I haven't seen the Quest for Eldorado but Shut Up and Sit Down are usually on the money with their great reviews. 3 of us Vs 3 random monsters in Horrified often ends in tragedy. Best thing is it's co-op so no fights and everyone gets to blame the monsters at the end if we lose. ;)
Ditto, my OH hates pandemic (lol) I find Horrified surprisingly difficult at times, the invisible Man can do one. We've played so many Marvel Champions games I have dreams about being Doctor Strange at this point. Have you seen the Quest for El Dorado? I liked the look of it on the shut up sit down review. Will order villainous tonight, TY for the share OP, good find! *Edited because I can't spell with a two year old using me as a climbing frame.
Jaws is good but it is 1 player vs 1 to 3 players. One as the shark has to sneak about eating folk the rest are hunting it. It plays well and builds tension. Who ever is the shark needs to be able to bluff a bit, we have one person that is incapable of keeping a poker face. The games aren't too long either. We've played it as a group of 3 and enjoyed it. The theme works well but Horrified co-op is still best of the three in my opinion and replaced Pandemic during the pandemic.
*Love* Horrified, haven't actually played Jaws yet, is it any good?