Groups

    Who killed Archie Mitchell?

    below.

    54 Comments

    Original Poster

    Starting a Whodunnit? and see if anyone can get it right, below i am going to show some candidates on who it could be and there motives and why i think this

    First off:
    Phil - Not leaving and too has an obvious motive, but i think it is too obvious.

    Jack - Shown threatening Archie on Xmas Eve or Day because Archie threatened Ronnie and pushed her and put her in hospital, losing her baby. Wants revenge

    Billy - because Archie and Janine have taken him for a mug again by buying his silence, now Archie has what he wants he may withdraw the offer of his house for Billy and then he would lose access to his kids....

    Sam She returns at Xmas, had time to think about it all and realise what Archie was up to when he gave her the dosh to do a runner....also shes wanted in connection with dens murder, so whats another wee murder to her...

    Glenda Thought she was still married to Archie so killed him to get his money... but wasn't still married...

    Danny Did it for Glenda maybe?

    Ben - It's always the quiet ones remember.......

    Now... here's the intresting ones...

    Bradley - Leaving in Februrary, just got back together with Stacey, rumour is that Archie raped Stacey in the laudrette: youtube.com/wat…NLc (0:40). Also in the Xmas Eastenders promo, Bradley says "who did this to you Stace". Maybe he takes revenge on Archie and does this to him, this would be my top candidate....

    Stacey - For the reason that is above, maybe she did it herself.

    Janine should be on that list. She's my favourite to 'do it'.

    Original Poster

    Penny Saver;7290836

    Janine should be on that list. She's my favourite to 'do it'.



    Oh yes, forgot about her....

    Billy?

    Original Poster

    jeany123;7290854

    Billy?



    Why would he do it though.... would put on the list, but can't work out why he would do it

    borolad94

    motif



    I assume you're going for motive there

    you are forgetting about ryan-he is a deffo suspect.

    You've so got the wrong motive for Janine. She knows/thinks Archie's changed his will. He probably did, because he knew she'd check it out. Now she knows he really loves Peggy, or at least doesn't intend to actually marry Janine herself. She'll kill him to get his fortune (inc the vic perhaps?) before he either has a chance to change his will again, or stop his divorce.

    Original Poster

    Penny Saver;7290901

    You've so got the wrong motive for Janine. She knows/thinks Archie's … You've so got the wrong motive for Janine. She knows/thinks Archie's changed his will. He probably did, because he knew she'd check it out. Now she knows he really loves Peggy, or at least doesn't intend to actually marry Janine herself. She'll kill him to get his fortune (inc the vic perhaps?) before he either has a chance to change his will again, or stop his divorce.



    word for word in the list of suspects now :thumbsup:

    Original Poster

    barky;7290894

    you are forgetting about ryan-he is a deffo suspect.



    give me a motive and i will put it up :thumbsup:

    Billy is a possibility because Archie and Janine have taken him for a mug again by buying his silence, now Archie has what he wants he may withdraw the offer of his house for Billy and then he would lose access to his kids....

    borolad94;7290863

    Why would he do it though.... would put on the list, but can't work out … Why would he do it though.... would put on the list, but can't work out why he would do it



    He might push him too far this time

    borolad94;7290926

    give me a motive and i will put it up :thumbsup:



    because he thinks there is money to be had from the scheme to get the queen vic-janine will not give him his share,will say she did it all herself despite his help-plus he is secretly in love with her despite all his protestations to the contrary.

    anniemickymoo;7290942

    Billy is a possibility because Archie and Janine have taken him for a mug … Billy is a possibility because Archie and Janine have taken him for a mug again by buying his silence, now Archie has what he wants he may withdraw the offer of his house for Billy and then he would lose access to his kids....



    +1

    Of course, they could suprise us all and actually go for someone really obvious for a change.

    I read in a mag front page "Grant is back to kill Archie" .

    However no confirmation that Ross Kemp will be appearing but they can probably get around this.

    mmm...what about throwing Sam into the mix...she could be missing her family, had time to think about it all and realise what Archie was up to when he gave her the dosh to do a runner....also shes wanted in connection with dens murder, so whats another wee murder to her...

    Original Poster

    lola;7291107

    mmm...what about throwing Sam into the mix...she could be missing her … mmm...what about throwing Sam into the mix...she could be missing her family, had time to think about it all and realise what Archie was up to when he gave her the dosh to do a runner....also shes wanted in connection with dens murder, so whats another wee murder to her...



    Sam does return??? So... i'll put that one up there tooo

    Original Poster

    tonights ep.

    Out in the Square, Janine counts down to the grand switch on of the Christmas tree lights, while Jane mentions to a distracted Christian that she's concerned about Ian having sold the Mitchells' loan to Archie. In The Vic, meanwhile, Peggy's outraged at the family's situation and proclaims that they should never have trusted Ian in the first place. Roxy, however, immediately jumps to Archie's defence and blames Peggy for signing the divorce papers - she now has no claim on any of Archie's estate. In an attempt to calm the situation, Ronnie reminds everyone that Archie owns The Vic on paper - and without a possession order, his ownership is theoretical. The Mitchell sisters argue over potential ways in which to deal with their father and when Roxy suggests mediation, Ronnie reminds Roxy that they can't trust him in the slightest.

