MOST OVERRATED GAME: RED DEAD REDEMPTION!!

76 replies
Found 26th Aug 2010
Surely I can't be the only person who thinks this game is pants!
Just got round to playing it after owning it for ages. Loved GTA IV so assumed it would be the same sort of style.

Just been to pick some flowers and got attacked by an invisible dog/cougar/wolf! Lost all the stuff I had collected, plus didn't save the side missions I had up to that point! How can someone die picking FLOWERS!!

76 Comments

Stop Trolling!

It would be better, if it was set in britain, around the year 2010, with cars, hookers, crime, death & guns.

hmmmmmm

Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah Montannah -_-

Banned

Ben3110

Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah … Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah Montannah -_-



Whereas you've got a wrestler:p (interesting sidenote that Scott Hall's Razor Ramon character was based on Tony Montana who is also in the OP's avi).

Anyway, I agree with OP. It's a beautiful game, very realistic, vast, etc. But it's also rather boring, with boring characters, a boring storyline and boring missions. So whilst I can see why it's so well received by many, I just couldn't be bothered to stick with it.

At least when GTA IV got boring (and it did) you could still go online and annoy people trying to race, or just jump off of a tall building.

Original Poster

Ben3110

Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah … Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah Montannah -_-



It's TONY and hannah montana, I guess it does not work.
Where did you get your gay pride photo from, I guess I could use one of those instead

Original Poster

phatzzzboob

Stop Trolling!



Was I trolling? Not sure about that!

Banned

brilliant game

/end

Banned

Ben3110

Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah … Can't take a guy's post seriously when his avatar includes Hannah Montannah -_-


yours is a bit homosexual mate

DaveLister

yours is a bit homosexual mate

Says the guy with a massive homosexual face as his avi.

mr.potato_head

Says the guy with a massive homosexual face as his avi.



LOL, JUST LOL.

Banned

mr.potato_head

Says the guy with a massive homosexual face as his avi.


lolz - you have a good point there though

mr.potato_head

Says the guy with a massive homosexual face as his avi.



haha, beat me to it

ivegotalobon

haha, beat me to it



Yeah by 10 minutes!

You have a lob on about davelister's avi? That's pretty homosexual. (Strong homosexual references in this thread)

Anyway OP, most over rated game ever is a bit of a bold statement, do you work for NME?

I actually think GTA IV was the most over rated. Couldn't get into it at all so had to resort to shooting old people for kicks.

The issues I had with RDR is that beyond the main story there isn't much to do. Could have done with a lot more side quests and mini games and the shops needed to actually hold stock you wanted to buy.

I did really enjoy the game while I played it but haven't kept going back to it like I did with GTA4.

Original Poster

It just may be very jubjective, as I can see that some people really like but as I say riding a horse from one side of the map to another with nothing to look at than sand is a little tiring. I know I could get a stagecoach but then you miss a lot of side missions along the way.

I suppose saying MOST OVERRATED was a little stong but I have aplyed most of the new releases lately and they are by far better in every way.

Banned

obviously the OP has never come across HAZE

Is this post not expired yet?
Go play High School Musical...

DaveLister

yours is a bit homosexual mate


Ben3110 might be a homosexual.

hate it but i knew i would hate all the gta games as well
i do quite enjoy constantly killing my mate on multiplayer though

Got to agree with op tbh, I found it very boring very quickly. Batman Arkham asylum (which I have just completed) on the other hand is absolutely top drawer

never evn bought into didn't like the look of it.
But i tell you if that happened to me i would be majorly pi ss ed lol

Banned

If you think RDR is a bad game you need to stop gaming because you are either mad or perhaps mentally disabled.

Banned

mr.potato_head

Says the guy with a massive homosexual face as his avi.


why don't you use your own picture as your avi? do you look like a child toucher or something?

DaveLister

why don't you use your own picture as your avi? do you look like a child … why don't you use your own picture as your avi? do you look like a child toucher or something?



Im scared of putting the children off, this is a family forum.

I don't only look like one, I smell like one too. PM me for pics, I will happily show you what I look like*



*Doing this may make you appear more homosexual than you currently do.

Original Poster

DJ1

If you think RDR is a bad game you need to stop gaming because you are … If you think RDR is a bad game you need to stop gaming because you are either mad or perhaps mentally disabled.



Perhaps I should stop gaming then 'cos this is rubbish!
Agree with sancho1983, Arkham Asylum is awesome, really worth the effort of going back and getting all the little secrets.

I will stick with RDR just to give a chance (and I don't like wasting money) but I can't see it getting much better TBH!

