Groups

    Police try to recruit Plane Stupid protester as spy - listen to the recordings on links

    Too many questions to ask about this, so will just see what you think after listening to the recording.

    Recordings and transcript here:

    guardian.co.uk/uk/…e-1

    14 Comments

    The two officers in question?
    http://blogs.fayobserver.com/faytoz/files/2008/05/starsky-hutch.jpeg

    Heard this on the radio this morning. These things happen all the time. This is just more publicity for the group and an opportunity for the media to fill a gap until something bigger comes along.

    The funniest thing about it was how the cops tried woefully to convince her to become an informant.....lol :thumbsup:

    Police are doing their job

    Fully support them 100%

    Sure the bleeding heart,police bashing,liberal PC brigade will come on and say otherwise

    Original Poster

    StevenA2000_uk;5028782

    Heard this on the radio this morning. These things happen all the time. … Heard this on the radio this morning. These things happen all the time. This is just more publicity for the group and an opportunity for the media to fill a gap until something bigger comes along.The funniest thing about it was how the cops tried woefully to convince her to become an informant.....lol :thumbsup:



    Yes, I was a bit surprised that they seemed to know the tape was running - or at least had been - so they obviously don't see any problem with this type of intelligence gathering.

    Personally, I see lots of potential for problems. The same tactic was used in NI for a long time and was proved time and time again to lead to misinformation being supplied to the police, wrongful arrests and other problems.

    Difficult one - once you start paying someone to give you the kind of secret info you want, you nearly automatically set up a situation where informants have a reason to supply info, even when it's not genuine or only rumour, etc.

    It also bothers me that the police are targeting a genuine environmental pressure group like Plane Stupid in this way. They are a not a dangerous group in the same way that a terrorist cell might be for example...

    Liddle ol' me;5028832

    Yes, I was a bit surprised that they seemed to know the tape was running … Yes, I was a bit surprised that they seemed to know the tape was running - or at least had been - so they obviously don't see any problem with this type of intelligence gathering. Personally, I see lots of potential for problems. The same tactic was used in NI for a long time and was proved time and time again to lead to misinformation being supplied to the police, wrongful arrests and other problems. Difficult one - once you start paying someone to give you the kind of secret info you want, you nearly automatically set up a situation where informants have a reason to supply info, even when it's not genuine or only rumour, etc. It also bothers me that the police are targeting a genuine environmental pressure group like Plane Stupid in this way. They are a not a dangerous group in the same way that a terrorist cell might be for example...


    There may be a lot of problems but its all the police have,The tactics in NI may have been flawed but they also saved many many lives,I dont believe in this case they want to subvert plane stupid but watch out for people advocating violent tactics and even though the evidence could not be used in court it would point police in the right direction,

    Liddle ol' me;5028832

    Yes, I was a bit surprised that they seemed to know the tape was running … Yes, I was a bit surprised that they seemed to know the tape was running - or at least had been - so they obviously don't see any problem with this type of intelligence gathering. Personally, I see lots of potential for problems. The same tactic was used in NI for a long time and was proved time and time again to lead to misinformation being supplied to the police, wrongful arrests and other problems. Difficult one - once you start paying someone to give you the kind of secret info you want, you nearly automatically set up a situation where informants have a reason to supply info, even when it's not genuine or only rumour, etc. It also bothers me that the police are targeting a genuine environmental pressure group like Plane Stupid in this way. They are a not a dangerous group in the same way that a terrorist cell might be for example...



    Totally agree.

    Banned

    Don't see a problem with it...bah move on

    If you read the transcripts they say they are not interested in the group,but the individuals in it

    Original Poster

    tonyg1962;5028897

    There may be a lot of problems but its all the police have,The tactics in … There may be a lot of problems but its all the police have,The tactics in NI may have been flawed but they also saved many many lives,I dont believe in this case they want to subvert plane stupid but watch out for people advocating violent tactics and even though the evidence could not be used in court it would point police in the right direction,



    I see where you are coming from, but in the NI example there is a strong argument that bad policing actually exacerbated the troubles. It's pretty much accepted by all 'sides' now that the old RUC often caused as many problems as they helped resolve - a major reason why they had to be renamed the PSNI and reorganised in an attempt to prevent future bias, etc.

    As for Plane Stupid, are there people within it advocating violent tactics? Perhaps there are, but it's not something I'm aware of.

    EDIT: I should add that I appreciate your point about them not wanting to subvert Plane Stupid.

    Banned

    Liddle ol' me;5028970

    As for Plane Stupid, are there people within it advocating violent … As for Plane Stupid, are there people within it advocating violent tactics? Perhaps there are, but it's not something I'm aware of.



    Why do you work for them? Passed on this information to my local police intelligence section for FREE!! :thumbsup:

    Original Poster

    lumoruk;5029036

    Why do you work for them? Passed on this information to my local police … Why do you work for them? Passed on this information to my local police intelligence section for FREE!! :thumbsup:



    I might do. Anyway, I thought you were moving on to more mundane things :whistling:

    Banned

    Liddle ol' me;5029040

    I might do. Anyway, I thought you were moving on to more mundane things … I might do. Anyway, I thought you were moving on to more mundane things :whistling:



    What have you been reading? Nothing is mundane in my life! I'm stuck in the outside lane overtaking the poor suckers on the inside

    Original Poster

    lumoruk;5029127

    What have you been reading? Nothing is mundane in my life! I'm stuck in … What have you been reading? Nothing is mundane in my life! I'm stuck in the outside lane overtaking the poor suckers on the inside



    :lol: Nice!
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Nightmare with BT over Broadband78
      2. Ditched Sky1620
      3. How to get laptop to boot from DVD/CD drive?611
      4. Easyjet - book now or wait?1016

      See more discussions