Found 14th Nov 2008
Was just wondering what people prefered out of these two games.

IMHO i think that cod 4 is much better i mean dogs after 7 kills on cod 5 wtf?!

I also think the whole modern warfare theme is much better?

All opinions welcome :-)

  1. Misc
  2. Call
  3. Xbox
25 Comments

Not played my copy of 5 yet, though I hated the dogs in the beta....

Btw I was hoping someone would post a COD thread. I've been looking for one

I havent tried cod 5 and i dont plan to buy it.

I much prefer modern warfare. Cooler equipment etc.

robtallica;3459913

Not played my copy of 5 yet, though I hated the dogs in the beta....Btw I … Not played my copy of 5 yet, though I hated the dogs in the beta....Btw I was hoping someone would post a COD thread. I've been looking for one



Happy COD Day :thumbsup:

Got it but not played it yet, Just loving Kiefer Sutherlands : " OUTFU**ING-STANDING MARINES"

I'm about 75% through the campaign and I think the campaign is as good in CoD5 as it was in CoD4, plus the flamethrower is a cool weapon. Nothing as cool as the helicopter level though

Multiplayer not as good on CoD5 though although there does seem to be less lag, not that it was really a problem in CoD4.

Original Poster

MCH1;3459917

I havent tried cod 5 and i dont plan to buy it.I much prefer modern … I havent tried cod 5 and i dont plan to buy it.I much prefer modern warfare. Cooler equipment etc.



I know what you mean, i loved the barrat etc on modern warfare but now u get something that looks like hypnodisk from robot wars ( if anyone knows what i mean ) lol

I've only played the demo for COD5 but so far I prefer COD4, it plays ok it just feels I dunno kinda like a step backwards just like it's Call of Duty Lite I would say i'm sticking with COD4 but I think Left 4 Dead is going to steal my live time.

I played the COD4 Beta loads and loved it, just waiting for the price to drop to sub £20 before I buy it. Played the COD5 Beta twice and lost interest, just didn't have the same feel to it, it seemed somehow rougher around the edges. I'm sure people who've played the full versions (is COD5 out now?) will be able to give a better comparison!

Boylin;3459939

I'm about 75% through the campaign and I think the campaign is as good in … I'm about 75% through the campaign and I think the campaign is as good in CoD5 as it was in CoD4, plus the flamethrower is a cool weapon. Nothing as cool as the helicopter level though :(Multiplayer not as good on CoD5 though although there does seem to be less lag, not that it was really a problem in CoD4.



geeze savour the flavour much?

chrishill;3459954

I played the COD4 Beta loads and loved it, just waiting for the price to … I played the COD4 Beta loads and loved it, just waiting for the price to drop to sub £20 before I buy it. Played the COD5 Beta twice and lost interest, just didn't have the same feel to it, it seemed somehow rougher around the edges. I'm sure people who've played the full versions (is COD5 out now?) will be able to give a better comparison!



Just get COD4! you wont regret it! dont know anyone who doesnt like it! :thumbsup:

Original Poster

chrishill;3459954

I played the COD4 Beta loads and loved it, just waiting for the price to … I played the COD4 Beta loads and loved it, just waiting for the price to drop to sub £20 before I buy it. Played the COD5 Beta twice and lost interest, just didn't have the same feel to it, it seemed somehow rougher around the edges. I'm sure people who've played the full versions (is COD5 out now?) will be able to give a better comparison!



COD 5 is out now so hopefully people will be able to shed some light on the campaign. I thought that the campaign on COD 4 was one of the best ive played, and doing the campaign on the hardest difficulty didnt make you want to stop it actually made u want to keep trying to do it, ghillies in the mist was an awesome mission!!

I like it, it's just a shame the yanks got a headstart.

robtallica;3459966

geeze savour the flavour much?



thats nothing I called in asda on my way to work this morning and there was alread some guy at customer services waiting for a copy, got talking to him he said his brother orderd his from game already and completed it by last night :? point?

chralph;3459980

COD 5 is out now so hopefully people will be able to shed some light on … COD 5 is out now so hopefully people will be able to shed some light on the campaign. I thought that the campaign on COD 4 was one of the best ive played, and doing the campaign on the hardest difficulty didnt make you want to stop it actually made u want to keep trying to do it, ghillies in the mist was an awesome mission!!



ghillies in the mist was so annoying, well the bit in the field with the tanks.

But yeah COD 4 was definitely the best game I have ever played. I played it for hours, and then was totally shocked when it ended, i thought there would be loads more missions. I hope COD 6 will be modern day again and more missions.

ifyoudontask?;3459979

Just get COD4! you wont regret it! dont know anyone who doesnt like it! … Just get COD4! you wont regret it! dont know anyone who doesnt like it! :thumbsup:



Oh I intend to, I just begrudge buying games at before they drop below the magic £20, seems to only take 6 months or so these days, so why rush and pay twice the price? anyway I've got HL2 EP2 to finish off along with the time trials for Portal, PGR4 to finish the last few races on and the final side-story missions on GTA4 to get through - plenty to keep me going til the likes of Dead Space, Fallout 3, GOW2, Mirrors Edge, Pure and COD4 drop to the right prices :thumbsup:

MinstrelMan;3460003

thats nothing I called in asda on my way to work this morning and there … thats nothing I called in asda on my way to work this morning and there was alread some guy at customer services waiting for a copy, got talking to him he said his brother orderd his from game already and completed it by last night :? point?



lol that's just wreckless.

I'm going through GOW2 on hardcore still - I stop playing after a few levels to make it last.

Original Poster

robtallica;3460165

lol that's just wreckless.I'm going through GOW2 on hardcore still - I … lol that's just wreckless.I'm going through GOW2 on hardcore still - I stop playing after a few levels to make it last.



Im liking a few modes on GOW2 i love wingman and horde and i thought the single player was good . There is one good thing about COD 5 which is the Zombie multiplayer mode , just waiting till i get home and see guitar hero there, if the missus hasnt taken the newness out of it!!

chralph;3460208

Im liking a few modes on GOW2 i love wingman and horde and i thought the … Im liking a few modes on GOW2 i love wingman and horde and i thought the single player was good . There is one good thing about COD 5 which is the Zombie multiplayer mode , just waiting till i get home and see guitar hero there, if the missus hasnt taken the newness out of it!!



I got the GH4 band bundle coming today too.

We're buying all the same games lol

Original Poster

robtallica;3460226

I got the GH4 band bundle coming today too.We're buying all the same … I got the GH4 band bundle coming today too.We're buying all the same games lol



Well maybe we can play it xbox 360?

I do prefer COD5 only because it is new.

Both are great,

I like cod 5 more, but I'm not too keen on a few of the maps, dome is far too small for any game mode.

I prefer COD 5 becuase it seems more difficult, although it did annoy me when I found out you have to get 25 kills with a bolt action rifle to unlock the sniper scope for it its made it more of a challenge.

Sloth/Mod

For online - COD 4 for me. Once i've completed the single player campaign on COD 5 it's off to eBay.

Cod 4 is better, lets see if they patch some of the balance issues on cod 5 though
Post a comment
Avatar
@
    Text
    Top Discussions
    1. Advice on claiming from Salford Council pot hole damage22
    2. What is the best weight training app for iOS please?33
    3. heart rate monitor fitness watch59
    4. Best renewal with sky after last offer88

    See more discussions