Groups

    Pro Evo 2009 Vs Fifa 09

    So basically i am having a dilemma, when i was younger fifa was always the game to play, then Pro Evo came to emergence as the top game.

    Now i have played the xbox 360 demo of Fifa 09 and its not bad and from the reviews it has it sounds like a great game.
    I haven't played but have heard that the pro evo demo isnt great and also that alot of pro evo fans are joining the ranks of fifa fans.

    So my questions is which game is for you?

    Have you played both demos?

    Please no stupid comments, or people who just post "Pro evo Rules" or "Pro Sux i love the FIFA"

    58 Comments

    I think "Misc" needs more FIFA 09/Pro Evo 2009 threads.

    Finally a FIFA 089 V PES 09 thread.

    /scarscam

    Original Poster

    Lol you know youve been waiting for this thread.

    So anyone played both demos?

    theres been around 3 same threads of dis lol.

    If your a REAL PRO EVO FAN u wont go for fifa end off.

    most people who played the pro evo demo on here and thought it was cack dont know wagwan.

    Its a really good game and much better than 08. Download it and try it out yourself. I was kinda close not playing it when people said it was rubbish but when i played it , it was just something else , its better than fifa!!!

    Pro evo Rules







































    joke













































    "Pro Sux i love the FIFA"












    no but rly, there both good games, played both demo, own fifa. Good games, I just hope pes dont lag online like it did last year.

    im tempted to buy fifa just for the be a pro season mode having been a big pro fan for as long as i can remember!!i havent got xbox live at uni server wont allow it so not sure whether to take the risk with fifa

    u buy fifa and it will be a costly mistake n u will live 2 regret it

    Original Poster

    I would download the demo but ain't got live at the moment...well i have kind of but itd not working, stupid xbox customer service.....anyway thats a different story.

    Well i almost brought fifa today but couldn't do it. So waiting to play pro before i decide anything.

    I've played both demos and I won't be getting fifa. It looks great but the gameplay is just lacking when compared with pro evo.

    MarzBarz;3119653

    u buy fifa and it will be a costly mistake n u will live 2 regret it



    i read all ur comments and u really need to give fifa a go. fifa is by far a better game now. even i thought id never say that

    i have tried it but pro evo all day way !!!

    I bought Fifa but i don't like it very much. One Pro Evo comes out i will probably sell it.

    The 10 v 10 online is a complete shambles.

    hahaha good to HEAR(wrote here before lol) JFK

    pro evo for me, though if Tesco still have any in stock when I'm doing the shopping tomorrow I'll get fifa anyway, but pro evo would be my first choice if I was just getting one.

    Original Poster

    If you have played both demos will you rate them out of 10 here.

    I would give fifa 8.5/10

    Ive played both demo's on xbox 360

    The fifa 09 demo was awesome and i loved teh glossy and better all round control of the players it was a sublime game and with the introduction of "be a pro season" as well as 10 V 10 online and the addidas live season which will update players weekly on real life performances this is real value for money aswell.

    The best thing about the pro evo 9 demo was the camera angle, it gives a good view of the play but then again you can customise the camera angles on fifa 09 then pro evo becomes abit pointless.

    Also when playing the pro evo demo it seems very much like an arcade game, with very arcade liek music and when playing the pro evos version of "be a pro season" you get points for various passes, goals and stuff and the graphic used to display the points gained where very arcade like.

    So all in all, buy fifa 09 and you will have loads of game content that will be updated regularly with the addidas live season, including squad updates after the winter transfere window ( which pro evo did not get last year, maybe a sign of things to come?)

    out of 10 rating

    fifa 09 : 9/10

    Pro evo 9 : 6/10

    andyfisher100;3120467

    out of 10 ratingfifa 09 : 9/10Pro evo 9 : 6/10



    think you was being a bit kind to pro evo 9 ,more like 3/10

    Pro Sux i love the FIFA

    Pro Sux i love the FIFA

    Pro Evo Is Da Bestest

    might give the new FIFA a try if I keep hearing good things about it . . .

    Banned

    out of 10 rating

    fifa 09 : 9/10

    Pro evo 9 : 2/10

    Ill be getting both but...

    to me its abit like this...

