Red Dead Redemption 360 graphics noticeably better then PS3!!!

51 replies
Found 19th May 2010
Here's the proof guys below damn! and i just ordered the PS3 version stupid Rockstar selling us an inferior game, and some people claim the ps3 version runs at 640p and that the xbox version runs at 720p hd now that just takes the coconut!!

51 Comments

Original Poster

A graphics comparison the xbox 360 being on top and the ps3 below
neogaf.com/for…704

Banned

Isn't this the case for most multi-platform games? Spend more money developing on the bigger console?

they are great gfx on both consoles the margins are not worth debating, the game will (hopefully) be just as awesome and fun as GTA IV and then some

This is the case with most games that are on both platforms, the 360 versions will have slightly better graphics.

Original Poster

Anyway, heres a ten second clip of red dead running on PS3, and 360 (by the same guy, doing the same thing in both clips)



youtube.com/wat…d=1 (PS3)



youtube.com/wat…d=1 (360)

The xbox has less flickering then the ps3 version :roll:

can't wait for this, mine was posted on MONDAY from thehut. Hoping to get it early. 360 BTW

Original Poster

mcnally32;8645339

can't wait for this, mine was posted on MONDAY from thehut. Hoping to … can't wait for this, mine was posted on MONDAY from thehut. Hoping to get it early. 360 BTW



lucky you:-D

Banned

Alfonse;8645271

they are great gfx on both consoles the margins are not worth debating, … they are great gfx on both consoles the margins are not worth debating, the game will (hopefully) be just as awesome and fun as GTA IV and then some



I hope so, I've even used a precious Verbatim DL disc on it.

master_chief;8645437

I hope so, I've even used a precious Verbatim DL disc on it.



oh my dayz.............

anywho have fun. PM if its any good, I take it you can't do MP?

:thumbsup:

Banned

Alfonse;8645454

oh my dayz.............anywho have fun. PM if its any good, I take it you … oh my dayz.............anywho have fun. PM if its any good, I take it you can't do MP?:thumbsup:



:lol:

I thought you'd appreciate it. You want me to do you a copy too? I'll even send it FOC.

master_chief;8645477

:lol:I thought you'd appreciate it. You want me to do you a copy too? … :lol:I thought you'd appreciate it. You want me to do you a copy too? I'll even send it FOC.



nah I'm trying to round up a posse, you interested :p:whistling::oops:

My eyesight is poor anyway, if i had both versions i very much doubt i could tell the difference.

Any PS3 owners feel free to add me: Retro1989

Banned

Alfonse;8645484

nah I'm trying to round up a posse, you interested :p:whistling::oops:



Sounds fun. I'm not one for online gaming though :whistling:

master_chief;8645527

Sounds fun. I'm not one for online gaming though :whistling:



damn you :oops:

:thumbsup:

Banned

Because the 360 is holding back the MIGHTY PLAYSTATION 3.

Original Poster

Mallinersha;8645625

http://www.hotukdeals.com/item/681009/red-redemption/showpost.php?p=8640153&postcount=5



taken from the above linked article

Red Dead Redemption 360 vs. PS3: our thoughts
By Ben Kuchera | Last updated about 23 hours ago
Our review copies of Red Dead Redemption have arrived, which means it's time to get to work on some coverage. Rockstar sent both a PS3 and a 360 version of the game, and many people are wondering which version to get, so we thought we'd do a quick comparison.

This is non-scientific, but after playing an hour of both games, and switching back and forth between the two systems on our display, it's clear that the 360 version has quite the graphical advantage. It's sharper, with much less aliasing. The faces of the characters were clearer in the opening section. Gameplay sections likewise looked better, with smoother graphics across the board. The PlayStation 3 version looked impressive, but there was a noticeable jump in quality while playing on the 360.

Keep in mind that the game doesn't look bad on the PS3—not by any stretch—but based on our time with the game and direct comparisons, the 360 version looks better. If you purchase the PS3 version of the game you're not going to be let down, but if you have the choice, pick up a copy for the 360
:x:?

