Groups

    Haggis or Black Pudding!

    Banned
    Haggis or Black Pudding!

    You decide!

    Haggis for me.

    39 Comments

    Banned

    Not sure.

    Haggis, hmmm piggybacking off my thread!

    never had haggis so black pudding

    Banned

    Is black pudding english?

    If so it has my vote X)

    vicknanth

    never had haggis so black pudding



    well only one way to fairly judge!!!

    Black Pudding!

    Black pud EVERY day of the week.

    vicknanth

    never had haggis so black pudding



    Wrong

    DLM

    Is black pudding english?If so it has my vote X)



    Wrong

    Jetpac

    Black Pudding!



    Wrong

    TUSSFC

    Black pud EVERY day of the week.



    Wrong

    COME ON PEOPLE HAGGIS IS THE WAY FORWARD!

    Banned

    vicknanth

    never had haggis so black pudding

    DLM

    Is black pudding english?If so it has my vote X)

    Jetpac

    Black Pudding!

    TUSSFC

    Black pud EVERY day of the week.



    If scottish food is so yum why did your family move?

    Black pudding RAW !

    To be honest I think we should try making a black pud in a haggis type recipe similar to turducken as I can't decide.

    dc7911

    Black pudding RAW !



    ok no need to growl

    Like Black Pudding - never had haggis.

    vicknanth

    never had haggis so black pudding

    DLM

    Is black pudding english?If so it has my vote X)

    Jetpac

    Black Pudding!

    TUSSFC

    Black pud EVERY day of the week.



    I moved alone, my mum is welsh!

    Haggis is horrible, I can't remember what black pudding tastes like but I'd have to choose it to avoid the haggis, bleugh!
    Unless you're talking about BB's dog Haggis, I'd like to give him a hug

    Original Poster Banned

    Silentone

    Like Black Pudding - never had haggis.



    It's similar to black pudding but spicier.
    The ingredients are equally disgusting!

    Original Poster Banned

    ham82

    Haggis, hmmm piggybacking off my thread!



    Only cause I'm in England and honestly believe black pudding lovers would prefer haggis if they only tried it

    Saumagen all the way! Haggis is just a cheap imitation.

    Original Poster Banned

    SUMMONER

    Saumagen all the way! Haggis is just a cheap imitation.



    To be honest Saumagen sounds like the expensive version
    en.wikipedia.org/wik…gen

    "potatoes, carrots and pork"
    None of that in Haggis!

    both

    greatest666

    To be honest Saumagen sounds like the expensive … To be honest Saumagen sounds like the expensive versionhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saumagen"potatoes, carrots and pork"None of that in Haggis!


    Similar concept and contains a variety of meats (ie: heart, kidney, liver etc.. no lungs... they are way too chewy - the ones I have tried anyway).

    Overall taste experience the Saumagen wins hands down.
    Edited by: "SUMMONER" 26th Jan 2011

    Isn't White Pudding the Scots version of Black Pudding (without the blood)?

    Raw Black Pudding or Cooked (with French Mustard) for me too.

    BFN,

    fp.

    fanpages

    Isn't White Pudding the Scots version of Black Pudding (without the … Isn't White Pudding the Scots version of Black Pudding (without the blood)?Raw Black Pudding or Cooked (with French Mustard) for me too.BFN,fp.


    White pudding is black pudding without thee blood. What's the point of that?

    I like both but Black paudding jsut wins it for taste and the fact you can have it with every meal, haggis you only have for dinner???

    Both.

    I like them both for breakfast as well as dinner. (as part of a cholesterol controlled diet)

    SUMMONER

    Saumagen all the way! Haggis is just a cheap imitation.



    Nonsense!

    Saumagen is a Cornish pastie without the pastry, ie Cornish pasty lite

    If you haven't tasted a McSween's 16 portion big boy you haven't lived!!

    vicknanth

    never had haggis so black pudding

    DLM

    Is black pudding english?If so it has my vote X)

    Jetpac

    Black Pudding!

    TUSSFC

    Black pud EVERY day of the week.



    It was a question, not an answer (_;)

    sickly sweet

    Haggis is horrible, I can't remember what black pudding tastes like but … Haggis is horrible, I can't remember what black pudding tastes like but I'd have to choose it to avoid the haggis, bleugh!Unless you're talking about BB's dog Haggis, I'd like to give him a hug <3



    Black pudding is very generic but there is many different haggis recipies and also like any thing like that different quality of ingredients so you may get one or two horrible haggis's and quite a few nice haggis's

    I have never tried real butchers haggis really.

    ham82

    I moved alone, my mum is welsh!



    uh, you realise you are in the minority in the family being scottish lol.

    oh, on topic,

    blackpudding.

    Never had haggis, just don't fancy it.


    However tried both black and white pudding in Ireland and love it, shame its so unhealthy!

    I recently had a lovely meal in a restaurant it was double cooked pork on a bed of black pudding mash, it was to die for, going to try and re-create it at home for a dinner party.

    Both Black Pudding and White Pudding

    Black pudding (or white pudding) for sure, yum yum in my tum

    like haggis, like black pudding but fruit pudding beats them both.

    I like black pudding but never ever tried Haggis , i thought a Haggis was an animal of some sort when i was younger , lol

    Love both - but both have to be well cooked and crispy edges (I stick the haggis under the grill after its been cooked to crisp it up). Can't stand soggy black pudding - yuk.

    greatest666

    Only cause I'm in England and honestly believe black pudding lovers would … Only cause I'm in England and honestly believe black pudding lovers would prefer haggis if they only tried it



    im in england to but scottish, as i said in other thread got the londoners to try it. they all LOVED it.

    shanecr

    uh, you realise you are in the minority in the family being scottish … uh, you realise you are in the minority in the family being scottish lol.oh, on topic,blackpudding.



    half welsh and half scottish, best of both!!!!!

    shopstilldrops

    I like black pudding but never ever tried Haggis , i thought a Haggis … I like black pudding but never ever tried Haggis , i thought a Haggis was an animal of some sort when i was younger , lol



    i managed to convince someone at work it was, before she looked online X)

    To be honest,

    Both Black Pudding and Haggis can taste completely different depending where it is made.

    I have tried both and loved them But tasted both and been disgusted by them so the question is not clear cut ...

    All depends where / who is making them ...
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Surprise! The HUKD Summer Flamedeer Hunt 2017 **OFFICIAL THREAD** (trading …285990
      2. Your dream gaming set up?2659
      3. ❅☁☁❅ I want☼to talk☼about the☔WEATHER☔no politics☃no religion❅☁☁❅18846322
      4. Supermarket may have sold Sausages & Other Pork products may have been inf…1841

      See more discussions