GTA IV or MAFIA II

12
Found 12th Mar 2011
Already got GTA which I love but have recently purchased Mafia 2 as it looks cool but if I already have GTA, is M2 very much the same, as not sure whether to sell it on or not.

Thoughts and opinions peeps!!!! PS3 by the way.

12 Comments

GTA IV killed the series for me, San-andreas was always the best and always will be! L.A. Noire looks good.

Haven't played Mafia 2 but first one was good.

GTA 4

Since you have it.
Why not play it and make your own mind up?

Original Poster


farhadmaster

GTA IV killed the series for me, San-andreas was always the best and … GTA IV killed the series for me, San-andreas was always the best and always will be! L.A. Noire looks good.Haven't played Mafia 2 but first one was good.



SA was prob the best for me but I like GTA IV. LA Noire does look cool.

rafalution2

GTA 4



Cheers

thesaint

Since you have it. Why not play it and make your own mind up?



Just thought with it being sealed I would get more so wasn't gonna open it til I make my mind up.

Banned

Not played Mafia 2 yet but GTA was really good

Recently finished it. It's like GTA without the free roam aspect. Apart from the story and some collectables there isn't anything to do. You can complete the story in about 8 hours so not too taxing. Missions are pretty repetitive (as you can expect) and the combat can be frustrating but generally it's an enjoyable play through.

Original Poster


gbspurs

Recently finished it. It's like GTA without the free roam aspect. Apart … Recently finished it. It's like GTA without the free roam aspect. Apart from the story and some collectables there isn't anything to do. You can complete the story in about 8 hours so not too taxing. Missions are pretty repetitive (as you can expect) and the combat can be frustrating but generally it's an enjoyable play through.



Cheers for that, I may look at getting rid then as I do really enjoy GTA.

Offering £8 for Mafia 2....

Original Poster


makershaker

Offering £8 for Mafia 2....



Err, no chance. This is the Collectors Edition, cheapest on the net is £26.99

Played both GTA 4. Mafia 2 is nothing like the original. GTA 4 is still good alot of people I think give it a tough time it has given me soo many hours for the £30-40 I paid for it and it still does, it's their first GTA with the RAGE engine.

Banned

Play Mafia 1 it's awesome

Banned

didnt really get into GTA4 and i wasnt a fan of SA in my opinion it attracted kids to an adult game ( no offence if any minors are here ).

my favs will always be the originals on PS1 then possibly GTA3 as it was different.

maybe sell your mafia collectors edition on ebay for a pretty penny, then buy a standard copy that should leave you some change left over to treat yourself further.
Edited by: "HybridTheory" 12th Mar 2011
Post a comment
Avatar
@
    Text