Groups

    External HDD - Lacie or Western Digital

    Hi All,

    I'm looking to buy a 1TB External HDD for use with my WD TV live, (Networking is a bit too temperamental for my liking just now).

    My decision is between The Lacie DD3 5:

    comet.co.uk/sho…-UK

    and the WD My Book Essential:

    comet.co.uk/sho…IVE

    Specification | Comet

    Any opinions would be gratefully received.

    Cheers,

    Gary

    7 Comments

    I have the WD one, never had a problem with it yet.

    WD

    lacie stuff I had all broke within 3-5 minutes of removing from box. 3 drives in 1 year

    Get 10% off ALL hard drives. Use the code 10HD in the basket

    you probably spotted it but just in case

    There is this one as well comet.co.uk/sho…062 I have this one as well but its never been out of box so could not say what its like.

    comet.co.uk/sho…1tb

    cheapest comet.co.uk/sho…IVE £64.99 -10% and topcashback or quidco if on either site

    Original Poster

    Hmmm, cheers for opinions, People have said similar, but I'd heard Lacie was a good name, or is that mainly for NAS drives?

    gjgbarclay;7692802

    Hmmm, cheers for opinions, People have said similar, but I'd heard Lacie … Hmmm, cheers for opinions, People have said similar, but I'd heard Lacie was a good name, or is that mainly for NAS drives?



    Mine was LaCie Internet Space 500GB External Hard Drive NAS Network Attached Storage

    Original Poster

    Think its gonna be WD. Iomega has 'mixed' reviews. Got Quidco, so on it now I think

    Original Poster

    out of stock at loal store. Damn them!!!

    Always Go With The Western Digital Brand....never Trust Anything Else
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Entitled to overtime to be included in your holiday pay1020
      2. Labour MP Naz Shah retweeted calling for abused white girls to shut their m…1534
      3. word association Game72944192
      4. Surprise! The HUKD Summer Flamedeer Hunt 2017 **OFFICIAL THREAD** (trading …277963

      See more discussions