Groups
    EXPIRED

    Panorama just starting.......

    mod
    Anyone watching?

    "The Panorama documentary on Manchester Uniteds finances is the most eagerly anticipated in the programmes history during the new media age.

    The programme, entitled 'Man Utd Into the Red', is set to shed further light on the Glazer familys ability to keep control of the club by centring on their ailing shopping-mall company. It will expose £400 million of previously unknown debt and cast more uncertainty over how much money Sir Alex Ferguson will be given to strengthen his squad this summer.

    Given that Panorama is screened nearly every week and is the longest running current affairs show in the world, the figures demonstrates the interest among United supporters and the broader football community in exposing the excesses of the Glazer regime"

    31 Comments

    Original Poster mod

    Kind of torn between laughing at Man Us expense and being worried about the state of finances in general in football

    Original Poster mod

    That'll be me then

    On my own :oops:

    75p in every £1 that the Glazers are scamming off the fans is just crazy

    At least (none MCFC head on) this programme is unmasking them for what they are and David Gill looking a fool also

    Banned

    AndyWedge,

    Nobody is interested apart from City fans.

    Shouldn't you be more worried that your owners will get bored and depart, leaving the club in freefall ?

    Original Poster mod

    Rather that than the state Man U are in at the moment ASB (although I'd rather have Gill than that idiot Cook)

    Yeah, I don't like Man U but I love football, so this is grim viewing actually

    Sympathy post Andy

    Original Poster mod

    1.1 Bn debt???

    That's terrifying

    Original Poster mod

    Marina;8792953

    Sympathy post Andy



    Thanks Marina :-D

    all the man u fans will be worrying about the start of wimbledon. I think they put their norwich scarves away until the champions league starts up again.

    I dont follow footy,but am always amazed at the lifestyles & amounts of money these guys get paid, back in the old days the players were getting no where near this amount of money, clubs are in serious debt yet there are no talks in cutting players wages etc, do you think as a football fan the players wages are justified ?

    Banned

    andywedge;8792838

    Rather that than the state Man U are in at the moment ASB (although I'd … Rather that than the state Man U are in at the moment ASB (although I'd rather have Gill than that idiot Cook)Yeah, I don't like Man U but I love football, so this is grim viewing actually



    As long as they have a business plan that can service the debts, then there's not a big worry. They have enough interest from potential buyers already to know that they can take their money and run whenever the need suits.

    It could be argued that some of the big spending clubs are ruining football (it's good when the club buys big from say another english club), however all they are doing is setting grossly inflated prices for other transfers as a benchmark. Decent players become worth a few millions more (plus huge wage costs) because of the current market conditions. Clubs with huge benefactors are not intent on helping anyone else with regards to football overall, perhaps that's where we should start looking ?

    Original Poster mod

    If you take this as - Man U - one of the biggest clubs in the world - and they are that much in debt and the fans are being ripped off by so much and there isn't going to be an end to it whilst this lot have the reins and can only get worse (looking at the Glaziers combined debt = £1.1 Bn) and it's an increasing debt. I'd be really worried if I was a Man U fan. Makes what happened at Pompey look like someone lost 10p.

    Original Poster mod

    aScottishBloke;8793100

    As long as they have a business plan that can service the debts, then … As long as they have a business plan that can service the debts, then there's not a big worry. They have enough interest from potential buyers already to know that they can take their money and run whenever the need suits.It could be argued that some of the big spending clubs are ruining football (it's good when the club buys big from say another english club), however all they are doing is setting grossly inflated prices for other transfers as a benchmark. Decent players become worth a few millions more (plus huge wage costs) because of the current market conditions. Clubs with huge benefactors are not intent on helping anyone else with regards to football overall, perhaps that's where we should start looking ?



    That just a dig at City ASB?

    But that debt is slowly decreasing. As ASB said, the debt on Man U, not the glaziers, is fine, as they can afford to pay it off, being the second largest profit grossing club after real madrid. Plus the fact that if the club was in dire straits, then the club would be sold, and I doubt there would be a shortage of buyers more then willing to pump money into it.

    Banned

    andywedge;8793120

    That just a dig at City ASB?



    Naw, don't get paranoid, City are only the most recent, not the 1st.

    Original Poster mod

    spic;8793161

    But that debt is slowly decreasing. As ASB said, the debt on Man U, not … But that debt is slowly decreasing. As ASB said, the debt on Man U, not the glaziers, is fine, as they can afford to pay it off, being the second largest profit grossing club after real madrid. Plus the fact that if the club was in dire straits, then the club would be sold, and I doubt there would be a shortage of buyers more then willing to pump money into it.



    So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and increasing due to their other "investments" failing? And the fact that 75p out of every £1 through the turnstiles/Megastores at Man U goes to covering the Glaziers Man U debt?

    I'm guessing you aren't a Man U fan - never met in the last two seasons who thinks Man U are on a financial sound base. I mean, sell Ronaldo for £80 million and replace with a free transfer perma injured Michael Owen?!?!??! There isn't another player left at Man U now who could fetch any real money in the transfer market. Berbatov might get £25 million (tops - after 18 months of averageness) and Vidic is worth something but that's about it. So the £80 M (cover the cracks) aint gonna happen this or next season and that 75p in the £1 could easily become 90p in the £1 or worse

    Original Poster mod

    aScottishBloke;8793232

    Naw, don't get paranoid, City are only the most recent, not the 1st.