    Fifa is a Simulation football game and

    PES is an arcade game if you get what im trying to say.
    ones realistic and ones not. Both good

    pes is realistic ! fifa is not !

    fifa 0/10

    Pro 9.9/10

    Banned

    MarzBarz;3121748

    pes is realistic ! fifa is not !fifa 0/10Pro 9.9/10


    Have to agree (if you like your football pinball style ;-))

    Theres no argument whether or not the gameplay is better in pro evo. The gameplay has ALWAYS been better.

    Fifa players turn back real SLOWWWWWWWWWWWW like a tank whereas in pro you can just the turn back a player ina touch.

    fifas skills , goal scoring styles are the same every year "YAWNS". Isnt it boring yet.

    In fifa i can run one end to the other without getting tackled lmao

    Pro evo got worse every year and looks like this years effort seems poor!!i wonder if they sorted out the super online lag on pro which they failed to fix even with a update.i have fifa 09 and loving it and plenty of my m8s have bought the game to,even pro evo fans are loving it!!i got my copy of from work(tesco) for £27 so a very good price!!

    All these people talking about how slow FIFA is, just turn the speed up in the options if you want it to play like an unrealistic PES.

    MarzBarz;3121748

    pes is realistic ! fifa is not !fifa 0/10Pro 9.9/10



    please tell me thats a joke?

    you can score crazy goals all the time pretty easy. Which isnt realistic. im getting it because of that tho its Fun

    pro isn't as fast as it used to be? More realistic now

    Tbh the ratings are very similar in all magazines and websites

    Banned

    If you played football in real life you would know which one is best. Pro evo is so bad i deleted it straight away from my hdd. Couldn't believe that they didn't even change anything.

    kcnw9;3122509

    If you played football in real life you would know which one is best. Pro … If you played football in real life you would know which one is best. Pro evo is so bad i deleted it straight away from my hdd. Couldn't believe that they didn't even change anything.



    Thats not true they have changed alot. it looks alot better than the last ones and plays smoother aswell.

    pro evo is the best multiplayer game.
    fifa has got better online and singleplayer gameplay especially that pro thing where you controll one player.

    what i hate about fifa 2009 is the way the camera moves from player to player. maybe it can be changed but when i played the demo it was awful. but it is alot more realistic than pro.
    pro did improve from the last one so and now theyve got sponsored teams!!!

    overall though i have to say pro is a much better game.

    ALICOM007;3122758

    pro evo is the best multiplayer game..



    You what?????? PES 2008 was unplayable multiplayer and never got fixed. FIFA has always worked fine and 10 v 10 is awesome. Considering PES isn't out yet and the demo has no multiplayer how can you say that?

    Fifa 09 is brilliant, best football game I have played....:)

    If you buy Pro Evo 09 you will regret it.

    Original Poster

    Lol well in the middle of downloading pro evo demo so will see but i think either way i am going to wait and see what the impartial critics say, i think alot of people commenting here seem veyr very biased. Also there is no way that the ratings are that far apart, i know it will be a close contest i just don't know which one is going to be better.

    I think if fifa 09 is alot better in the critics rating then i will get it, if not then i will just stick with Pro.

    Also for those saying fifa is always more realistic that is completly wrong, Fifa used to be more realistic and the graphics have always been more realistic, but the gameplay of pro has always been better.

    Seeing centre backs doing fancy flicks, flick the ball over their head etc is ridiculous and in fifa it is very very easy to do this.

    But at the moment i am staying impartial.

    MarzBarz;3121811

    Theres no argument whether or not the gameplay is better in pro evo. The … Theres no argument whether or not the gameplay is better in pro evo. The gameplay has ALWAYS been better.



    aaahhh so you are the one person who thought last years pro evo was good lol
    tell your mummy to buy you fifa this year and play a proper game :whistling:

    MarzBarz;3121824

    In fifa i can run one end to the other without getting tackled lmao



    You should be removed from this site, you clearly havent played both demos at all, infact i think i will request you to be removed from the site because you are foolish and dont get people the best deals which is what the site is about.

    You have no clue on the market.

    Pro is an arcade retro 1960's game
    Fifa in the simulation 2009 game.
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Win a Davosa Ternos Submariner Wristwatch worth £64578
      2. Win 1 of 3 x £1000 Selfridges vouchers with Virgin Trains1211
      3. Win a luxury eight-night break for two in Malaysia with Ushvani Spa and Tra…55
      4. Win a safari adventure & claim a free Chicago Town pizza coupon44

      See more discussions