Groups

    Can anyone tell me which one of these is better please?

    Hi, its my birthday in a couple of weeks and thought i might get a cheap camcorder off my parents. I have seen these two ones below, could anyone tell me which one is better and why? Also the pros and cons of each if possible. Rep will be left for any help.

    Thanks guys

    additionsdirect.co.uk/rf/…esc
    or
    additionsdirect.co.uk/rf/…esc

    10 Comments

    I'd go for the SD card one (No.1) . It will be easier to store your movies, I have one of the others (mini DV) and it takes time to record and keep what I record.

    PS. It is obviously easier to carry extra SD cards than tapes

    Original Poster

    Predikuesi;4013724

    I'd go for the SD card one (No.1) . It will be easier to store your … I'd go for the SD card one (No.1) . It will be easier to store your movies, I have one of the others (mini DV) and it takes time to record and keep what I record.PS. It is obviously easier to carry extra SD cards than tapes



    Yeh i was thinking that, I was wondering which one had better quality as well? Do you know?
    Also im a complete newbie to camcorders so if i did go for the mini dv one, how would i get them onto DVD's? Im confused. Obviously if i got the sd one i could do it all easy on my pc but the whole mini dv thing is confusing me.
    Thanks for the help. Rep added.

    The ]Praktica one is HD, while the ]Canon is standard, so the first one again.

    Too much time (and cables) with the mini DV.


    I have ruined so many DVDs trying to burn movies with my PC, I just use a DVD recorder, much easier and less time consuming. With this method, if you can use a DVD, then you cannot go wrong. Never had a ruined DVD disc since.

    Banned

    mini dv one looks much better as 35x zoom is great. 5x is rubbish.

    also cam 2 has image stabilisation which is essential unless on a tripod (imho of course).

    mini dv holds 60 mins per tape and they are very small. easy to transfer to pc too. Check you have a firewire port on your pc

    2gb sd card wouldn't hold much I believe.

    Original Poster

    Predikuesi;4013801

    The ]Praktica one is HD, while the ]Canon is standard, so the first one … The ]Praktica one is HD, while the ]Canon is standard, so the first one again.Too much time (and cables) with the mini DV.I have ruined so many DVDs trying to burn movies with my PC, I just use a DVD recorder, much easier and less time consuming. With this method, if you can use a DVD, then you cannot go wrong. Never had a ruined DVD disc since.



    Thats great thanks so much, i did think that when i saw it was HD but it confused me because the other one has a higher normal price by £30.00 i think it was so i thought maybe that one was better. Thanks again. I tried to rep you but need to spread some around 1st. Thanks again.

    Original Poster

    csiman;4013821

    cam … cam 2http://www.additionsdirect.co.uk/rf/add/p.do?categoryId=8231063&productPos=2&catno=PM0331D&groupId=527161840&pageSize=12&priceOrder=desc



    csiman;4013838

    mini dv one looks much better as 35x zoom is great. 5x is rubbish.also … mini dv one looks much better as 35x zoom is great. 5x is rubbish.also cam 2 has image stabilisation which is essential unless on a tripod (imho of course).mini dv holds 60 mins per tape and they are very small. easy to transfer to pc too. Check you have a firewire port on your pc2gb sd card wouldn't hold much I believe.



    Ok so a complete different side of opinion on this then. Oh dear im so confused, lol. Lets see what other peoples opinions are then i will decide. Thanks, repped!

    Banned

    then again the praktica is HD (5mp) as opposed to 0.8 on the canon.

    canon is a brilliant SD camcorder (up to 1000x digital zoom)

    praktica is a low budget HD cam.

    hard to compare the two really

    Original Poster

    csiman;4013873

    then again the praktica is HD (5mp) as opposed to 0.8 on the canon.canon … then again the praktica is HD (5mp) as opposed to 0.8 on the canon.canon is a brilliant SD camcorder (up to 1000x digital zoom)praktica is a low budget HD cam.hard to compare the two really



    Thanks, im so confused but at least i know there is good reason to be confused, lol.
    Well in all honest which one would u go for? I probably wont even use it much at all thats why im not getting an expensive one, but i'd just like one if an occasion ever came up.
    When i have children or something i will probably upgrade it and get a decent one but at the moment that would be a waste of money to me.
    Thanks.
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. One for the mathmaticians3050
      2. Bearded chat917
      3. What would be HELL to you?3459
      4. word association Game74044582

      See more discussions