    Chelsea, Blackburn, Newcastle, Leeds (to a lesser extent)

    Trouble is - if a club has the ££££ then trying to buy a UK based player means you get ripped off. Lescott/Santa Cruz to name just two
    So, you go abroad where you don't get ripped off as much - De Jong/Kompany/

    Banned

    andywedge;8793270

    So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and … So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and increasing due to their other "investments" failing? And the fact that 75p out of every £1 through the turnstiles/Megastores at Man U goes to covering the Glaziers Man U debt?I'm guessing you aren't a Man U fan - never met in the last two seasons who thinks Man U are on a financial sound base. I mean, sell Ronaldo for £80 million and replace with a free transfer perma injured Michael Owen?!?!??! There isn't another player left at Man U now who could fetch any real money in the transfer market. Berbatov might get £25 million (tops - after 18 months of averageness) and Vidic is worth something but that's about it. So the £80 M (cover the cracks) aint gonna happen this or next season and that 75p in the £1 could easily become 90p in the £1 or worse



    Bad example, Fergie will get it right more often than not re Owen. Berbatov, you've added prob 15 million to his true value in the current market.

    City fans don't contribute anywhere near the cost of running their team, nor would they be in a position to bale out should someone get bored.

    United seems the best bet for me.

    Banned

    andywedge;8793325

    Chelsea, Blackburn, Newcastle, Leeds (to a lesser extent)Trouble is - if … Chelsea, Blackburn, Newcastle, Leeds (to a lesser extent)Trouble is - if a club has the ££££ then trying to buy a UK based player means you get ripped off. Lescott/Santa Cruz to name just twoSo, you go abroad where you don't get ripped off as much - De Jong/Kompany/



    Oops, you forgot Robhinio.

    Original Poster mod

    aScottishBloke;8793350

    Oops, you forgot Robhinio.



    He was a "statement of intent" signing and don't think you'll find many City fans who don't think it was a bad signing and hopefully Mansoor has sussed that out now. IE "Rome wasn't built in a day" so don't buy players who are just "names"

    andywedge;8793270

    So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and … So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and increasing due to their other "investments" failing? And the fact that 75p out of every £1 through the turnstiles/Megastores at Man U goes to covering the Glaziers Man U debt?I'm guessing you aren't a Man U fan - never met in the last two seasons who thinks Man U are on a financial sound base. I mean, sell Ronaldo for £80 million and replace with a free transfer perma injured Michael Owen?!?!??! There isn't another player left at Man U now who could fetch any real money in the transfer market. Berbatov might get £25 million (tops - after 18 months of averageness) and Vidic is worth something but that's about it. So the £80 M (cover the cracks) aint gonna happen this or next season and that 75p in the £1 could easily become 90p in the £1 or worse



    You guessed wrong. But a lot of it is spin. Take the net value of the Glaziers current three business ventures - they are currently worth 2.13 billion (these figures are taken from the anti-glazier feller Andy Green, who is advisor to the MU supporters trust), means they have a net assets value after debts of around 1 billion (dependant on the sources you look at).

    Yes, these debts are high, but as I mentioned before they are manageable, and the Glaziers have been managing debts within their business' for many years.

    You also forgot Valencia, and what SAF loves to do - bring from the youth squad - such as rafael and Evans.

    Comparing them to Pompy is like comparing chalk and cheese in my opinion - Pompy is a very small south coast team with a fan base that doesn't really reach out of the city, which is mostly comprised of students and sailors anyway, and certainly does not have any international following. Man U are completely different however, and a very promising investment for someone if the club were to be sold.

    Banned

    andywedge;8792705

    Kind of torn between laughing at Man Us expense and being worried about … Kind of torn between laughing at Man Us expense and being worried about the state of finances in general in football



    andywedge;8792793

    That'll be me thenOn my own :oops:75p in every £1 that the Glazers are … That'll be me thenOn my own :oops:75p in every £1 that the Glazers are scamming off the fans is just crazyAt least (none MCFC head on) this programme is unmasking them for what they are and David Gill looking a fool also



    aScottishBloke;8792810

    AndyWedge, Nobody is interested apart from City fans. Shouldn't you be … AndyWedge, Nobody is interested apart from City fans. Shouldn't you be more worried that your owners will get bored and depart, leaving the club in freefall ?



    andywedge;8792838

    Rather that than the state Man U are in at the moment ASB (although I'd … Rather that than the state Man U are in at the moment ASB (although I'd rather have Gill than that idiot Cook)Yeah, I don't like Man U but I love football, so this is grim viewing actually



    MOD FIGHT MOD FIGHT!!!

    inb4 susp.

    Original Poster mod

    aScottishBloke;8793346

    Bad example, Fergie will get it right more often than not re Owen. … Bad example, Fergie will get it right more often than not re Owen. Berbatov, you've added prob 15 million to his true value in the current market.City fans don't contribute anywhere near the cost of running their team, nor would they be in a position to bale out should someone get bored.United seems the best bet for me.



