken and meats with rice - she loves rice - forever but there's enough people and meals to cook anyway and it seems a bit too precious to cook something especially for her.

    Original Poster

    Mikethemanc

    My mums cat won't eat anything but the Aldi catfood! Sheba, felix, … My mums cat won't eat anything but the Aldi catfood! Sheba, felix, Whiskas, Kitekat etc... all rejected for Aldi's own food. Clearly fussy, clearly Irish



    Thanks will try some next time in Aldi.

    Banned

    mine also likes the skin of cooked salmon, chicken, raw bacon rind, butter and cheese slices

    Original Poster

    goldmax

    mine also likes the skin of cooked salmon, chicken, raw bacon rind, … mine also likes the skin of cooked salmon, chicken, raw bacon rind, butter and cheese slices



    Yep, it's just plain nasty when someone hasn't put the lid on the butter dish and you can see she's had a go at it.
    It's a battle between the dog and the cat as to who gets which meaty leftovers, the girls in the house give them to the cat and the boys in the house give them to the dog. You've got to be stealth-like to get in there first and try and hide it 'no, there wasn't any skin left from the chicken' 'oh, we must have finished it last night'. Sadly the cat doesn't understand the need for speed like the dog does so us girlies have been busted a few times.

    I had the same problem,but now feed my cat with go cat dry food.she love's it

    If she is old then I would cook a large amount of rice and chicken etc in one go then freeze portions. She will be happy and it will be more cost effective for you.

    It could be that her taste buds and smell are not the same anymore so she is not being fussy for the sake of it.

    Original Poster

    funny.onion

    If she is old then I would cook a large amount of rice and chicken etc in … If she is old then I would cook a large amount of rice and chicken etc in one go then freeze portions. She will be happy and it will be more cost effective for you.It could be that her taste buds and smell are not the same anymore so she is not being fussy for the sake of it.



    I've been trying this, well, freezing leftover rice and so far she's happy with it.
    I recon it isn't just fussiness but as she'll eat the Gourmet salmon pate when she's in the mood I recon she's a little bit fussy. Plus the daily death trail she leaves on the doormat she's not as old and doddery as she makes out. She's hugely loved and I don't like hearing her yowl for food, makes me feel like a mean cow.

    Hi SS,
    my cat is really fussy too. When she was a kitten she did not like wet food, so I used to give her just dry food. Now she has got older and has discovered rats and hunting I've had to put wet food down again. I still give her dry but I give her sheba every other day as like a treat.
    Do you give your car dry food too?
    Maybe try it and then give him/her wet food once a day and see?
    Might sound silly but it worked for me.
    x

    funny.onion

    If she is old then I would cook a large amount of rice and chicken etc in … If she is old then I would cook a large amount of rice and chicken etc in one go then freeze portions. She will be happy and it will be more cost effective for you.It could be that her taste buds and smell are not the same anymore so she is not being fussy for the sake of it.


    I think this is what happened to my cat. Her taste bud chnaged when she started hunting and now she doesn't feel satified on just dry food.

    mine loves lidl's wet food..:3 tried it?

    Original Poster

    cloudbusting

    Hi SS,my cat is really fussy too. When she was a kitten she did not like … Hi SS,my cat is really fussy too. When she was a kitten she did not like wet food, so I used to give her just dry food. Now she has got older and has discovered rats and hunting I've had to put wet food down again. I still give her dry but I give her sheba every other day as like a treat.Do you give your car dry food too?Maybe try it and then give him/her wet food once a day and see?Might sound silly but it worked for me.x



    There's always dry food available and wet food on a demand basis, ie she meows by the food and we take the hint X)
    It happened instantly, one day she was enjoying felix, the next day she was hungry but wanted something else.
    Thanks Sam, I'll try Lidl food and if no luck I think it might be a matter of cooking up food and freezing it for her but there's no way of knowing she's getting all the nutrition she needs which is another reason I wasn't sure about this. I want her to have strong bones and good eyesight so she can have many more happy years of pottering about the house and garden, living a fab life.

    my cat loves aldi one too.especially the jelly variety.failing that try tuna in spring water,get gu deals on it sumtimes.
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Apple Watch Series 3 EE Contract Cost518
      2. Ditched Sky55
      3. Minecraft Foam Diamond Pickaxe - Source?22
      4. Should I buy brand new wd drive without warranty on ebay1016

      See more discussions