    Later, Archie turns up at The Vic and sits around a table with his daughters in an attempt to mediate. They all agree that they'll at least attempt to maintain the peace over Christmas but when Janine arrives, Ronnie makes her feelings explicitly clear - Janine's no part of the Mitchell family. Furious by Ronnie's harsh words, Archie expresses his disappointment, before storming out of the pub. With Archie gone, Janine cruelly reveals to Ronnie and Roxy that Billy knew about their plan to seize The Vic. With that, Ronnie lunges at Janine and throws her out, while Roxy agrees with her sister - it's all-out war.

    Meanwhile, Ian tells Ben that selling the Mitchells' loan to Archie was nothing personal. Ben, however, suggests that Ian buy it back and Jane agrees. Distraught over Ian's actions, Jane confides in Christian about her husband's stupidity. During their conversation, Christian unwitting reveals that he's met someone and has been having a relationship with them for a number of months. Later in the Square, Jane spots Christian staring up at Syed's bedroom window and she suddenly realises that Syed is the man that her brother's in love with.

    Dot Cotton did it :thumbsup:


    she speared him with a giant fag



    hang on isnt that another xmas storyline:whistling:

    didnt know that archie raped poor stacey, may have been what tipped her over the edge poor lass

    Banned

    ilovepink;7293073

    didnt know that archie raped poor stacey, may have been what tipped her … didnt know that archie raped poor stacey, may have been what tipped her over the edge poor lass



    It's not real:?

    It's not even well-written.

    Original Poster

    ilovepink;7293073

    didnt know that archie raped poor stacey, may have been what tipped her … didnt know that archie raped poor stacey, may have been what tipped her over the edge poor lass



    well its just a rumour.... we'll just have to wait and see....

    Original Poster

    Anybody got stronger suspicions? I think Sam or Bradley.....

    borolad94;7335046

    Anybody got stronger suspicions? I think Sam or Bradley.....



    I had to sit through this bile yesterday, and have been infomred its on tonight. Its eating into my xbox time!

    Ian did it!

    Original Poster

    leecroot;7335062

    I had to sit through this bile yesterday, and have been infomred its on … I had to sit through this bile yesterday, and have been infomred its on tonight. Its eating into my xbox time!Ian did it!



    Do you think its Ian because he's the only name you know? :lol:

    Banned

    I think it's Sam or the little boy phills son ---

    Sam as she said she is going to prove herself a mitchell or the kid as he's not as stupid as he looks

    Original Poster

    Anyone agree to rule out Ronnie, Roxy, Peggy and Janine?

    Rule out anyone who hasn't got any upper body strength to lift that Vicky bust over Archie's head lol

    bradley here

    why....

    coz
    love is a strong emotion just like hate. He loves Stacey deeply, and for what Archie did to her i can see him having enough hate inside him to do it

    its not Ian hes the biggest wimp going he cant stand up to phil, yet alone commit murder

    Original Poster

    ilovepink;7335650

    bradley herewhy....cozlove is a strong emotion just like hate. He loves … bradley herewhy....cozlove is a strong emotion just like hate. He loves Stacey deeply, and for what Archie did to her i can see him having enough hate inside him to do it



    Yeo, i think Bradley too....

    LOL just watched last nights ep on iplayer

    archies death reminded me of last episode of blackadder goes forth with slow music and slow mo haha

    as for who killed him

    staceys mum

    just cos shes mental and she probs gone off on a rage cos she fuelled up on some schitzo drugs

    I think it was Bradley tbh, He just looked so guilty in tonights episode. Plus we all know hes due to leave so could he be leaving for jail ?

    Ian, Ben or a female suspect, phil would not have hit him from behind like that, neither would grant if he did does return. No sure about bradley????

    well I'm going to go for david beckham. the bbc will soon be wheeling out all the stops to promote englands bid to retain the world cup so what better way than have beckam doing keepy ups in the vic with minty and accidently hitting that statue on top of archie.

    Original Poster

    Took off Janine, Peggy, Ronnie and Ryan now... Far to shocked when hearing about the death for it too be them

    Definately Peggy, she's retiring next year so would be well timed.

    loulou11;7344770

    Definately Peggy, she's retiring next year so would be well timed.



    or sam, already wanted by cops, and leaving show so would tie in, bradley also leaving

    how about shaun (staceys brother)?
    Post a comment
    Avatar
    @
      Text
      Top Discussions
      1. Royal Mail chat says I am not allowed to send paper of any kind to Hong Kon…2368
      2. Shana Tova to all Jewish HUKDers1826
      3. 75% off Sky TV for existing customers. Only works when you call the specifi…17826369
      4. HUKD Satellite Information & IPTV Thread48710950

      See more discussions