    Three seasons ago - yes for sure; but not now.

    City fans contribute a helluva lot more than 25p in the £1 - our money goes into Man City not into some debt ridden owners pockets

    You are right about Berbatov - I was being very generous at his value; but your comment only backs up my point that Man U no longer have anything of value that they can sell to ease this debt and it can only get worse for the Man U fans whilst this lot are running the show

    Original Poster mod

    spic;8793425

    You guessed wrong. But a lot of it is spin. Take the net value of the … You guessed wrong. But a lot of it is spin. Take the net value of the Glaziers current three business ventures - they are currently worth 2.13 billion (these figures are taken from the anti-glazier feller Andy Green, who is advisor to the MU supporters trust), means they have a net assets value after debts of around 1 billion (dependant on the sources you look at). Yes, these debts are high, but as I mentioned before they are manageable, and the Glaziers have been managing debts within their business' for many years. You also forgot Valencia, and what SAF loves to do - bring from the youth squad - such as rafael and Evans. Comparing them to Pompy is like comparing chalk and cheese in my opinion - Pompy is a very small south coast team with a fan base that doesn't really reach out of the city, which is mostly comprised of students and sailors anyway, and certainly does not have any international following. Man U are completely different however, and a very promising investment for someone if the club were to be sold.



    Did you see Panorama? Seriously, I'd be really worried. No doubting it was made by a member of the Delia Smith appreciation bunch at Old T but even if half of what was said was/is true that's a grim state of affairs

    andywedge;8793467

    Did you see Panorama? Seriously, I'd be really worried. No doubting it … Did you see Panorama? Seriously, I'd be really worried. No doubting it was made by a member of the Delia Smith appreciation bunch at Old T but even if half of what was said was/is true that's a grim state of affairs



    I did not, but I still think a lot of it is pure hype against a group of people who have been demonised for the way they do business. Granted, this is probably not the best way to work it though.
    However, as I mentioned before, if the Glaziers were to sell the Bucs, they would almost completely wipe out all of the debt that is currently owed, however, they obviously feel that they can pay that debt with Man U earnings (something I am not sure about). BUT, with the current value of their assets,the debt is not currently something that needs to be worried about. AND, as has been mentioned before, SAF does have a kitty to spend at Man U (dependant on who you believe of course, but I think this would be a difficult one to cover up).

    Andy you forgot about rooney when you said no one else was worth any money at OT. I think if he were to go they'd get over 100m at the current transfer ridiculousness.

    The reason football is debt riddled is because they pay a bunch of morons several years salary a WEEK to play a game. Of course that's not sustainable.

    andywedge;8793270

    So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and … So you aren't worried that the Glaziers current debt is £1.1Bn and increasing due to their other "investments" failing? And the fact that 75p out of every £1 through the turnstiles/Megastores at Man U goes to covering the Glaziers Man U debt?I'm guessing you aren't a Man U fan - never met in the last two seasons who thinks Man U are on a financial sound base. I mean, sell Ronaldo for £80 million and replace with a free transfer perma injured Michael Owen?!?!??! There isn't another player left at Man U now who could fetch any real money in the transfer market. Berbatov might get £25 million (tops - after 18 months of averageness) and Vidic is worth something but that's about it. So the £80 M (cover the cracks) aint gonna happen this or next season and that 75p in the £1 could easily become 90p in the £1 or worse



    How about Evra the French Captain and arguably the best left back in the world (+Rooney but he'll be at Unted for life!)?! But shame is I have to agree the Glaziers need to be outed and as much as I hate to admit it Man U's finances are in a bit of a mess at the moment and it is worrying that as fast as united is earning the money, the interest is swallowing it up. Love United, hate Glazier.

    stephen4X;8793599

    The reason football is debt riddled is because they pay a bunch of morons … The reason football is debt riddled is because they pay a bunch of morons several years salary a WEEK to play a game. Of course that's not sustainable.



    That's very true but if the FA, for example, was to cut all the players wages as a requirement the best players would just go abroad. There's no way to put a pay cap on wages globally and so if you want the premier league to stay at such a good standard and if you want to compete in the champions league (i.e. keep the money pouring in - much more than players are getting paid!) then you have to accept that it is the way it is.

    If you capped the wages then the excess money has to go somewhere else, most likely then into boardmembers pockets.

    Would rather the players get the millions than the fat cats.

    Original Poster mod

    mcnally32;8793577

    Andy you forgot about rooney when you said no one else was worth any … Andy you forgot about rooney when you said no one else was worth any money at OT. I think if he were to go they'd get over 100m at the current transfer ridiculousness.



    Ooops yes - he is worth a bob or two :oops:
    That would be a sign o' the times if they had to sell him though

    Original Poster mod

    Just about to start on BBC1
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Free JackpotJoy Plate56
      2. Win a Free minion usb stick77
      3. Tv choice magazine Issue 391313
      4. Magazine competitions - Issue 38 @ tvchoicemagazine.co.uk1717

      See more discussions