*Dances*

I'm going to have to get this at some point I guess

Original Poster

I guess when i eventually get my copy from tesco it's going to cex so i can buy the 360 version:-D

Edit: cex are currently offering to buy this game for £42 on both platforms

Original Poster

ridgerama;8646809

http://youtubedoubler.com/?video1=8X271DTsH_g&start1=0&video2=2wge2EVB3wE&start2=0&authorName=Greynot a lot of difference



sure there is! i guess i just have a keen eye for detail and so will my hd lcd tv:thinking:

DEALofaLifetime;8647200

sure there is! i guess i just have a keen eye for detail and so will my … sure there is! i guess i just have a keen eye for detail and so will my hd lcd tv:thinking:



u say there's is a LOT of difference :roll:

I wanna play this

Banned

DEALofaLifetime;8646224

I guess when i eventually get my copy from tesco it's going to cex so i … I guess when i eventually get my copy from tesco it's going to cex so i can buy the 360 version:-DEdit: cex are currently offering to buy this game for £42 on both platforms



Serious ! I've got 7 copies on the way :-D

Original Poster

ridgerama;8647913

u say there's is a LOT of difference :roll:



I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics department. Anyone with good eyesight can notice that the 360 version has much more sharper and crisp graphics who else agrees with me??;-)

DEALofaLifetime;8648477

I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics … I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics department. Anyone with good eyesight can notice that the 360 version is much more sharper and crisp graphics who else agrees with me??;-)


meee!

You'll only notice when comparing not playing

DEALofaLifetime;8648477

I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics … I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics department. Anyone with good eyesight can notice that the 360 version has much more sharper and crisp graphics who else agrees with me??;-)



oh right so its a competition then which console has rdr looking the best wins , the difference is slight even if u think its massive . if anyone has both consoles they should buy it for the console that the majority of friends play with . ps3 also has exclusive dlc aswell incase ppl didnt know

Original Poster

ridgerama;8648953

oh right so its a competition then which console has rdr looking the best … oh right so its a competition then which console has rdr looking the best wins , the difference is slight even if u think its massive . if anyone has both consoles they should buy it for the console that the majority of friends play with . ps3 also has exclusive dlc aswell incase ppl didnt know



riight;-) whatever rings your bell:p

will still pick it up for the ps3 regardless of this, play on it more than i play on my 360 and im not overly fussed by the difference in picture quality so long as it plays the same as the 360 version

Peterdj41;8649334

will still pick it up for the ps3 regardless of this, play on it more … will still pick it up for the ps3 regardless of this, play on it more than i play on my 360 and im not overly fussed by the difference in picture quality so long as it plays the same as the 360 version



Yeah me too. I used to prefer my Xbox over my PS3 by a long way, but now it is the other way round. The small difference in picture is exactly that. Although a few months back i would have thought differently, we all know the ps3 is the better console in the long run

Once again R* have shafted the loyal PS3 gamer!!!
There is quite a difference if u have a good eye for it. It's GTA5 and Beyonetta all over again..
But I will still be playing it on the PS3. It is the better console and when devs can understand how to develope for the the ps3 first then sub it to the xbox, rather than the other way round things will start looking more magical!
At the end of the day PS3's have been outselling xbox's for a very long time now and by a huge margin.. It was the the huge year gap that gave Micro$oft the huge 8mil head start.

Imagine also the RRoD rate for xbox consoles over the years? How many people over the world have brought a new system twice, three times or maybe four as I heard one person say?
;-)

As a PC user I must admit both these look very good. Although the picture looks noticeably different between the two. The PS3 appears to have way too much AA, almost purposely turned up to the point it forces everything to lose detail. Whereas the 360 screens appear to have no AA at all causing jaggies but retaining much clearer detail.

I think it would be a matter of ones opinion which you would prefer. Neither to me look right though, they could of easily got the AA right on both and the difference would be barely noticeable. It sure looks to me though as if this was done on purpose.

Banned

DEALofaLifetime;8648477

I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics … I think the 360 has the ps3 beaten on this one im afraid in the graphics department. Anyone with good eyesight can notice that the 360 version has much more sharper and crisp graphics who else agrees with me??;-)


seriously, how old are you? :roll:

PhearFactor;8649805

As a PC user I must admit both these look very good. Although the picture … As a PC user I must admit both these look very good. Although the picture looks noticeably different between the two. The PS3 appears to have way too much AA, almost purposely turned up to the point it forces everything to lose detail. Whereas the 360 screens appear to have no AA at all causing jaggies but retaining much clearer detail.I think it would be a matter of ones opinion which you would prefer. Neither to me look right though, they could of easily got the AA right on both and the difference would be barely noticeable. It sure looks to me though as if this was done on purpose.


I actually prefer the ps3 graphics as jaggies in the 360 version dont look right at all but your point is well made and as mentioned previously, I doubt anyone would notice any difference at all in actual gameplay.

i watched my recording of 3:10 to Yuma (from Sunday) last night, almost every ad break had the RDR trailer, lol

Original Poster

csiman;8649834

seriously, how old are you? :roll:I actually prefer the ps3 graphics as … seriously, how old are you? :roll:I actually prefer the ps3 graphics as jaggies in the 360 version dont look right at all but your point is well made and as mentioned previously, I doubt anyone would notice any difference at all in actual gameplay.