Banned

mr.potato_head

Im scared of putting the children off, this is a family forum.I don't … Im scared of putting the children off, this is a family forum.I don't only look like one, I smell like one too. PM me for pics, I will happily show you what I look like**Doing this may make you appear more homosexual than you currently do.


i don't wish to participate in a picture trading session with you via private message, sorry

Banned

norfolk_enchance

Perhaps I should stop gaming then 'cos this is rubbish!Agree with … Perhaps I should stop gaming then 'cos this is rubbish!Agree with sancho1983, Arkham Asylum is awesome, really worth the effort of going back and getting all the little secrets.I will stick with RDR just to give a chance (and I don't like wasting money) but I can't see it getting much better TBH!


i was put off by the fact that you can slide down mountains while sitting on your horse, the totally unrealistic speed in which horses pass you while you're riding towards them and a few other things

DaveLister

i don't wish to participate in a picture trading session with you via … i don't wish to participate in a picture trading session with you via private message, sorry



You've changed. Only 30 mins a go you were asking me to use a pic of me as my avi now you don't wanna know. Seems you've been cured. Good work.

There wasn't going to be a trade, I was offering pics with none in return, I'm kind like that. Plus I don't need any from you as your avi has already crossed the mark of vanity, homosexuality and elephantiasis.

Banned

mr.potato_head

You've changed. Only 30 mins a go you were asking me to use a pic of me … You've changed. Only 30 mins a go you were asking me to use a pic of me as my avi now you don't wanna know. Seems you've been cured. Good work.There wasn't going to be a trade, I was offering pics with none in return, I'm kind like that. Plus I don't need any from you as your avi has already crossed the mark of vanity, homosexuality and elephantiasis.


are you just typing random big words to try and look half intelligent? doesn't work. you're obviously extremely obese or just totally ugly. must have something to hide if you'll only show someone your picture in a private message.

DaveLister

why don't you use your own picture as your avi? do you look like a child … why don't you use your own picture as your avi? do you look like a child toucher or something?



looool rookie mistake from the rookie troll, mr potato head is easily the looking man on here, even i would give him a go (no homo)

btw remember when you were in a baad mood and called me fat?

new avi should clear up the fat issue

Edited by: "micoo" 26th Aug 2010

Banned

if you're talking to me i don't remember calling you fat, korean yeah but not fat, might be mistaken though. not quite sure whats going on with your hair there, i guess you could put it down to the running around playing netball

DaveLister

if you're talking to me i don't remember calling you fat, korean yeah but … if you're talking to me i don't remember calling you fat, korean yeah but not fat, might be mistaken though. not quite sure whats going on with your hair there, i guess you could put it down to the running around playing netball


netball
http://www.netballroundup.com/NRU%20Norfolk%20Island%20netball%20418.jpg

basketball
http://i360.photobucket.com/albums/oo42/Graycap23/NBANasty.jpg
Edited by: "micoo" 26th Aug 2010

DaveLister

are you just typing random big words to try and look half intelligent? … are you just typing random big words to try and look half intelligent? doesn't work. you're obviously extremely obese or just totally ugly. must have something to hide if you'll only show someone your picture in a private message.



As you said, I am a child toucher. Although Micoo still wants to do me, his parents have consented.

Those words may seem long to gym monkeys but to me they are just normal. I can dumb my posts down if you prefer. I LUV GYM. Is that OK?

I don't use a pic of me as an avi as I'm not that vain and dont want to be ridiculed like you have been and will be in future posts, but without wanting to be accused of being homophobic I will fulfil your request for the next 10 minutes.

[img]i803.photobucket.com/alb…jpg?t=1282834656[/img]

There you go. Enjoy!

Banned

Davelister - Were you channeling Rodin ironically? Or are you a massive Brucie fan?

FilthAndFurry

Davelister - Were you channeling Rodin ironically? Or are you a massive … Davelister - Were you channeling Rodin ironically? Or are you a massive Brucie fan?



Don't use long words. He struggles.

mr.potato_head

Don't use long words. He struggles.



hold on while i go get my thesaurus

it will be like making up a code

I agree the game is definitely overrated! and I was expecting alot more from the game in terns of gameplay.

Banned

mr.potato_head you look about 12 years old, looking forward to having your first shave in a few years time? quite funny that you took the mick out of my picture when you look like that, unless it's fake and you've only posted it as a joke

FilthAndFurry

Davelister - Were you channeling Rodin ironically? Or are you a massive … Davelister - Were you channeling Rodin ironically? Or are you a massive Brucie fan?



I think he is just squeezing a spot on his forehead

Hope it didn't hit the person take the pic
Post a comment
Avatar
@
    Text
    Top Discussions
    1. Topcashback Trick or Treat competition59608
    2. Win a £100 Amazon Voucher From LoveMyVouchers11
    3. Win a Fisher-Price Think & Learn Teach 'n tag Movi @ Netmums33
    4. Win a Mama to Bee necklace from Blooming Lovely Jewellery, worth £249! @ Ne…33

    See more discussions