Im not trying to start a fanboy war, but you have to admit lots of ps3 owners and buyers of this game must be a little dissapointed knowing that the 360 has the better graphics on RDR!!
Damn you R* :x

Djnino;8649788

Once again R* have shafted the loyal PS3 gamer!!!There is quite a … Once again R* have shafted the loyal PS3 gamer!!!There is quite a difference if u have a good eye for it. It's GTA5 and Beyonetta all over again..But I will still be playing it on the PS3. It is the better console and when devs can understand how to develope for the the ps3 first then sub it to the xbox, rather than the other way round things will start looking more magical! :)At the end of the day PS3's have been outselling xbox's for a very long time now and by a huge margin.. It was the the huge year gap that gave Micro$oft the huge 8mil head start.Imagine also the RRoD rate for xbox consoles over the years? How many people over the world have brought a new system twice, three times or maybe four as I heard one person say? ;-)



Oh dear lord... :roll:

DEALofaLifetime;8651655

Im not trying to start a fanboy war, but you have to admit lots of ps3 … Im not trying to start a fanboy war, but you have to admit lots of ps3 owners and buyer of this game must be a little dissapointed knowing that the 360 has the better graphics on RDR!! Damn you R* :x



Most people have both consoles by now, as someone said earlier buy it on the format that most of your online friends have it on (if you play online) or go with most comfortable controller...

Banned

Djnino;8649788

Once again R* have shafted the loyal PS3 gamer!!!There is quite a … Once again R* have shafted the loyal PS3 gamer!!!There is quite a difference if u have a good eye for it. It's GTA5 and Beyonetta all over again..But I will still be playing it on the PS3. It is the better console and when devs can understand how to develope for the the ps3 first then sub it to the xbox, rather than the other way round things will start looking more magical! :)At the end of the day PS3's have been outselling xbox's for a very long time now and by a huge margin.. It was the the huge year gap that gave Micro$oft the huge 8mil head start.Imagine also the RRoD rate for xbox consoles over the years? How many people over the world have brought a new system twice, three times or maybe four as I heard one person say? ;-)



Worldwide sales

1. Wii – 70.78 million, as of 10 May 2010[30]
2. Xbox 360 – 42 million, as of 1 January 2010[31]
3. PlayStation 3 – 37.5 million, as of 10 May 2010[32]

United Kingdom sales figures
Based on figures from GfK Chart-Track, as of 3 January 2009:[35]
Wii – 4.9 million
Xbox 360 – 3.2 million
PlayStation 3 - 1.9 million

United States sales figures
Based on figures from the NPD Group, as of 1 November 2008
Wii – 13.4 million
Xbox 360 – 11.6 million
PlayStation 3 - 5.2 million

Japan sales figures
Based on figures from Famitsu/Enterbrain, as of 17 December 2009
Wii – 9,048,012
PlayStation 3 – 4,020,563
Xbox 360 – 900,000 (as of 2/20/2009)

1. You do not live in Japan
2. The sales figures are based on each year, not overall
3. RROD is only found on older consoles and rarely new ones YLOD occurs quite frequently even on new consoles
4. The horrible menu's, controller and online make a PS3 the inferior console

ryman1000;8651990

Worldwide sales1. Wii – 70.78 million, as of 10 May 2010[30]2. Xbox 360 – … Worldwide sales1. Wii – 70.78 million, as of 10 May 2010[30]2. Xbox 360 – 42 million, as of 1 January 2010[31]3. PlayStation 3 – 37.5 million, as of 10 May 2010[32]United Kingdom sales figuresBased on figures from GfK Chart-Track, as of 3 January 2009:[35]Wii – 4.9 millionXbox 360 – 3.2 millionPlayStation 3 - 1.9 millionUnited States sales figuresBased on figures from the NPD Group, as of 1 November 2008Wii – 13.4 millionXbox 360 – 11.6 millionPlayStation 3 - 5.2 millionJapan sales figuresBased on figures from Famitsu/Enterbrain, as of 17 December 2009Wii – 9,048,012PlayStation 3 – 4,020,563Xbox 360 – 900,000 (as of 2/20/2009)1. You do not live in Japan2. The sales figures are based on each year, not overall3. RROD is only found on older consoles and rarely new ones YLOD occurs quite frequently even on new consoles4. The horrible menu's, controller and online make a PS3 the inferior console



That's not as of 10 may. I'd say its end of 2009.
Post a comment
Avatar
@
    Text
    Top Discussions
    1. Misco about to go into administration1014
    2. Free escape route from TalkMobile to Vodafone11
    3. Without giving away your age, name three things that remind you of when you…1834
    4. The HUKD home for Star Trek: Discovery2687

    See more discussions